In the evolving mobile internet, one issue is critical to all parties ‘ whether the operators or the internet services companies will be the dominant channel in delivering applications to the consumers. While, in the short to medium term, nobody can avoid working with the cellco that control most of the market, it is clear that direct-to-consumer and open access moves by Nokia, Google and the others potentially pave the way for operators to become mere bit pipes, with little value added revenue opportunity. Cellcos are reacting in different ways, trying to keep internet majors firmly within their fold by offering the incentive of preferential access to the user base (Vodafone); or seeking to make their services more attractive and mobile-optimized than those of the web majors (3 or Sprint Xohm). Their lethal weapon, at least in the short term, is likely to be their intimate knowledge of the individual consumer’s devices, behavior and preferences, which if well exploited will enable the operator to deliver the holy grail of a fully personalized experience far more easily than the open access companies, which rely on consumers having a high degree of awareness of the services they wish to use. Giving users free rein, and trusting them to be proactive, is still a daunting prospect in the awkward environment of the mobile internet, and will remain so until significant improvements are made in interfaces and navigation. This justifies many of the comments of AT&T and others, however self-serving, that most users still prefer the closed world where the device and interface are supported by the operator and tied to its network, delivering a more restricted, but easily usable, experience.
If operators can enhance their readymade advantages of usability and security with a high level of personalization, they may strengthen their hand against the threat of the internet players. Some technology companies are looking to help them, ranging from giants such as Qualcomm ‘ always ready to pose as the operators’ friend as it expands its activities in internet software ‘ to start-ups such as InfoGin, the latest company to gain profile in the important mobile browser war.
Qualcomm has been stepping up its software activities, centered on its Brew content platform, for several years and the emergence of mobile internet models gives it new opportunities. Its chief focuses are on personalization of the user interface, and on carrier content delivery and media development. While Brew and its surrounding products used to be tied to CDMA, and represented a way to make the network platform more attractive to operators, Qualcomm is now making its software increasingly network agnostic and looks to create a separate business around software and media, as well as increasing the competitiveness of its chips for 3G and beyond.
It has acquired a string of small companies as part of this strategy, and the latest is Ireland’s Xiam Technologies, which specializes in content targeting solutions, and for which Qualcomm has paid $32m. Founded in 2004 and funded with venture capital from Delta Partners and Enterprise Ireland, Xiam provides personalized targeting and recommendations technology specifically for wireless systems.
The description of Xiam’s product, as issued in the official statement about the acquisition, is significant in that it focuses heavily on helping operators to address their subscribers directly, rather than a third party services provider being the main brand and experience visible to the end user. Xiam’s MPOS (My Personal Offers System) claims to enable ”wireless operators to interact directly with individual customers offering them meaningful, timely and relevant content offers, promotions and advertisements through all wireless channels including WAP, web and outbound messaging’. Qualcomm says it will offer MPOS as a standalone technology but is also likely to integrate its functionality into its broader web software platform for carriers. Last year it partnered with Xiam to integrate MPOS with the Brew content delivery and user interface platform. MPOS will also be incorporated into its BrandXtend solution for media and brand companies.
Indicating its seriousness about this market, Qualcomm recently set up a dedicated Internet Services division, echoing similar moves by operators like Vodafone and vendors like Nokia. This unit is headed up by former Flarion executive Andrew Gilbert, who also runs MediaFLO and Qualcomm Europe. The tie-in of internet and European activities is unlikely to be random ‘ the addressable market for mobile carrier web services will be far larger in Europe than Qualcomm’s traditional CDMA heartlands and Europe’s operators are on the cusp of major moves in the wireless internet, offering Qualcomm a long awaited opportunity to break into the EU fortress, creating new operator relationships as well as boosting its W-CDMA and HSPA technologies in a territory that was barred to it in the days of the CDMA/GSM divide. Xiam has three named operator customers, all in Europe ‘ Vodafone Ireland, Orange UK and O2 Ireland ‘ and claims it is in the early stages of deployment with three further European cellcos. Vodafone Ireland uses MPOS for targeting users with relevant advertising; Orange UK to make content recommendations from its Orange World portal; and O2 to market its own services to subscribers.
“Qualcomm’s acquisition of Xiam provides us with advanced content discovery and recommendation technology that strengthens Qualcomm’s services portfolio,” said Gilbert in a statement.
MPOS helps to identify the content that is of most relevance to an individual, enabling operators to be more accurate in targeting paid-for products or advertising, and to improve the subscriber’s overall experience even when there is no revenue attached to the content.
This acquisition is likely to be part of a broader ramp-up of Qualcomm’s services business. Executive VP Len Lauer, who is overseeing all the services business units, is charged with unveiling a new services strategy for the company, which is expected to be unveiled mid-year.
