Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

9 April 2008

ICO launches satellite to support mobile TV ambitions and Clearwire alliance

Although the US mobile TV market is widely thought to have been sewn up by Qualcomm’s MediaFLO, which has been adopted (for now at least) by both Verizon Wireless and AT&T, there are many chances remaining for other technologies to make an inroad. Sprint Nextel may well use NextWave’s WiMAX-based MXtv, much touted at the CTIA show, for Xohm, and AT&T’s long term commitment to FLO is not assured (see Wireless Watch April 1 2008). T-Mobile has tested DVB-H, the main standard in other parts of the world, notably Europe, and now mobile satellite provider ICO Global Communications is making the most concrete moves so far to show off the capabilities of DVB-SH, a satellite/terrestrial variant of DVB-H largely conceived by Alcatel-Lucent.

ICO is one of four mobile satellite operators looking to move out of their emergency services and extreme rural niches and into mainstream wireless services, by using hybrid terrestrial/satellite networks (greatly improving the economics of satellite) and by tapping into new markets such as mobile TV (see Wireless Watch March 11 2008). By blazing a trail, they hope to attract major radio-based partners for wholesale or joint venture activities, and one potential match for ICO is immediately apparent ‘ Clearwire, which shares its major backer, Craig McCaw, the greatest weaver of wireless webs and alliances, with ICO. The two companies have already worked on mobile TV tests using a combination of DVB-SH and WiMAX and will now collaborate on full trials.

The heat is on ‘ the far larger Inmarsat is already in talks with Verizon, AT&T and T-Mobile USA about a possible deal where they could use its hybrid network for additional services such as rural video, and has made common cause with hybrid specialist MSV; while Terrestar received an injection of funds earlier this year from satellite TV major EchoStar, whose arms-length operator Dish Network also acquired major 700MHz spectrum in the recent auction, pointing to some major new service plans from the company some time soon. Terrestar has been working on WiMAX/satellite technology trials with Nokia Siemens, while MSV has been in WiMAX tests with Nortel. ICO has been lower profile in terms of partnerships, but is getting on with the business of proving the technology to McCaw and others (no doubt with its eyes on the possible prize of a Sprint deal, alongside or instead of MXtv, should Clearwire and the Sprint Xohm operation fulfil their objective of a joint venture).

ICO will launch a $500m satellite into space on Monday, looking to provide nationwide DVB-SH (digital video broadcast-satellite handheld) services and emulate the commercial success in the US of satellite radio. First trials will take place in Las Vegas and Raleigh, North Carolina, in June or July, working with Clearwire. ICO pointed to spectral efficiency as one of the greatest benefits of the technology, as well as the ability to cover remote areas. John Leonard, president of applications and business at Alcatel-Lucent, said trials have produced twice the spectral efficiency of the technology’s terrestrial cousin DVB-H and better (by an unspecified amount) than MediaFLO. ICO has signed with Alcatel-Lucent to provide software to manage content, the programming guide and interactive components for multiple screens, and which will work with multiple access technologies, and provide an identical experience on any device. Its first target will not be handsets but in-car systems, echoing the model of the satellite radio broadcasters, and larger portable video devices ‘ indeed, ICO executives steered clear of talking much about cellphones, and instead harked repeatedly to the satellite radio business, comparing the addressable market for the ICO system, via its hoped-for carrier partners, to that sector, which boasts 17m subscribers.

On the programming side, Alcatel-Lucent is taking a different line to that of Qualcomm with MediaFLO, leaving most of the content deals and choices to the carriers. Leonard claims this gives greater flexibility to support whichever business models the immature market evolves to demand. ‘MediaFLO is a predefined business model in the way it operates,’ he said at the media launch of the ICO satellite, yet he feels no business model has been proven or even fully defined yet for mobile TV.

With Clearwire and potentially a Clearwire-Sprint venture in its sights, ICO has been conducting trials with its stablemate since September. The pilots have aimed to test the value proposition and cost effectiveness of delivering an advanced interactive mobile video service to consumers, and to study the technical feasibility of using Clearwire’s 2.5GHz spectrum and ICO’s 2GHz mobile satellite/hybrid spectrum more efficiently in combination. It is worth remembering that, although EchoStar has now invested in ICO rival Terrestar, the satellite broadcaster, and DirecTV, are also part of the Clearwire ecosystem, with cross-marketing agreements. Clearwire will now move from inhouse pilots to anchoring the Las Vegas and Raleigh trials.

Clearwire ‘ like Sprint ‘ is interested in the possibility of delivering interactive video and broadcast TV over WiMAX rather than relying on an additional or third party network such as MediaFLO. Bringing satellite into the equation could help to extend coverage and functionality rapidly, especially in areas where Clearwire does not want to build out itself. ‘Our next generation wireless personal broadband networks are built to deliver data, voice and video over a single network,’ said Scott Richardson, chief strategy officer for Clearwire. ‘Working with ICO to trial an interactive mobile video element that can potentially enhance our service offering not only in areas where we don’t intend to build our own network, but that can also potentially enhance the use of infrastructure and spectrum where our coverage overlaps, makes a lot of sense.’

‘Mobile two-way video, advanced interactive navigation, plus emergency calling and messaging becomes an even more compelling value proposition when integrated with a wireless broadband network such as Clearwire’s,’ said Tim Bryan, CEO at ICO, in September.

Elektrobit’s hybrid handset:

Elektrobit of Finland claimed the world’s first reference design for a combined satellite/terrestrial handset, showing the platform ‘ co-developed with Terrestar ‘ at CTIA.

“After Hurricane Katrina hit, wiping out all the cellular base stations, there has been a lot of interest in dual-use handsets that can access satellite services whenever cellular towers go out of service. We have the first reference design that OEMs can use to actually build such handsets,” said Jani Lyrintzis, director of the Finnish company’s professional terminals business.

The handset has a touchscreen and full Qwerty keyboard. It uses Infineon chipsets for the radio link and satellite chips from Hughes Network Systems.

Elektrobit also showed off two other reference designs for OEMs ‘ the Mobile Internet Multimedia Device, based on Intel’s Menlo processor and Windows CE, and with support for cellular and Wi-Fi links; and the Mobile WiMAX smartphone design created in partnership with NextWave. This uses NextWave’s own chipset.