One of the great hopes for WiMAX has always been that it would not carry the IPR burden that has plagued GSM and 3G, but patent activity is gathering pace as the technology comes to market, and although the WiMAX Forum has clear guidelines on ‘reasonable and non-discriminatory’ (RAND) licensing terms, it is not yet clear whether any patent holder will try to cash in to the extent of affecting the all-important device price tag.
According to new research from West Technology Research Solutions, there are now 628 US and international patents awarded or pending for WiMAX, a 24% increase on the figure at the end of 2006. Unsurprisingly, essential IPR is dominated by Samsung and Intel, and analysts hope that these two giants will create a balance, with it being in neither’s interests to be too aggressive about licensing terms.
However, the situation is scarcely balanced, and the industry will do better to place trust in Samsung’s ambition to make the WiMAX platform universal, something that high IPR charges would hinder, and in the lack of history of aggressive patent activity in the Korean firm. Samsung owns about 30% of resolved or pending WiMAX patents, and in Mobile WiMAX this figure rises to 42%, because of the company’s key role in developing Wi-Bro, the Korean platform that became the basis of 802.16e. By contrast, second largest IPR holder Intel has about 7% of the patents, or 8% in Mobile WiMAX. No other company controls more than 3%, and there are over 100 companies claiming significant IPR.
Some observers have predicted a patent pool system for WiMAX, under the auspices of the Forum, but given the strength of Samsung and Intel, it is more likely that 802.16e will go the same route as the cellular standards, relying on a web of bilaterial negotiations on licensing rates. West suggests that another approach might be to have a pool for the smaller holders, which would then negotiate collectively with Samsung and Intel and a few other majors.
“It also depends on the strength and commitment the companies have to the WiMAX Forum,’ she added in a recent interview. ‘If all companies involved are committed to the WiMAX Forum and committed to working together maybe there could be a situation where they could all pool their IP. I think these decisions could be made in the next year or so.”
The industry’s most famous patent holder, Qualcomm, has hinted it holds IPR in WiMAX, but has not declared its hand, and many speculate that its failure to join the WiMAX Forum is because it would not wish to sign up to the body’s RAND terms (though it is a member of the Wi-Fi Alliance, which has similar guidelines, and anyway, the enforceability of the code of conduct has not been tested).
WTRS report author Kirsten West said the patent applications will not plateau for another two years, and that there has been a shift in new patent filings away from fundamental network architecture towards applications and devices, a trend she expects to continue as the platform matures. West singles out location-based services, multimode Wi-Fi/WiMAX devices, and the development of wireless backhaul networks as key areas of development .
“A lot of new research focuses on handoff between WiMAX and other networks like Wi-Fi and that means people are starting to think about WiMAX interoperability. We are seeing Nortel, Cisco and Lucent developing new IP in this area of handoff,” she said.
West points out that operators are getting more involved in WiMAX innovation and singles out SK Telecom, Sprint and AT&T as carriers that are beginning to develop IPR to support 802.16e infrastructure, while Nokia, Ericsson and Kyocera are most active on the device side.