Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

26 February 2008

Vodafone stumbling in key Indian territory?

In the past two years, Vodafone has sought to address its financial risks and shareholder jitters by refocusing more heavily on emerging markets, and the flagship of this effort has been its entry into the Indian market through its purchase of the majority stake in Vodafone Essar. However, despite a great explosion in this country’s mobile usage, there are worrying signs that Vodafone may not be cashing in on the boom as much as its major rivals.

For January, Vodafone Essar reported its sixth successive month of declining subscriber numbers, at a time when the GSM market as a whole saw record new additions. The largest cellco in the country, Bharti Airtel, which plans a major GSM expansion in 2008-9, beat its own record of monthly net additions in January, with 2.25m new connection numbers, up from 2.2m the previous month. By comparison, Vodafone Essar had a high number of net adds, at 1.69m, last July, and has seen a gradual decline since, to 1.28m in January.

Monthly net additions in the Indian GSM market as a whole were the highest ever recorded in January 2008, according to the Cellular Operators Association of India (COAI), at 6.54m, ahead of the previous record, 6.24m, in August 2007, and over 30% up on the previous January. India now has a national total of GSM customers of 178.8m.

In terms of percentage growth in net adds, the smaller mobile players were looking most impressive. Reliance Telecom gained a 5.2% share of total net adds against 3.6% of total customers, and Aircel reported a 7.5% share of net adds against a 5.6% share of the overall base.

Despite Vodafone’s apparently lacklustre appeal to the Indian public, compared to its homegrown rivals, the UK-based cellco did report a 56% year-on-year increase in revenue in the country in the third quarter, so part of its downturn appears to be down to a shift to higher ARPU services in a nation that is legendarily price competitive, and it appears to be stealing a march on competitors, at least when compared to previous owner Hutchison, in terms of data and business options. Even with a negative impact on volume, this may place Vodafone in a strong position to generate new revenues quickly at the 3G stage, with India set to auction both 3G and broadband wireless spectrum this year.

However, CEO Arun Sarin’s major challenge is always to reassure Vodafone’s shareholders, which are generally short termist and nervous about risk and expansion. And to retain the giant cellco’s place in the world’s top two, Sarin will certainly need to be bold in developing markets, something he indicated he was prepared to be when announcing the last quarterly results. At this time, he was sounding aggressive about
major investment plans to build up Vodafone Essar, and to look to neighboring regions. Vodafone has opened discussions with the Bangladeshi government, where there is high growth potential. There are six existing operators in Bangladesh with just under 34.4m mobile subscribers, penetration of just 22.6% of the population. Sarin also said he was interested in balancing slow growth in saturated markets with further interests in Asia and Africa, but did not go into more detail. Sarin has specified that Vodafone will invest $2bn in India in the next few years.