Italy, one of the last European countries to auction 3.5GHz broadband wireless spectrum, concluded its auction after nine rounds, selling off 35, 15-year regional licenses ‘ which will nearly all be used for WiMAX networks ‘ to six operators, down from the 48 that originally expressed interest.
The auction raised a total of €136.3m ($209m), a European record in this band and a leap of 176% on the starting offers – a figure that reflects the inflation of value of 3.5GHz licenses. By contrast, when PCCW acquired all the available 3.4GHz licenses in the UK auction in 2003, gaining national coverage, it paid just $14m. Recent 3.5GHz auctions in France and Germany raised €125.8m and €56.1m respectively.
The increase in demand for 3.4GHz-3.6GHz frequencies has been driven by regulators’ increasingly willingness to allow mobile applications in what has previously been a fixed-only band ‘ Italy is likely to make this concession, as the UK already has, although this is not officially confirmed. Another factor driving up 3.5GHz value is the availability, for the first time, of a standards-based technology (WiMAX) for the band, with the resulting impact on broadband wireless economics, and the promise of international roaming.
Although mobility and global roaming may enhance the attractiveness of the spectrum and the associated business models, the initial focus of Italy’s regulator, and most of the winning bidders, is on improving rural access. The biggest winner, little known AriaDSL, which paid €47.5m for licenses in all regions, is strongly focused on delivering premium rate, fixed and nomadic broadband access to underserved regions of the country. It is reportedly controlled by Israeli billionaire David Gilo, who founded US-based broadband wireless equipment maker Vyyo.
The second largest winner was Wi-Fi provider AFT. This company paid €34.4m, again gaining licenses in all regions. It’s initial priorities will be rural access as well as expanding some of its its hotspot and residential metrozone activities to support higher value services. Italy was slow to support public or outdoor Wi-Fi in its regulations and this market remains more open than in many other regions, and less dominated by the larger cellcos.
The country’s incumbent, Telecom Italia, spent the third largest sum on licenses, paying €13.8m for rights in central and southern Italy, plus the island of Sardinia. These are areas with significant rural regions and the telco will look to use fixed and nomadic WiMAX to meet its universal access targets without having to lay wires everywhere, and potentially to add mobile broadband applications to its converged services in future. Although the operator has been very active in trialling WiMAX, it has remained ambivalent about how far it would deploy the technology in mobile applications, as opposed to DSL alternative.
Fourth placed winner, Retelit (bidding through its subsidiary e-via), is also looking to extend the coverage of its broadband and multimedia networks and services economically, though its geographical focus is mainly on the north east ‘ it paid €23.3m for licenses in Lombardy, Friuli Venezia Giulia, Veneto, Emilia Romagna and Marche.
At one time it had seemed that the Italian WiMAX auction might pave the way for futuristic applications of the technology in mobile multimedia and quad play models. Italy is one of the world’s most advanced nations in quad play and IPTV, and so most service providers are eager to gain more bandwidth to deliver such services. In the early stages, large numbers of media companies joined the auction race, but most of the big names, including former prime minister Silvio Berlusconi’s MediaSet and IPTV/internet giant Fastweb, dropped out. The fifth winner of 3.5GHz franchises was the only remaining pure media interest ‘ this was MGM Productions, which took licenses in the regions of Trento, Tuscany and Liguria.
A sixth winner, Tourist Ferry Boat, took a single license to offer internet access on ships travelling between the mainland and the island of Sicily, as well as services on the island itself.
Another surprise exit from the auction was Wind, the cellco controlled by Egypt-based multinational Orascom, which is looking to build an extensive empire around the Mediterranean and Middle East, using a combination of cellular and WiMAX technology.
The focus on underserved access is natural given Italy’s variable and often difficult terrains. About 4.2m citizens, or 7.5% of the population, have no access to broadband which is higher than most western European countries. For this reason, the terms of the auction had obliged all contenders to outline plans to reach broadband black spots, in order to be eligible to bid.
‘The market geography to emerge from this auction is extremely positive, because it shows we have competition, a significant number of players and sizeable investments,’ commented Communications Minister Paolo Gentiloni said in a statement.
The spectrum was auctioned in three blocks of paired 2’21MHz.