Other important acquisitions in recent years have included UK start-ups Trigenix and elata (see Wireless Watch October 14 2004 and August 26 2005). These clearly pointed the way to a strategy where Qualcomm would offer operators the ability to create customized user experiences relatively quickly and dynamically, and so boost their ARPU from content, always an area where Brew scores well against Java-based content delivery systems (although it does support Java downloads). Despite some genuine advantages, Brew has made limited headway outside CDMA strongholds like the US and Korea (and even in the latter has been challenged by homegrown alternatives). The user interface technologies that were added with Trigenix were a first step to breaking into UMTS and Europe ‘ with the significant win of O2 in 2005 ‘ and the operators’ urgent need to deliver an attractive mobile internet experience should, Qualcomm hopes, further its cause more rapidly right across the developed mobile markets.
For a chipmaker, Qualcomm has a shrewd understanding of what operators and consumers are looking for, and so the enhancements to Brew and its surrounding products have recently focused on advanced gaming, Java, multimedia content and putting the end user in control of his or her mobile experience, and now will increasingly home in on web services and navigation. Trigenix, elata and now Xiam all fit into this picture. Qualcomm used the former’s technology to create uiOne, a very graphics rich capability that is now an option within Brew and was first implemented by US carrier Alltel for its innovative and ARPU-boosting Celltop system (see Wireless Watch January 22 2007). Although uiOne gives cellcos more advanced tools to create innovative UIs, it can also be put into the hands of end users. Qualcomm sees customized UIs moving alongside wallpaper and ringtones as a major revenue generator for cellcos that will compensate operators somewhat for the loss of brand control.
UIone is probably the most important Trojan horse for getting into the UMTS/Java stronghold. The ability for operators to reduce the time it takes to create a complex UI is important to platforms such as Vodafone Live! especially as these look to find their place within a broader mobile internet market. Live! has a strong reliance on Java technologies, but also very complicated UI requirements. ‘Vodafone Live! has a very thick document of user interface requirements that the handset manufacturers have to build into their handsets. This is a perfect use of uiOne because it can allow the handset manufacturers to shorten the time to market to get that specific user interface back to Vodafone,’ Qualcomm commented last year. ‘You see that duplicated with all the European operators. They have a lengthy list of user interface requirements.’
elata took Qualcomm a step further, with its Senses platform for delivering content and applications over the air. This pointed to the creation of a single service delivery framework, network-agnostic, under which a broad array of content could be unified and managed, including Brew, Java, streaming and Open Mobile Alliance standards-compliant content. This content could then be delivered in a uniform way to different networks and devices. Most importantly to Qualcomm’s customization drive is Senses’ ability to automate the process of targeting specific services to customers depending on their profiles, allowing the carrier’s back end system to recognize a device as it connects to the network.
While bringing Brew-style facilities to non-Brew devices has had immediate attractions, in the longer term, this ongoing effort to create a neutral umbrella platform could be even more important. It could be part of a content platform that could be adapted for non-cellular platforms, potentially incorporated with systems like MediaFLO to create a 4G-style infrastructure that could be marketed to wireline and start-up carriers as well as cellcos and offer an alternative to investment in their own WiMAX or other networks.
Other start-ups are also looking to build their fortunes on helping sort out the operators’ challenges in delivering a mobile web experience ‘ and may, in the process, catch the eye of larger players like Qualcomm as they assemble their software portfolios. One such is InfoGin, an eight-year old Israeli start-up that is looking to position itself in the increasingly crowded mobile browser space alongside the main independent, Opera Software, and vendor offerings like Apple Safari or, of course, Windows Mobile/IE. It is differentiating itself from these majors, and a host of transcoding start-ups, in the same manner as Qualcomm, by working with operators rather than on direct-to-consumer channels and applications.
In 2005, InfoGin got its breakthrough when it signed an agreement to power AOL’s mobile search, and later won the deal to format web pages for the internet provider. It has won other transcoding contracts, formatting web pages for Mapquest and others, but it has increasingly focused on its browser and on selling that to operators. In the past year, it claims to have signed up 18 cellcos and internet providers, including six tier one carriers in North America and Europe, with a total of 20m active users of its technology.
InfoGin offers white label, web-to-mobile technology that supports rich web technologies like Flash, Ajax and Javascript (not true of many transcoders). It is pursuing the same server-based ethos as Nokia, arguing that this enables it to control the optimization of functionality to the device’s individual capability rather than placing the burden on the device end. It claims its platform is a low cost, low risk approach for operators to bring mobile web experiences to users without significant investment in ensuring all the base has smartphones, and meanwhile retaining their own brand and user contact. Such offerings may have only temporary value ‘ as a larger percentage of the user base moves to smartphones, browsers like Safari and Opera Mini provide greater functionality, and some of these will start to work with cellcos too if they see the need. However, by the time the Europeans and Japanese all have advanced internet phones, there will be a new market for the likes of InfoGin, with operators in less developed mobile economies. Even in the most advanced territories, it will be some years before the true open, usable mobile internet experience, as envisaged by Google and its gang, is a reality ‘ and in the meantime, the carriers will be looking for any help they can to ensure they fill in the gap, and stake themselves a profitable position in the mobile web future.