The CTIA wireless event in Las Vegas last week was saved from being a transatlantic re-run of February’s Mobile World Congress in Spain by the aftermath of the recently concluded 700MHz auction. Although the FCC gag on operators revealing their plans for the licenses was only lifted at the end of the show, talk of the new band and the likely 4G-oriented deployments that would take place in it added new flavor to CTIA ‘ while confirming that many of the original hopes for 700MHz, including a boost to rural access and public safety across the US, had largely been sidelined by the race to mobile broadband and 4G apps. As vendors lined up to prove their credentials for next generation networks in 700MHz and elsewhere, operators dropped heavy hints about their plans, which at least gave a topical twist to a show where most of the themes were the same as in Barcelona ‘ LTE versus WiMAX (or a convergence of the two); the possible fate of Qualcomm’s technologies; femtocells; open applications and software platforms. Verizon duly obliged with femtocell talk and AT&T did the same for Google’s open handset architecture Android, all of which obscured the fact that many keynote speakers – most notably Vodafone CEO Arun Sarin, repeating his plea for WiMAX-LTE harmonization ‘ had hardly altered their addresses at all for an American audience in the wake of a major auction.
Verizon Wireless and AT&T both focused on their 4G plans and protestations of openness ‘ though the latter also took the chance to point out that it could build out its own 700MHz spectrum, which is unfettered by open access conditions, more quickly and cheaply than its rival, and support more flexibility in revenue models. Both carriers also talked up their LTE plans to turn the tables on Sprint Nextel, whose open mobile broadband strategy, and the 4G-class network to support it, are far more advanced than those of its larger competitors, though currently enmired in Sprint’s operational problems.
Verizon Wireless reminded investors, in the wake of the show, that it will conduct field trials of LTE, in conjunction with co-parent Vodafone, later this year, selecting vendors and running device trials in 2009 and starting commercial launch in 2010. This sounds almost as ambitious as Sprint’s WiMAX agenda did when it first mooted it in 2006, and may well run into similar roadblocks, though these are more likely to spring from delays in availability of fully interoperable and functional LTE products than from financial blips at the carrier.
The initial trials will not run in 700MHz, and will be done in conjunction with not just Vodafone but also China Mobile. Once the new spectrum is cleared for use ‘ probably in February 2009 ‘ Verizon’s average spectrum depth will increase from 52MHz to 82MHz. “We now have sufficient spectrum to continue growing our business and data revenues well into – and possibly through – the next decade,” said CEO Lowell McAdam. “This is the very best spectrum with excellent propagation and in-building characteristics. We also believe that the combination of the national, contiguous, same-frequency C block footprint and our transition to LTE will make Verizon the preferred partner for developers of a new wave of consumer electronics and applications using this next generation technology.”
AT&T is also looking to initial LTE deployment in 2010, though it was less detailed about the steps it would take to get to that goal. It did crow over the fact that it spend about $3bn less than its arch-rival to get 700MHz licenses with no open access restrictions, and it will combine the results of its $6.6bn investment in the recent auction with further 700MHz licenses it acquired from Aloha Partners last year, giving it a bigger swathe of spectrum overall than Verizon (see Wireless Watch April 1 2008).
“With fewer costly and complex regulations, we have the certainty and flexibility needed to move faster in rolling out new mobile technology and more customer choices in devices and applications,” said Ralph de la Vega, president and CEO of AT&T’s wireless business, in a statement. “We will put our spectrum to work so that customers can do more with their wireless devices, the user experience is superb, and wireless connectivity can be embedded in more devices.” This is clearly the AT&T line ‘ it will deploy its advanced spectrum and its ability to lure attractive device exclusives such as the iPhone to create a superior mobile broadband experience, such that most consumers will not be interested in full open access and unrestricted use of online services from any handset. This is a line that we have heard before, in Europe, but many of those that took it most firmly, such as 3 and Vodafone, have been forced by consumer trends to embrace at least a measure of openness after all ‘ and AT&T is likely to find the same, especially if Verizon’s admittedly lukewarm open developer strategy starts to attract a broad and attractive set of applications to its own pre-4G services. Already, AT&T has said it is likely to support Google’s Android open handset platform for data and content services on its network.
With the US’ two largest carriers both opting for LTE for their mobile broadband roll-outs, the country seems to offer the best case for those who believe LTE and Mobile WiMAX should be converged to create a single set of 4G technology standards ‘ assuming that of the other would-be contenders, Qualcomm’s UltraMobile Broadband fails to come to market, and the Chinese successor to TD-SCDMA becomes an intrinsic part of the TDD flavor of LTE, as now seems almost inevitable. Vodafone CEO Arun Sarin plugged this idea in his keynote at Mobile World Congress and reiterated the message at CTIA, calling for WiMAX to be placed under the auspices of the 3GPP and treated as “part of the TDD section of the LTE standard’. For all the logic behind this view, the WiMAX community still appears broadly hostile to being submerged into the 3GPP efforts, and while Ericsson might welcome the end of a separate technology that could challenge LTE, it has recently seemed keen to harness the Chinese efforts to help build a TDD implementation of LTE that would beat WiMAX at its own game in this area of the spectrum ‘ where to date WiMAX has been a natural, while LTE has come out of the FDD-focused UMTS market.
