Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

19 February 2008

Slim and Nawiris battle incumbents for place in wireless top 10

The Latin American mobile market is dominated by two giant operators, Mexico’s America Movil and Spain’s Telefonica, especially since BellSouth sold its own holdings in the region to the Spanish carrier in 2004. Now their battle is set to shift to Telefonica’s home territory, with America Movil, part of the Telmex empire controlled by Carlos Slim, in talks to buy a 76.5% stake in Spanish cellco Xfera from Scandinavian player TeliaSonera, whose own international ambitions are increasingly focused eastwards.

The reported talks took place at the Mobile World Congress in Barcelona last week, with America Movil’s chairman Daniel Hajj meeting TeliaSonera top directors. However, Johan Andsjo, CEO of Xfera (more commonly known by its brand name of Yoigo) denied the company was for sale. Xfera has struggled to gain share against Telefonica and Vodafone, and is targeting an increase from under 5% to 10% by 2015.

A takeover of Xfera by such an aggressive operator could make it a far more serious player in the Spanish market and would show America Movil hitting back against a recent alliance of Telefonica and another European carrier with significant Latin American presence, Telecom Italia (see Wireless Watch April 30 2007). America Movil operates in 16 countries in Latin America and the Caribbean, as well as in the US, and its mobile customers rose by 23% in 2007 to 153.4m. It owns Mexico’s biggest cellular company, Telcel, which has 36m subscribers and brings in about half of the company’s sales; and 98% of Telecom Americas in Brazil.

But Telefonica went head-to-head in the region in 2004 when it acquired the Latin American assets of BellSouth for $5.85bn. BellSouth’s activities had been in Argentina, Chile, Peru, Venezuela, Colombia, Ecuador, Uruguay, Guatemala, Nicaragua and Panama, and they gave Telefonica 40.5m additional mobile subscribers. Before the TIM deal, it had 74m subscribers in 13 Latin American countries and will now also add TIM Brasil’s 25.4m customers. TIM Brasil is the country’s second largest cellco out of eight players, and the country is already the second biggest revenue generator for Telefonica after Spain, bringing in 18.2% of the total in 2005 through fixed line, broadband and cellular services, operated under the brand Brasilcel.

Hajj recently said that he expected the rate of subscriber acquisition to slow significantly in 2008 compared to 2007, and that America Movil would gain 20m-21m new users this year, rather than over 28m in the prior year. This slowdown is because many Latin American markets are saturating and the operator’s M&A program in the region is being pulled back, and may explain why the company is now looking to steal share from Telefonica in other areas. With few acquisition opportunities left in the CALA region, America Movil has moved into a phase of organic expansion in the 17 countries where it operates, which helped boost profit margins from to 38.5% EBITDA in 2007.

However, it will be a tough job to boost the fortunes of Xfera/Yoigo in Spain, against the huge market weight of Telefonica and the other two multinationals at work in the country, Vodafone and Orange/Amena. Xfera suffered greatly from 3G delays and the disappointed expectations in that market. IN mid-2006 it was saved from having to give back its 3G license by TeliaSonera increasing its stake from 16% to almost 80%, and it was finally bailed out of likely collapse in late 2006 by Spanish cellco Yoigo. However, it has less than 2% market share in 3G, and limited coverage. However, America Movil’s deep pockets could help accelerate the roll-out and marketing of services, and even a shift to mobile broadband offerings to try to leapfrog Telefonica. Initially, a key target for both Latin American heavyweights will be roaming traffic and travellers between the region and Spain.

The last rapidly expanding international operator to take an interest in Xfera was Orascom of Egypt, which remains determined to create a mobile empire spanning the Mediterranean region and other parts of Africa and the Middle East. Although it backed away from the Spanish cellco, it is now putting itself firmly in the running to be a tier one global player, taking on Vodafone, Orange and the other established giants. It may even merge with one of these, hinted chairman Naguib Sawiris recently in an interview with the London Financial Times. He said that the major western operators need to accelerate their expansion in emerging markets in order to stay in the top 10 and that some might need to partner with Orascom. “These western incumbents do not have any choice but to try and partner with one of the emerging market players so they can keep their position,” he said. “If they don’t do that they are doomed to go out of the list.”

He denied any plans to sell the company but added: ‘I have always said that I think my exit will be one day joining one of these players. I believe that the consolidation is feasible and unavoidable long term.”

Vodafone and Orange have recently stepped up their activities in emerging markets, with Orange particularly focused on taking stakes in African operators and introducing WiMAX or cellular systems there. One emerging major that has sometimes been linked to Orange as a possible merger or joint venture partner is MTN, the largest wireless carrier in Africa.

Orascom’s market capitalization has increased from $340m in 2003 to $16bn today, and it recently acquired a 25-year license in one of the world’s last untapped markets, North Korea.