Here is a sad story of two handset chip companies ‘ one beset by legal battles and the hostility of much of the industry, and currently excluded from the business of the holder of 40% of the market; the other naming all top three phonemakers among its major customers and managing to tread a careful line in its political alliances. Yet it is the former that is seeing its ratings upgraded on strong 3G forecasts and a stubborn refusal to turn in a bad quarter amid all its problems, while the latter last week faced downgrades on warnings that its own 3G fortunes were flagging. The companies are, of course, the top two cellphone processor providers, Qualcomm and Texas Instruments, and if rising hopes that the former may settle its differences with Nokia before year-end are fulfilled, former Nokia alter ego TI may find itself under even greater pressure.
Qualcomm’s fortunes in 2007 were dominated by its series of legal battles with Nokia and Broadcom, and the threat of a European Union investigation into its business and licensing practises, petitioned by Nokia, Ericsson and others. Most significantly, its patent cross-licensing agreement with Nokia expired in April last year, and the two companies have failed to agree terms since, leaving Qualcomm without royalties from the holder of 40% share of the handset market for almost a year. Despite this and more court setbacks than wins on patent actions – and professing itself willing to spin off the licensing business if this proves essential ‘ Qualcomm’s main business in chip technologies has withstood the storm with remarkably resilience. Most companies’ stock might have been expected to have suffered a downward slide in these circumstances, but it has held virtually solid for the past year, with regular upward leaps when strong results have been announced.
Qualcomm has executed ahead of the market and more effectively than any other major in W-CDMA and now HSDPA and HSUPA/HSPA+, which is adding credibility to its aggressive LTE roadmap. The chip company has convinced many doubters that it could, if it really had to, lead its market even without the benefits of its high margin, tightly controlled IPR business. It could even survive the likely loss, over the coming 5-8 years, of significant new CDMA silicon business, as operators look to LTE and WiMAX for their next generation roll-outs, rather than a CDMA follow-on. Significant realignment and revaluing of the company will be necessary if CDMA declines more rapidly than expected, or Qualcomm is forced to hive off IPR, but this looks like a supplier that can weather the storm on the back of its engineering excellence, strong understanding of operator needs, and accelerating expansion into software and services (see separate item). None of this optimistic view can realistically come true, though, without at least some rapprochement with Nokia, especially if the Finnish machine maintains its current massive market lead.
Most immediately, any level of royalties from Nokia would obviously boost Qualcomm’s earnings power. A settlement on the patents front – if spun effectively to appear, at least, that concessions had been made to Nokia’s views on reducing total handset cost and the new balance of power in handset IPR ‘ could finally open the door to Nokia’s adding its traditional enemy to its increasingly broad list of chip suppliers. This will not be a decision made lightly in Helsinki ‘ remember that Nokia arguably blew its chances to compete in CDMA handsets by remaining obdurate against buying Qualcomm silicon and seeking, with TI and STMicro, to create its own alternate supply. The dominant vendor was able to leverage its grip on the R&D roadmap to shift the goalposts every time TI jumped, leaving it with a second rate product. While its grasp of the agenda, and the market, in W-CDMA and HSPA is significantly less, if Qualcomm carries on the way it has been lately, Nokia could face a similar dilemma again ‘ stick with its usual suppliers and settle for a second class product, or swallow its pride and go with the most advanced features on the market.
This makes two things essential if Qualcomm is not to fall on its face in the legal and licensing bog, as the market has been waiting for it to do for over a year ‘ it must continue to deliver its technological promises and offer silicon visibly superior to that of TI and others in key markets, while showing greater flexibility than it is wont to do on pricing; and it must settle its licensing differences with Nokia, because short of spinning off IPR altogether, that is the only way its chip business can sit down at the table with the mighty Finns. The company has been hinting strongly that this is now more likely than at any time in recent history, with statements made publicly and privately, at Mobile World Congress and elsewhere, to the effect that Qualcomm no longer regarded Nokia’s business as out of reach.
