After 20 days of blind bidding, the US 700MHz auction had netted a record sum of $19.5bn yesterday, and now must be grinding to its conclusion,with the FCC running six rounds of bidding per day, but with ever decreasing activity in all five blocks of spectrum.
Bidding on the C-Block ‘ the most closely watched because its license is national and carries the open access requirements – appears to be largely over, with no new bids as recently and a $4.7bn haul so far. The D-Block, with its public safety obligations, will have to be reauctioned, since it has come nowhere near its reserve price and there has been minimal bidding, following the demise of the natural but underfunded winner, Frontline Wireless, even before the auctions started. In a reauction, which would probably carry less stringent requirements (though it would almost certainly have to retain some role in the national public safety communications plan), it is likely Verizon or AT&T would win, in their general desperation for more beachfront spectrum.
Now that the bidding has slowed to a drip, the main focus of remaining activity is on the E-Block mobile TV section, and the regional B-Block. E-Block licenses received $9.1m in new bids during the first three rounds on Wednesday, while B-Block licenses generated the most action, drawing 107 bids during rounds 88, 89 and 90; the E Block drew 105 bids. There are seven B-Block licenses yet to see a single bid ‘ in Bismarck, Grand Forks and Fargo, North Dakota, as well as in portions of Virginia, North and South Carolina and Louisiana.
In the E-Block, there are four likely outcomes, according to analyst Jamie Townsend at JPRG, and none of them is good news for Qualcomm, which already holds a swathe of 700MHz spectrum, from a previous auction, in which it runs its MediaFLO service. AT&T recently finalized its acquisition of the other major winner of that older 700MHz mobile TV auction, Aloha Partners. The four options, according to JPRG, are:
‘ Qualcomm wins but pays too much: 30% likelihood
o Prices in the auction have moved up to $0.70/pop/MHz and these seem like high prices relative to Qualcomm’s prior spectrum purchases, meaning the company is challenged to both purchase spectrum and build out the network. However, given Qualcomm’s improving financial resources and need to deploy cash this is the most favorable scenario for the chipmaker.
‘ AT&T wins and competes with MediaFLO by shutting it out: 40% likelihood
o This outcome ensures Qualcomm will not have sufficient spectrum to expand beyond its current eight channels and AT&T is likely to be a stronger contender.
‘ Verizon wins and dilutes Qualcomm: 20% likelihood
o In this scenario, Verizon wins and partners with Qualcomm to provide a highly competitive service. We see Verizon as having the upper hand in this partnership thus diluting Qualcomm’s profitability.
‘ Someone else wins and a new competitor surfaces: 10% likelihood
o While we believe the majors are the most likely bidders, we do not rule out Echostar or other independents from entering the market.
Bidding in the similar Block-A and Block-B (both 12MHz) started most aggressively and has resulted in some of the most expensive high bids. The upside surprise in the $19bn total for the auction is almost entirely a result of the bidding in these blocks. Prices in excess of $7/MHz/pop have been registered in such cities as Chicago, Seattle and Oklahoma City. Many other cities have seen prices in excess of $3/MHz/pop ‘ well above prices in the AWS auction or the other blocks in this auction. Once again, the most likely large bidders are Verizon and AT&T. Due to its historical proclivity for the regional blocks we suspect that AT&T may emerge with substantial portions of B-Block and possibly A-Block, although analysts at JPRG also speculate that some of the smaller regional carriers (Leap, US Cellular, MetroPCS and Alltel) may have got aggressive here and overpaid. It is also possible that satellite TV operator Echostar has been active here, although more likely it has already dropped out. There is also a possibility that Cablevision and Cox Communication may have won some regions that correspond to their operating bases, but likely overpaid too, with negative short term consequences.
Most observers had expected the most aggressive and highest prices to be in the C-Block but this did not happen, and auction rules prevent new bids. JPRG believes Google was the only bidder in the nationwide portion of block C, bidding up until it passed its reserve price of $4.64bn, thus triggering the open access mandate that was the search giant’s main objective in order to support its open mobile internet model. At that point, Google probably ceased bidding. In ensuing rounds it appears that one of the majors (Verizon or AT&T) began slowly repositioning their bidding units from Blocks A and B into the regional options of C-Block. This action was completed in the thirtieth round when the total of the regional bids was sufficient to exceed the $4.73bn nationwide bid from Google. With no subsequent bidding in the C-Block, it appears that the winner will emerge with the 22MHz at the very attractive price of $0.71/MHz/pop, and the money is on the victor being Verizon, which unlike AT&T has a history of avoiding the regional blocks, and which has been talking up its take on ‘open access’.