The momentum behind femtocells continues to mount, and membership of Femto Forum – the industry body backing the miniature indoor base stations – now stands at 58. New joiners include Cisco, Huawei, Samsung, Vodafone, BT and even the ambivalent Ericsson, whose traditional high margin macro station model could be under threat in some markets from this new approach to RAN building (see separate item on LTE). One of the key challenges for the femtocell community is that methods of integrating the devices into the core network remain fragmented and sometimes proprietary. This is a real concern for operators looking for full interoperability and with this in mind, the Femto Forum has kicked off the process of creating a common framework.
At the Forum’s next plenary meeting in March, it will consider proposals from various members and, based on these submissions, will develop a framework to support interoperability, and which will then be advanced to relevant standards bodies such as 3GPP, whose own Home Node B (femtocell) initiative is at the feasibility study stage, and should be adopted as a work item in March. Forum chair Simon Saunders said a reference architecture for core integration has already been agreed upon, to provide a consistent basis for comparing the proposals. The Forum has identified 15 different femtocell architectures, which span all air interfaces including CDMA, GSM, W-CDMA, and WiMAX.
New members of the Femto Forum:
‘ Cisco, which recently invested in ip.access
‘ Ericsson, which says it will have a product for W-CDMA in 2009, the point at which it sees the market being ready
‘ Session border controller vendor Acme Packet
‘ Enterprise fixed/mobile convergence company NewStep Networks
‘ Operators BT, Mobilkom Austria, SaskTel of Canada, Softbank of Japan, Cellcom Israel, Telecom Italia and Vodafone, all of which have femto trials at various stages
‘ Huawei
‘ Samsung
‘ NXP Semiconductors, bringing an important second silicon vendor to the party, in addition to picoChip
‘ Genband
‘ KTL
‘ AudioCodes
Picocells:
With all the fuss around femtocells, their more established bigger siblings, GSM picocells, are often overlooked, though picocell designs are gaining new interest now from operators, often for indoor coverage in enterprises or large premises such as shopping malls. TeliaSonera has launched a GSM picocell indoor coverage service for business users in Denmark, based on equipment from ip.access, and claims the emergence of low cost IP backhaul options, as opposed to leased lines, have made the economics work out for the first time.
Paul-Flemming Hermann, in-building expert at TeliaSonera, told Unstrung: “In some cases, we couldn’t help customers because the revenue they provided us wouldn’t pay for the in-building solution. Ten years ago, picocells were present, but you needed the leased lines, and that did not make a business case.’
Orange also recently launched a picocell offering, called OnSite Coverage, for which it charges a monthly rental fee for the cell (TeliaSonera bundles the cost of the device).
Orange offers OnSite currently in Switzerland and the UK, and the service will also be rolled out in France, Spain, and Poland, using products made by RadioFrame and sold by Nokia Siemens.
While NSN has turned to RadioFrame for picocells, it is spreading its favors in 3G femtocells for the residential market, and has just signed a joint sales and marketing agreement with UK-based Ubiquisys for its ZoneGate femtocell. This runs W-CDMA and conforms to NSN’s Femto Gateway open architecture.
In another 3G deal, Airvana is to provide its UMTS femtocells to Thomson for use with the French consumer electronics company’s residential gateways. This highlights what will become a common combination, and echoes similar agreements by Ubiquisys with NEC and Netgear. Thomson’s Premises Systems business unit already has its own agreement with NSN for femto-based home access.