Although some executives were even hinting at a d’tente this year, it seems unlikely that the IPR issues could be solved and a possible customer relationship negotiated in that space of time, but the prospect of a twin reconciliation certainly puts a gloss on hopes for 2009. There has been a general growth of optimism on Wall Street about a settlement on the licensing front, at least, sparked by Nokia’s increasing strength, which suggests Qualcomm’s negotiating position will not get any better in the near term. Last week, this optimism was given voice by American Technology Research, whose Qualcomm analyst Mark McKechnie upgraded the stock from ‘hold’ to ‘buy’ on predictions that the chipmaker would settle with Nokia in ‘three to 18 months’ and that the handset giant would pay royalties of ‘upwards of 2%’ which, combined with lower legal costs, would drive up earnings in 2009 and 2010.
McKechnie set a price target on the stock of $52 (which rose 1% to $39.80 on his note) and offered five reasons for the upgrade:
‘ Management has indicated that the March quarter is on target.
‘ He expects a settlement of the Nokia dispute in 3-18 months and predicts Nokia will pay royalties of 2% or higher.
‘ He projects earnings power in 2009/2010 of $2.60 a share.
‘ Stock is cheap, at just 15x the earnings power estimate above.
‘ Most importantly of all, the global ramp-up of 3G, with ATR forecasting that the market for 3G handsets will grow from 180m last year to 280m this year and 350m next year, with Qualcomm strongly positioned to take advantage in chips and IPR.
Investment research firm JRPG is also looking for an early settlement with Nokia, possibly even before the companies’ patents battle comes to court in Delaware in July. Analyst Jamie Townsend wrote in a recent research note: ‘Given Qualcomm’s string of court losses and customers defections we expect the invisible hand will make them want to settle sooner than the street expects. We expect any settlement will likely result in Nokia purchasing chips from Qualcomm. This seems especially plausible in light of Nokia’s rather considerable rearrangement of its chip suppliers. From an investors’ point of view, we believe a settlement will likely be good for both companies, particularly Qualcomm. Should Nokia receive better than industry chip pricing, which seems likely; it may:
‘ Spill over into other suppliers hurting other industry suppliers Broadcom, Texas Instrument, Infineon, and ST Micro.
‘ Reduce Qualcomm’s semiconductor margins.
‘ Hurt struggling competitors like Motorola.’
There is certainly huge potential upside for Qualcomm’s chip business if the IPR flank comes to settlement with Nokia. Whereas the company has often been accused of deriving unfair advantage for its semiconductor business from its power in IPR, nowadays the disputes over patent royalties are actually hindering the silicon unit from reaping full advantage from its technological advances (a powerful argument for spinning off IPR proactively, rather than as a last resort under potential EU pressure). Qualcomm is advanced in several areas that will be key to new handset spending in the coming few years, such as HSPA/+, highly integrated multimode devices, software defined radio and GPS. It is also building strong positions in other high growth, high value markets such as handset software, machine-to-machine (where it is very powerful) and even mobile satellite.
But UMTS/HSPA will be the backbone for some time, and one risk factor hanging over the more bullish views of Qualcomm will be the effect of macro economic trends on demand for 3G, the area of the market that is now most vital to the fortunes of the handset silicon majors. Economic uncertainty in developed markets, where 3G will be strongest in the coming 1-2 years, could affect the speed with which consumers upgrade their handsets, squeezing demand. This may already be affecting Texas Instruments, though with Qualcomm and the handset giants not yet reporting significant impact from a consumer spending squeeze, the market leader’s lowering of quarterly targets last week can also be blamed on a weakening of its competitiveness against Qualcomm, STMicro and others.
TI reduced its earnings and revenue target for the first quarter, citing weakening cellphone chip demand ‘especially from one customer’ ‘ assumed to be Nokia, which last year broke TI’s near-monopoly on its baseband business and added three other vendors to its supply chain (Infineon for 2G, Broadcom for EDGE and STMicro for 3G). It was not clear how much revenue these new suppliers would gain at TI’s expense, and how far the ploy was primarily to put pressure on the incumbent chipmaker to cut prices and accelerate product roll-outs. But it appears there has already been some shift away from TI, which has not, yet at least, been balanced by new deals with Motorola and Ericsson Mobile Platforms.
