Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

4 March 2008

Simply Everything shows Sprint still has vision, but dismal Q4 drains confidence

Sprint Nextel has been a story of strong vision and terrible execution since its merger, and amid the announcement of dismal fourth quarter results, the operator was still demonstrating sparks of brilliance in its appreciation of how the mobile internet market needs to develop.

Sprint’s stock plummeted after the operator reported a $29.5bn loss in the fourth quarter due to a writedown of the value of Nextel, which Sprint acquired in 2005. Sprint Nextel’s stock was down 10.4% to $8.02 on the news. As it had to do, it responded to the flat rate plans of its three major rivals (see Wireless Watch February 26 2008) with a far broader offering, called Simply Everything, which encompasses full data services and, in future, the Xohm WiMAX-based mobile broadband offering, and provides what CEO Dan Hesse described as ‘a stepping stone toward the fourth generation, a long way off for most carriers but just around the corner for Sprint’. There is some justice in what he said ‘ if Sprint sticks to its guns on Xohm build-out, it will have a 4G headstart on Verizon’s and AT&T’s LTE programs, but more importantly, it has grasped that 4G business models will rely on clever pricing, access and bundling plans as much as on services and performance. For all this forward thinking, however, Sprint’s finances get worse, forcing it to calm investor nerves by defocusing on new services and concentrating on CDMA, and raising real doubts over whether it will ever be in a position to execute on its 4G vision.

The greatest asset Sprint Nextel has, now it has succeeded in wrecking the once impressive margins and services of iDEN, is Xohm, with its opportunity to leapfrog other operators into true mobile broadband services and business models, and with its 100MHz of high value spectrum. Yet Hesse was forced, in the results announcement, almost to apologize for Xohm, even while he said he was ‘extremely encouraged’ by the soft launches in Baltimore, Washington DC and Chicago, talked up the value of the spectrum, and hinted that a deal with Clearwire was still on the cards. ‘We have had wide ranging discussions with Clearwire on potential relationships but no final agreements have been reached,’ was all he could reveal. But while a healthier carrier ‘ or even a non-carrier like Google ‘ would be praising Xohm and its open access model to the skies, Sprint is forced to reassure shareholders by playing it down and addressing the more difficult issue of how to operate its CDMA business more effectively. ‘I want to leave you with no doubt that our first priority is our core business, which is where our people and our capital are focused without distraction,’ soothed Hesse.

He knows that without some improvement in the immediate business, there will be little opportunity to exploit Xohm for Sprint’s advantage, rather than selling it off, losing control and at least some of the spectrum asset, in return for (probably) just the rights to use someone else’s network. A joint venture with Clearwire and partners such as Intel remains a far more attractive option, but again will need Hesse to convince investors that there is a real future in Xohm, and that this effort can realistically be supported by an improvement in CDMA. The prospects are not looking rosy. ‘Our business is not performing well right now. Because we have not provided the right customer experience, customers are leaving us. We are working aggressively to turn this around, but our financial performance will not improve overnight,’ summarized Hesse with depressing clarity. He set two overriding goals ‘ reducing churn and establishing a clear brand position with well understood differentiation that appeals to high value customers.

Simply Everything is firmly aimed at addressing these two issues, as well as, longer term, providing a bridge between CDMA and Xohm services and pricing models. Hesse claims the new plan will appeal primarily to high value customers, the ones Sprint has been losing most damagingly, and will give these people ‘a reason for choosing and staying with Sprint. For the first time, your wireless device can be your only device as we bring unprecedented simplicity and utility to the Swiss army knife phones of today. And later this year we plan to introduce dual-mode CDMA/WiMAX devices that will turbocharge the customer experience.’

Simply Everything offers unlimited voice and data access, including SMS, mobile TV, email and push to talk, for $100 a month (rival carriers are mainly offering just voice and basic data/text for this price). And by making the unavoidable move of trumping the other national cellcos by including unlimited data in its flat rate plan, Sprint has also taken on the huge risk of having to support a network that can cope with potentially crippling levels of usage, for no additional ARPU ‘ forcing the operator into the dangerous dilemma of increasing capex to upgrade the network’s capacity and efficiency, or delivering a sub-standard user experience (the main problem at Sprint already, especially for the once super-loyal Nextel subscribers, whose experience has now been greatly degraded). This is another reason why it is essential that Sprint hangs on to Xohm, or at least leading rights to use its network, since 100MHz of spectrum with an efficient modern IP network built in it will considerably ease the pressure of unlimited data usage on the infrastructure. While it waits for Xohm ‘ or worse, lets go of it ‘ Sprint will have to think of ways to address possible overburdening of its current network. The most common is the one that Verizon Wireless adopted this week, when it admitted there was a cap on data usage in its flat rate monthly data plans (50Mb a month on the $39.99 plan or 5Gb on the $59.99 plan). Verizon learned the lesson of being too enthusiastic about unfettered access when its network was compromised by its original BroadbandAccess offer, now moderated by the data caps.

Meanwhile, Simply Everything does not look nearly enough to restore confidence in Sprint’s ability to bounce back from its string of disastrous results. The operator’s forecast that it will make EBITDA of $1.8bn-$1.9bn in the current first quarter disappointed Wall Street, which had been looking for $2.6bn, and this suggests that for the full year, EBITDA might be only $8bn, rather than the current conservative Wall Street prediction of $8.9bn.

The company reported it had lost 683,000 subscribers in the fourth quarter and warned analysts it expects to lose another 1.2m customers in the current quarter, far more than the 800,000 Wall Street had forecast. Prepaid and wholesale channels were the only areas where the company was experiencing growth. In the fourth quarter, ARPU fell by 3.9% (1% in CDMA and 7% in iDEN) and this trend is also likely to continue in the current quarter. Revenue was $9.85bn ($8.5bn from wireless), lower than analyst estimates of $9.9bn and 6% down on the previous year’s Q4. The carrier had 35m CDMA subscribers at the end of 2007, 17.3m iDEN subscribers and 1.4m PowerSource subscribers who access both platforms.

Fourth quarter postpaid churn was 2.3%, the same as the third quarter for both iDEN and CDMA. Postpaid ARPU was $58, down from $59 in the third quarter. Data contributed more than $11 to postpaid ARPU. On the CDMA base, data ARPU was $14, an increase of 21 percent. Data now accounts for 20% of total ARPU.

Qwest:

Qwest CEO Ed Mueller told analysts that the company’s MVNO deal with Sprint is not producing enough profit so it is looking elsewhere to fill its wireless “hole’. “We have a hole in wireless. It’s sad to be up here saying this, trust me,” Mueller told the analysts.

He said that Qwest was not going to buy spectrum because it “can’t go this alone’, and is expected to do a deal with Verizon Wireless.