Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

12 February 2008

MWC: Sarin calls for LTE-WiMAX convergence as China Mobile signs for LTE

Vodafone CEO Arun Sarin generally manages to grab the headlines at the big events, and uses the stage expertly to stir things up among the vendors. This year’s Mobile World Congress was no exception, with the executive calling for a convergence of the Mobile WiMAX and LTE standards, and for a dramatic cut in the number of handset operating systems.

Neither idea is new ‘ the WiMAX Forum and 3GPP have held various talks over the years about some measure of harmonization of their increasingly similar looking platforms, with politics rather than technology standing in the way; and Vodafone has already been a prime mover in pushing phonemakers to reduce the number of OS choices, committing itself to supporting just five. However, Sarin still managed to cause a stir, and a wave of speculation that LTE and WiMAX would, indeed, get closer.

“I think LTE has made real improvements in the last twelve months, and I would say WiMAX has made some progress as well,” Sarin said. “The issue for me is simply resources in our industry: We only have a finite number of R&D engineers and we split them into three camps, then we would be diluting what we can do in the future. LTE standard is an encompassing standard, an accommodating standard ‘ and ‘ there is a TBD section that I think WiMAX could fit into.”

“We have to narrow the range of operating systems,” Sarin said. “We have 30 or 40 operating systems right now. If we had three or five operating systems, then that would be a good thing. Let the marketplace decide whether its Symbian, Microsoft, Android, LiMo or Linux 3.0 or whatever it is. But we cannot have 30 of these.” He urged fellow carriers not to buy phones that would have unsupported operating systems in five years’ time.

All this highlights some key Vodafone objectives, shared with most large cellcos ‘ to reduce costs by backing a few, highly standardized technologies, generating competition among suppliers and creating purchasing economies; and ensuring these technologies follow an operator driven agenda.

LTE is clearly the heart of the harmonized Vodafone/Verizon 4G roadmap, but WiMAX still represents a threat, in that it could well be used as a tool by non-cellcos looking to come into Vodafone’s markets. Incorporating it into the LTE platform, and the 3GPP processes in which the large mobile operators are highly influential, would do much to neutralize its disruptive power.

Meanwhile, the momentum behind the nascent LTE increased with the addition of China Mobile to the Vodafone/Verizon trial programme. The largest cellco in the world by numbers of subscribers joined the largest by revenue in a plan to trial FDD and TDD variants of LTE. China Mobile will bring considerable experience on the TDD side, since this version of LTE will be an evolution of the Chinese TD-SCDMA standard.

The group trials will be focused on ensuring the interoperability of different LTE systems in various frequencies, and will “provide an opportunity to adopt a harmonized access platform with global scale’.

“Verizon looks upon LTE as a singular opportunity to align wireless carriers on a 4G technology which will support the desires of customers to have a common experience, with any device of their choosing, anywhere in the world,” said Richard Lynch, Verizon’s CTO, in a statement, adding that he looks forward to “planning compatible networks” with China Mobile and Vodafone. This just reinforces the line taken by Sarin, that harmonization of different platforms will be in the interest of the cellcos.

China Mobile is already a member of the LTE/SAE (systems architecture evolution) Trial Initiative, a group of 18 operators, vendors and handset makers that is working on speeding LTE development and last week showed the technology running at 300MBps in a demonstration. Its early interest in LTE raised speculation that some Chinese operators may skip 3G altogether and go straight to LTE, in order to leapfrog other economies in mobile broadband and move beyond the repeated delays and performance hitches in Chinese 3G.