Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

18 March 2008

Australia’s rural WiMAX super-project in doubt

There are doubts hanging over the Australian government’s ambitious plan for public/private roll-out of WiMAX to rural and interior areas, a contract won last year by the Opel consortium, which a venture between SingTel, Optus and Elders. The Opel award was made last September by the Liberal government, with the government agreeing to match an A$1bn ($888m) injection from Opel’s stakeholders. However, that government has been ousted by a new Labor one, and two months after the general elections, the market is getting nervous about the lack of public endorsement of Opel by the new Communications Minister, Stephen Conroy. Some say his silence could indicate that he will pull the plug on the venture and focus on Labor’s A$4.7bn National Broadband Plan, which plans to set up a public/private joint venture to deliver fiber-to-the-node (FTTN) services to 98% of homes. When in opposition, Conroy criticized the large size of the funding to Opel and the tender’s lack of transparency, and he questioned the project on technical grounds. However, he said during election campaigning that he would not withdraw Opel’s funding, but he has now stated that he is looking at the contract, and funding is yet to be transferred.

SingTel says it still expects the deal to go through by mid-April. In early January, Opel announced a deal to purchase pay TV operator Austar’s 2.3GHz licenses so it could roll out WiMAX regionally, but this agreement may have muddied the waters, according to Ovum analyst Nathan Burley, because of an existing spectrum sharing and cross-licensing deal between Austar and Unwired Australia, now part of the broadcast group Seven. “The Austar deal has raised more questions in the market,” Burley said. “Austar had a number of agreements in place with Unwired which reportedly still need to be honoured by Opel.” In particular, Unwired and Austar previously agreed to a swap of their 3.5GHz and 2.3GHz spectrum, meaning Austar agreed to use Unwired’s spectrum in rural areas and vice versa.

“Importantly, under the agreement, both parties agreed to deploy technology that was interoperable, and since Opel has committed to deploying mobile WiMAX technology, by default, Opel has to as well,” Burley says. “But Opel’s commitment is to fixed WiMAX technology using unlicensed spectrum at 5.8GHz. So does this new requirement fit into its contract with the government? Perhaps this could be a potential get-out clause for the government.” Other analysts believe WiMAX’ commercial potential in Australia is being squeezed by the imminent switch-on of incumbent Telstra’s ASDL2+ network, which will have greater range and efficiency, and by the government’s plans to push fiber deep into the interior of the country.