Under pressure on all fronts, Sprint Nextel has been forced to take the initiative in new pricing models, but in some cases is seeing its lead usurped by copycat actions by its larger rivals. Sprint was first among the majors to promise open access, on Xohm, but Verizon Wireless has received greater attention for its own less wholehearted open plans, even though it has certainly not yet embraced the Xohm support for flat rate charging regardless of the number of devices a user attaches to the network. Then last year saw Sprint being the first of the big four cellcos to trial unlimited, flat rate calling, responding to the growth of flat rate specialists Leap Wireless and MetroPCS. But the operator’s roll-out in selected markets does not look set to go nationwide, and is now overshadowed by the other three mobile majors’ ‘all you can dial’ packages.
Verizon Wireless kicked off, announcing a flat rate unlimited voice plan starting at $100 a month, cheaper than Sprint’s $120 base package, though this also includes unlimited text and picture messaging plus some web access and email (it is only available in the San Francisco Bay Area, upper central California, Minneapolis, Philadelphia and Tampa, Florida, and Sprint said last week there are no plans to extend this any time soon, despite CEO Dan Hesse dropping recent hints about unlimited calling).
Verizon’s new plan includes unlimited, anytime minutes to any caller in the US, regardless of network and including landline phones (most cellcos already offer unlimited calling plans if users stay within their networks). There are no domestic roaming or long distance fees and unlimited browsing is also permitted. The individual plans come in three levels – $100 for basic single line phones, $120 for unlimited messaging and $140 for V Cast, VZ Navigator and mobile email. Data sent and received, taxes and activation fees and international calls are extra.
Verizon may have hoped to have the unlimited calling market to itself for a while, but this was not to be. AT&T Mobility announced a virtually identical plan almost immediately, and then T-Mobile followed suit, though ‘ as a smaller challenger must do ‘ it sweetened the offer by throwing unlimited messaging into its basic $100 package, pushing its claim to be the lowest cost national carrier.
Smaller carriers also jumping on the bandwagon include MVNOs Boost Mobile (part of Sprint) and Helio, which enhanced their own unlimited offers earlier this month, plus Cellular South, which offers unlimited messaging and data at $80 for handsets or $100 for smartphones, and US Cellular, which introduced its own $100 plan. Alltel has not gone the whole hog to unlimited calls, but was talking up its popular MyCircle feature, which allows customers to call selected numbers without pulling from their monthly bucket of minutes (T-Mobile also offers this option, which it calls myFaves).
‘The introduction of unlimited voice and data wireless plans is the beginning of a fundamental shift in how wireless carriers are structuring their plans. We believe Verizon pre-emptively introduced its unlimited pricing plan due to speculation last week that Sprint was going to announce,’ analysts at Morgan Stanley wrote in a research note.
The rush towards unlimited calling shows the pressure the cellcos are under to fend off MetroPCS and other disruptive carriers, as well as to try to poach each other’s users and cash in on the trend towards the wireless handset becoming the subscriber’s primary phone. This has been gathering pace in the past two years, in contrast with 2002, when AT&T first tried an $100 unlimited calling plan, which it withdrew after only a few months following lack of interest. Now that the cellphone is in constant use, $100-plus packages look more attractive, especially to enterprise users. For instance, Verizon’s $99 plan offers 2,000 talk minutes, making it worthwhile for customers who spend more than 33 hours a month on their cellphones ‘ which is estimated to be 10-15% of users in the US, or 25-30m people. While stealing subscribers from other networks will be the key goal, even if just 10% of Verizon’s own user base converts to the new options, there would be a small positive effect on ARPU.
Apart from greater consumer demand, the other factor making unlimited calling more viable for operators now than a few years ago is the upgraded infrastructure. As the cellcos deploy UMTS/HSPA and CDMA EV-DO, they can take advantage of the spectral efficiency of these systems to deliver voice at lower cost ‘ at least until they have to adapt to the more network hungry VoIP. Once the cellcos may have hoped to turn these lower costs of delivery into higher margins, but at least in the more pressurized environment of 2008 they have the flexibility to be creative with pricing.
Success in winning a higher proportion of that 10-15% of power users, who are also likely to be heavy consumers of data and added value services, will affect ARPU and general performance well beyond the economics of voice calling, but of course, with three of the big four introducing similar plans, poaching each other’s most valuable subscribers will depend on further enhancements to the plans and bundles; on strong (and expensive) marketing, which Verizon has already initiated with a nationwide advertising campaign; and ‘ most efficiently for the business ‘ on stealing customers from smaller rivals and from the suffering Sprint. In particular, the big operators will be hoping to steal the thunder from Leap and MetroPCS, at a time when those flat rate operators are facing major expansion costs if they are to maintain growth.
Sprint Nextel, despite its apparent coyness, is almost certain to introduce some form of unlimited calling plan soon, or risk accelerating the exodus of subscribers from its network. Despite its operational challenges, Sprint is usually innovative around business models and Hesse may be brave enough to go a step further than his rivals and introduce a flat rate offer that includes significant amounts of data and media, not just browsing, something that could be supported by the relatively advanced state of its EV-DO build-out.