Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

4 March 2008

Emobile will be catalyst for further price wars in Japan

Last week the headlines were full of the US cellcos’ race to flat rate, unlimited voice pricing, and now the virus is spreading to the world’s most saturated mobile market, Japan. It is legendarily hard to thrive in this country, where Vodafone has already failed and even leader DoCoMo is suffering from the combination of price competition and a hugely demanding consumer base. This has not deterred Sachio Semmoto, founder of Japan’s second cellco KDDI, which is now launching an MVNO called Emobile, which aims to shake up the sector by offering flat rate pricing and no monthly subscription charges.

The main stakeholders in Emobile are broadband ISP eAccess, with 37.6%, and Goldman Sachs, with 35.7%, while Temasek is also a backer. Although the would-be disruptive provider is initially relying on an MVNO deal with DoCoMo, it will be freer to push new models once it completes its own HSPA network, planned to be live by October 2010. At this point, it is also likely to be supporting a converged quad play offering for eAccess, which would also be a challenge to the big two carriers.

In the first phase, Emobile aims to take on these two players and Softbank with its innovative pricing schemes. Launching on March 28, its customers will pay ’18 for every 30 seconds of call time, and it will also offer unlimited calling packages for ‘980 a month, matching Softbank’s offer. Softbank – which owns the former Vodafone KK and is also developing a converged internet play leveraging its majority ownership of Yahoo Japan ‘ was previously the most disruptive cellco in Japan, setting the cat among the pigeons late last year when it slashed its call prices and monthly charges. Last week, KDDI responded with a package that offers free calls between family members, emulating the type of ‘friends and family’ deals that have been popular in the US and some parts of Europe (like T-Mobile’s MyFaves). Emobile will initially use handsets from HTC and Toshiba.

Emobile’s chances of gaining major share in Japan seem slim, given the intense competition in the market and the agility of DoCoMo and KDDI, which are already introducing innovative services such as mobile payments integrated with other web applications, and planning for their 4G networks. However, Emobile may well prove the catalyst for a further round of painful blood-letting in the country. Already, DoCoMo has followed the launch of its MVNO partner, and the price cuts of its nearest two rivals, with its own reduced rate pricing plans and family circle schemes ‘ plans that it says will cut its revenues in its next financial year, starting on April 1, by ’80bn ($752m).

This loss will be partially offset by increases in monthly charges for its mobile internet service, i-Mode, which could add ’50bn to revenues for the year. The ability of DoCoMo to balance price cuts with increased ARPU from advanced services is a valuable cushion for now, although it puts the cellco under intense pressure to increase capex and accelerate its web services and 4G roll-outs to stay ahead of the game. This is something Emobile, however well funded, will not have the luxury of doing, and even if it sticks to its HSPA deadline of 2010 ‘ when its MVNO deal with DoCoMo expires ‘ its larger rivals will by then have 4G-class services in place. The big two will focus as heavily as possible on high margin, advanced offerings in order to remain differentiated from low cost players ‘ and this is something in which DoCoMo, in particular, has a strong track record with i-Mode, its FOMA 3G network and other innovations. However, DoCoMo, despite still having 53% of the customer base, is having to rely on cutting edge technology and service roll-outs, in a world where operators are increasingly needing to reduce capex and opex, and it has seen a wave of user defections since Japan introduced number portability in 2006. In the nine months to December, it added only 529,400 subscribers against KDDI’s 1.4m gain and 1.7m at Softbank, and DoCoMo reported an 8% fall in operating profit for the period.

As operators face declining revenues from voice calls, they are shifting towards an advertising-supported model for internet services, which will be highly disruptive for DoCoMo. Nearly 24% of Japanese users access the internet solely by mobile, and this is driving a move to ad-supported structures rather than subscription fees for content, a model that also reduces operator control of the customer.