Virgin Mobile’s alliance with carrier Tata to launch its brand in India has come under fire from Vodafone and other Indian cellcos, which are accusing the UK giant of taking a back door route to running an MVNO, illegal in India.
The Cellular Operators Association of India, which represents India’s GSM operators, has told the Department of Telecom that the deal violates regulations. Tata is a CDMA operator, so always the subject of the COAI’s hostility, but it retorted with its own claims that GSM operators are flouting Indian regulations with some of their network outsourcing contracts.
The DoT has asked Tata to clarify the terms of the deal, under which the cellco will license Virgin’s brand name to offer voice and value added services. Tata claims this is not an MVNO because it is not selling network capacity to Virgin to run its own services and although it says it has furnished the required information, it has gone ahead and launched the new brand.
One of the features of Virgin Mobile India is to offer users 10 paise (about 25 cents) credit for every minute of incoming calls they receive from another network. The COAI argues that such an offer would involve Virgin buying airtime from Tata. The brand will target 14- to 25-year-olds, had signed up 500 subscribers within two days of launching.
In any event, the DoT is considering lifting the ban on MVNOs and is likely to ask the regulator to draft guidelines later this year. India has 13 mobile operators and five more companies have now received licenses.