Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

11 March 2008

Nokia signs $2bn deal with Chinese distributor, but there are seeds of decay

Nokia, like all handset makers, sees China as a critical market, and needs to strike the difficult balance between gaining market share there, and avoiding too drastic an impact on margins. So far the Finnish company has enjoyed a strong measure of success, achieving market lead at the expense, largely, of Motorola and domestic vendors. It has mainly avoided the ultra-low cost (sub-$50) sector, concentrating instead on the market for budget smartphones and on the population groups with high potential growth in disposable income, so the negative drag on profits has not been severe ‘ indeed, despite falling average selling price (ASP) last year, Nokia saw its global margin increase, a feat unmatched by its major challengers. However, there are signs of concern for 2008 onwards, as highlighted by the renewal of its agreement with Postel, the largest distributor of handsets in China, which controls 30% of the distribution market by unit volume.

The new deal with Postel is for $2bn worth of handsets in 2008. Hardly a bad figure, especially as Postel is not Nokia’s only channel into the country ‘ it also has relationships with all three national cellcos and with 25 regional ones. However, the $2bn figure is a 20% reduction on the value of last year’s contract with Postel, at a time when the overall Chinese market is growing. The best interpretation, from Nokia’s point of view, is that it aims to sell more phones directly to the operators, an arrangement that tends to give it greater influence over how the carrier markets and brands its devices.

Other explanations are more concerning ‘ that domestic phonemakers are gaining ground after a downturn in their fortunes in 2006-7; that there are still large numbers of handsets unsold from last year’s agreement; and/or that the volumes are still stable or growing, but ASP is dropping steeply. The first of these is the least likely. China’s strongest phonemakers, like Ningbo Bird and ZTE, are starting to gain significant brand clout at home and to sell in international markets, but in general the middle class demographics that Nokia is primarily targeting remain attracted to western devices, and the smaller Chinese vendors are struggling badly and going through a wave of consolidation. Few have the design, R&D and marketing capabilities of a more established handset firm, and their assumed key advantage, low cost manufacturing, is shared by Nokia, which has invested in major manufacturing ventures in China, and can also bring its legendary economies of scale and supply chain efficiency to the table.

Unsold inventory would be more worrying, and could reflect a downturn in consumer confidence caused by the effects of last year’s huge storms, which have boosted inflation. However, there have been few concrete indications that these factors are seriously affecting Nokia, which says patterns in China remain largely predictable and seasonal. So the most likely scenario seems to be a combination of Nokia spreading its favors more widely, aiming to take pole position with key carriers like China Mobile in the run-up to the reorganization of Chinese carriers around a convergence model; and the inevitable decline in ASP. Last year Nokia saw its sales to China rise, in unit terms, by 39% on the year before, to 70m units. To deliver a similar level of growth again, it will no longer be able to protect its margins as effectively as it has done until now, and will need to make some hard decisions to ensure it keeps the Chinese phonemakers at bay, but also avoids the disastrous experience of Motorola, of rushing too headlong into ultra-low cost markets. Despite its early move into very cheap handsets, Motorola has seen declining market share in China, whereas, when its RAZR was at the height of its powers, it largely defied the market wisdom that Chinese consumers would only buy very cheap devices. In fact, the RAZR led the market there in its first year of launch, representing an aspirational product in a country with a rapidly growing middle class and where consumers are likely to emulate their counterparts in neighboring Japan and Korea, spending a higher proportion of their income on their cellphones than western users would consider.

Nokia said in its statement that China Postel is ‘expected’ to make purchases worth $2bn, rather than being committed to these levels, and added that the two parties would ‘strengthen strategic ties’ in distribution channels, marketing and ‘resource investment’, a partnership model common to foreign investment in China. The two companies have worked together since 1998 and Nokia overtook Motorola as market leader in 2004.