Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

26 February 2008

Wireless-only models are not just for emerging economies, as Telia shows

In emerging nations with limited wireline infrastructure, it will be common to see wireless networks being used even to deliver basic fixed access and telephony, but this trend is even apparent in rural areas of advanced economies, especially as low frequency spectrum starts to be opened up. In the US, the initial aim of groups lobbying the FCC over rulemaking for the 700MHz band was to see this spectrum ‘ highly attractive for large cells and sparse populations ‘ being harnessed to improve rural broadband access. This agenda has been somewhat hijacked by the open internet campaign and the needs of advanced applications, but in reality, we will see many of the WiMAX and cellular deployments in 700MHz being geared to rural coverage. In parts of Europe, similar considerations have put the 450MHz former analog spectrum into the the limelight, and TeliaSonera is showing off the potential for profitable rural business models by using this frequency to replace landlines in rural Finland.

The Scandinavian operator plans to migrate 53,000 rural customers to wireless networks from fixed lines. Initially this is purely a move to reduce costs, since users will just receive voice and basic data services via the existing GSM network. However, by the end of next year they will also receive broadband (though with a maximum rate of 1Mbps) over wireless, as TeliaSonera harnesses a 450MHz partner network, based on the Flash-OFDM system now owned by Qualcomm, and in future implements HSPA in its 900MHz GSM band too.

This is a pattern that is likely to be repeated elsewhere, with variations depending on the combination and amount of spectrum an operator holds in rural regions. Fixed lines can initially be replaced ‘ or at least, new build-out halted ‘ with a broadband wireless network in any readily available and low cost spectrum. Typically this will be WiMAX in 3.5GHz, but in countries where the 450MHz band has been opened up for broadband data, CDMA450 is the most likely network choice, or even Flash-OFDM or NextWave’s TD-CDMA, both of which are more specifically geared to IP data, and both of which have 450MHz profiles.

Then, for operators that also have GSM and/or 3G spectrum, a second phase could see that largely fixed broadband wireless network extended to broader areas, or upgraded with greater mobility and cellular integration, using refarmed 3G spectrum. In this case, the most likely technology will be HSPA, though it is also possible that WiMAX, now it has been accepted as an IMT-2000 standard and therefore adoptable in Europe’s 3G bands, will also acquire a 900MHz profile. This could take advantage of the EU regulators’ increasing willingness to consider allowing cellcos to run 3G in their 2G bands, in order to target rural areas more profitably (although Finland is the only country that has actually introduced this policy so far, with France likely to follow next).

Finland was one of the first European countries to allow the 450MHz spectrum to be refarmed and used for broadband wireless, although there has also been considerable deployment of CDMA450 in the eastern half of the region. Since WiMAX does not have a 450MHz profile, TeliaSonera steered clear of this technology (though it has trialled it in other scenarios) and instead looked to partner with the company that gained the new-look 450MHz national license, TV and radio provider Digita, which selected Flarion’s Flash-OFDM system before this was acquired by Qualcomm. Its network is provided by Nokia Siemens ‘ the German half of the partnership has been very active in 450MHz technologies. Flash-OFDM is highly spectrally efficient and therefore, when combined with the propagation qualities of low frequencies, can allow an operator to cover a large area of sparse population with a single base station. Its modulation scheme can support an average data rate of around 1.5Mbps in just 1.25MHz of spectrum. Combined with the fact that scarcity of broadband services in rural areas often means premium rates can be charged, suddenly carriers have a profit model that looks quite enticing. Telia will charge €44.90 (US$66) a month for a 1Mbps service, well above the national and European averages for broadband. Digita always intended to operate a wholesale-only model and Telia is its biggest customer to date.

The incumbent operator told Unstrung: ‘We have 53,000 customers and one million poles that are 35 years old. It’s too expensive to have this kind of fixed network in rural areas.’ Also, a rising incidence of storms affects the lamp poles and makes a mobile network more reliable, it added.

Operators in 3G-heavy regions are excited about the prospect of being able to convert the frequencies to use for enhanced indoor UMTS coverage – and where GSM license expiry dates are looming, there is the added bonus of providing an argument for cellcos to be allowed to keep their spectrum rather than return it to a pool for re-auction. Finland, France and Portugal are leading the way in using UMTS900 over GSM frequencies to expand rural and indoor coverage with the more efficient spectrum. From the beginning of last year, Europe’s CEPT cleared the path for the roll-out of UMTS900 in its 47 member states, in the bands formerly reserved for GSM. Member states still need to implement the decision into their national RF plans, a process that has already begun in Finland and Portugal. Nokia and SFR have made test data calls in France as have Vodafone Portugal and Finland’s Elisa, the last two using Option Wireless technology, with Vodafone relying on Nortel base stations and Elisa on Nokia.

Refarming 900MHz is clearly an option beloved of cellular infrastructure makers, and Ericsson and Nokia have been important in the creation of the new products, as has Qualcomm in the US. However, critics warn that, while UMTS900 gives better macro coverage because of its larger cell sizes, which can support sparsely populated areas, it does not match the indoor performance of GSM because of the burden of carrying broadband data, and indoor coverage options like femtocells will be important to complete the business case.

Meanwhile, while 450MHz has seemed less attractive to GSM/3G operators ‘ despite its even better propagation ‘ because of its lack of GSM support, this is now being remedied by the 3G infrastructure makers, with an eye to eastern Europe and, in particular, emerging economies. Operators can make a profit on charging consumers just $5 a month for mobile services, if they use the 450MHz spectrum, according to Nokia. Such a pricing level, combined with the emerging breed of sub-$100 handsets, will make cellular services far more viable for large sections of the population in new economies. With that huge potential market in mind, as well as the increasing use of 450MHz spectrum in eastern Europe and rural areas, Nokia and Ericsson are to develop an implementation of GSM for this band, seeking to prevent CDMA450 from taking a monopoly position in an increasingly valuable frequency.

The 450MHz band requires about 16 times fewer base stations to provide similar coverage in similar terrain, compared to 1.8GHz, for instance. Much of the early activity in 450MHz has been in south east Asia and eastern Europe, though there is also interest in Africa and Latin America. ‘Ericsson GSM 450 will particularly help to bring mobile services to remote areas previously considered not feasible to cover,’ Ericsson stated last year. ‘Better coverage with lower operating costs is one result of the new technology.’

GSM networks currently operate at frequencies of 800MHz, 900MHz, 1.8GHz and 1.9GHz. Nokia and Ericsson have developed some products in the 450MHz frequency in the past, but never marketed them actively. In future, GPRS, EDGE and even 3G implementations could be made for 450MHz, and GSM450 base stations can work alongside those in higher frequencies.