However, the vendors have to listen to the views of major operators to a far greater extent than in any previous generation of wireless deployment. Organizations like the NGMN (Next Generation Mobile Network), which are operator-driven, have given the carriers far greater coherence in defining and promoting their own goals, with unified platforms being a key to reducing their cost base and the technological complexity of rolling out new services. Hence Vodafone’s interest in a unified 4G platform ‘ albeit one with various perhaps very different flavors ‘ as well as in common handset frameworks in hardware and software, and a greatly reduced number of mobile operating systems. In a panel at CTIA, containing the heads of three of the world’s top cellular networks vendors ‘ and moderated by Verizon CEO Lowell McAdam ‘ Nortel chief Mike Zafirovsky said:
“Operators are pushing us to go faster with 4G. It’s definitely a different environment.”
His counterpart at Alcatel-Lucent, Pat Russo, was broadly favorable to the idea of a unified 4G standard but thought it would be a long way off. “Alcatel-Lucent does have an aspiration to have a global standard because there are some real positives,” she said. “In WiMAX there are specific applications with uses based on spectrum and business models. The underlying technologies are similar in terms of radio access and all IP, but I think we are going to see a coexistence of some of these choices for some time.”
Meanwhile, Ericsson CEO Carl-Henric Svanberg was, implicitly at least, pursuing his company’s standard line, that LTE would be the only standard necessary because of the market share of its closest ancestors. He said: ‘In a perfect world it would be better for our resources to have one standard, but also different standards have pushed each other. But now we have a world where 85% of the world is on the GSM/W-CDMA path and is poised to dominate the world going forward.”
Companies like Nortel and Motorola, which have failed in W-CDMA and have taken an early stand in WiMAX, may be in two minds about a unified standard. On the one hand, the similarity between the two technologies, and their work on unified platforms for both, might put them in a strong position for a combined market. On the other, they could thrive better in a discrete WiMAX market, even though smaller, rather than taking on the giants (Ericsson, Alcatel-Lucent and Nokia Siemens) on all fronts.
While the leaders battle it out, the two major Chinese vendors regard deployment of almost any new technology, and the 700MHz windfall, as chances for new revenue streams outside their home country. Huawei used CTIA to reinforce its ambitions to make a major splash in the US, and announced that its 700MHz products ‘ for UMTS, CDMA EV-DO and LTE ‘ would be ready in the first quarter of 2009. The product series will rely heavily on software defined radios, said Huawei. It will support multiband operations over 700MHz, 850MHz, AWS and 1.9GHz, the key 3G/4G frequencies in the US; and will support dual-mode systems for CDMA/LTE and UMTS/LTE.
Charlie Martin, CTO for Huawei’s wireless activities outside China, said: “The US market is very strategic for us. Our goal is to be the premier vendor in the world. We can’t do that without the US.’ A breakthrough came last summer when Huawei won an EV-DO deal with Leap Wireless and so a foot in the coveted US door ‘ the Chinese vendors are enjoying rapid growth, but much of this comes from emerging economies and operators and they need to get themselves firmly on to the shortlists of the world’s top cellcos. Huawei has already signed a framework agreement for selected technologies with Vodafone and ZTE last week announced a similar achievement. ZTE signed a global framework agreement with Vodafone covering its whole product portfolio, which lays the foundation for the Chinese vendor to supply any Vodafone unit with infrastructure. This complements an existing deal between the two companies for low cost GSM handsets. Analysts speculate that, as well as putting price pressure on Vodafone’s more traditional infrastructure suppliers, as its deal with Huawei did, the carrier may be looking to use ZTE gear for its newly acquired Essar unit in India, where price pressure is intense but, according to CTO Steve Pusey, expansion needs to be on a huge scale ‘ ‘in India, we’re building a Germany in one year’, he told a recent conference. India is ZTE’s second biggest market after China and it expects to make $1bn in revenues there this year.
Huawei has also won contracts in Europe recently with T-Mobile (in five countries), Telecom Italia and O2 Germany, and also with China Mobile’s Pakistani unit and New Zealand Communications. Although the vendor was initially aggressive about WiMAX, it believes this is not a US opportunity, since it missed out at Sprint, and is targeting its 802.16 efforts at emerging markets and alternative operators. Overall, Huawei saw orders leap by 45% last year, recording global contract sales worth about $16bn (these are contracts signed, not revenues. Huawei is privately owned and does not need to adopt public accounting methods).