TI cut its earnings per share forecast to 41-45 cents from its target of 43-49 cents. It now expects revenue of $3.21bn-$3.35bn, compared with its earlier target range of $3.27bn-$3.55bn. Analysts on average had expected earnings of 46 cents per share on revenue of $3.4bn.
Analysts estimated that TI could be talking about a pullback in phone units of as many as six million, and assumed this was largely down to economic uncertainty and the consequent effect on handset targets ‘ an assumption that sent Nokia’s shares down as much as 3.5% to $31.75 in after hours trading last Monday. Fears that this was a macro economic issue, rather than just a loss of share by TI, were reinforced by comments from Ron Slaymaker, TI’s investor relations manager, who said the weak demand his company was seeing was not down to market share losses at its customers. However, he refused to be more specific about causes, something that hurt the stock last week. “We have other customers also that haven’t fully lived up to initial expectations that we had, but it is mostly a particular customer,” he said. Didier Scemama, an analyst at ABN Amro, joined most of the market in assuming Nokia to be that customer. “We estimate that the $130m revenue cut (at the mid point) announced last night is equivalent to a reduction of 4.3m-8.6m third generation handset unit shipments, as Texas Instruments derives between $15 and $30 per 3G handset,” he wrote. A few analysts were looking for alternative culprits.
“Although many will be tempted to blame the shortfall primarily on Nokia, based on our checks we are more worried about the pace of sales at Sony Ericsson, the other major wireless customer,” wrote Matthew Hoffman of Cowen & Co in a note to clients.
Slaymaker said demand was on track for chips for low end phones, and for analog chips used in many consumer and industrial products, and on which TI has been focusing more strongly of late (see Wireless Watch March 4 2008). But the fact that 3G is the problem area worried analysts, as this is the sector where growth is most expected and where, despite TI’s protestations about no loss of share, other players appear still to be making progress. Following its optimistic view of Qualcomm’s 3G prospects, American Technology Research was particularly disappointed in TI. “Because it’s 3G it really puts an overhang on the stock because that’s a segment of the market we expect to be growing,” analyst Doug Freedman said.
It will be even more serious for market prospects if TI’s caution does turn out to be attributable to lower overall 3G demand at Nokia, rather than a shift towards other suppliers by the Finnish leader. The handset giant is not showing any jitters yet and has maintained its outlook for the year, which calls for 10% growth this year over the 1.14bn devices shipped globally by all players last year. Nokia will report first quarter earnings on April 17, when it could adjust its outlook, but it has offered no indication that it will do so, and most analysts are supporting the Nokia view, and an overall market growth of 8-11%.
‘Our checks suggest that while some models are seeing mixed demand, Nokia’s overall 3G portfolio is seeing solid demand in the first quarter,’ wrote Ittai Kidron at Oppenheimer, in a research note following the TI warning. Others were more bearish. “We are usually careful about comments from Nokia’s supply chain, but the scale of the downgrade at Texas Instruments and the precision of the comments make us conclude that demand for Nokia’s 3G/high end phones has decreased in the second half of the quarter,” wrote Cazenove analysts in a note.
Given Nokia’s habitual caution in public statements, we believe the absence of reaction from the Finn is a sign that it is not seeing major problems. If this proves over optimistic, the impact for TI ‘ and any potential Qualcomm deal of the future ‘ is serious, but perhaps the chipmaker that would be hit hardest would be STMicro. ST scored a major goal last year when it not only became Nokia’s second source of UMTS/HSPA baseband silicon, alongside TI, but also netted a coveted joint development deal with the phonemaker, which will accelerate its R&D activities in this area and reduce its cost and risk. However, ST has thrown most of its handset eggs in the high end sector, largely on the back of the Nokia deal, and so weakness in 3G, especially in ST’s native Europe ‘ where the relative maturity of the market, with many users already approaching upgrades, makes it particularly vulnerable to slowdown ‘ could be very serious.