The FCC is weighing its options for block D of the 700MHz band, which failed to attract its reserve price in the recent auction. Many campaigners are still calling for the regulator to persist with its plan for a national public/private network for public safety, but with clearer rules and less upfront cost. Meanwhile, one of the early players in the game, Cyren Call, denied that it was responsible for the demise of Frontline Wireless, the most likely winner of the D block, on the eve of the auction; while others are trying to come up with more innovative approaches, notably stratellite proponent Space Data, which uses balloons to provide a cross between satellite and terrestrial services across rural areas.
Public safety lobbyists say that the FCC should resurrect its idea for the D block, but offer far more detail on what the project would cost, how it should be structured and what revenues it might generate, as well as more technical information about building and operating the network.
The D block received a single bid of $472m from Qualcomm, far short of the $1.3bn reserve price. To create the national network, FCC had ordered that a 10MHz portion of the block be shared by public safety and commercial users, with first responders having priority during major emergencies. The winning bidder was to negotiate the sharing arrangement with the Public Safety Spectrum Trust, a group designated by the FCC. On March 19, advocacy groups asked the FCC to investigate allegations that an official adviser to the spectrum trust (Morgan O’Brien, chairman of Cyren Call) may have scared off bidders by stating that the winning bidder would pay as much as $500m in fees over 10 years as a cost of operating the network. The public bidding documents mentioned a fee but did not specify the amount, but operating the network would be handled by an entity nominated by the FCC, likely Cyren Call, for a fee.
If the auction is held again, the regulator will need to disclose upfront all potential costs and how much public safety groups are likely to pay for the network, and also give the winner more legal control of the network.
For its part, Cyren Call said last week that it never demanded long term payments as a condition for a winning bidder of the 700MHz D block license, and therefore was not responsible for the loss of investor confidence in Frontline. ‘Anyone stating or implying that I or any member of Cyren Call or the Public Safety Spectrum Trust ‘demanded’ a spectrum lease payment is lying. Furthermore, anyone suggesting that any spectrum lease payment would be paid to Cyren Call is lying,’ said O’Brien. The body acknowledged that in conversations with potential bidders, it presented an estimate of $50m a year when asked about the spectrum lease payment likely to be requested by the PSST during negotiations over a network sharing agreement. However, O’Brien said this was not dismissed by potential bidders as unrealistic, and rejected claims that the $50m would have been recurring, and so totalling $500m over the 10-year license period.
Any winning bidder, if the FCC reauctions later this year as planned, will be looking for technologies that best enable it to service public safety requirements of ubiquity, interoperability and reliability, at realistic cost. Mobile satellite interests hope that the new hybrid terrestrial/satellite (ATC) technologies they are introducing will fit the bill, allowing remote areas to be covered by satellite and others by cheaper radio, but Space Data has another solution. Stratellites or high altitude balloons have been used since the 1930s for communications and have been periodically given some limelight as possible solutions to affordable access in remote areas, but have failed to gain significant commercial traction. However, Space Data, the leading proponent of this approach (along with Sanswire, now owned by the controversial operator GlobeTel), sees 700MHz as a golden opportunity.
It currently offers services mainly to oil and gas sectors in the southwest US, as well as to the US Air Force, and is looking for contracts in the safety and enterprise markets. It has raised $75m in funding and has about 100 employees.
According to RCRnews, cell sites cost about $250,000. Space Data pays $50 to launch a balloon and $100 to retrieve electronics (valued at $1,500) that parachute to the ground for reuse after the 24-hour life of each balloon expires. One balloon 100,000 feet high covers a 420-mile diameter circle, so it would take 41 SkySites for national machine-to-machine wireless connectivity, or over 200 SkySites for nationwide wireless voice coverage across the US. The SkySites work with all major wireless technologies and handsets, says the company, which is the largest holder of nationwide narrowband PCS spectrum, and now has 21 new iDEN-capable channels ‘ a possible fit with Sprint, which has been rumored to be interested in spinning off Nextel’s iDEN network to public safety agencies. Space Data also holds AWS licenses in the Gulf of Mexico and Alaska.
The company did not bid directly in the 700MHz auction, however, but aims instead to be an infrastructure provider to spectrum holders, especially in the D block, when that is snapped up, but potentially also to support rural services for commercial holders in other blocks ‘ with Space Data operating and owning the network in the partner’s spectrum, and the revenues shared. This is a model that is becoming increasingly common in emerging markets with large rural areas, such as Russia, where it has been adopted by some WiMAX providers. Space Data claims it can achieve up to 100% coverage with SkySites for 700MHz A, B, C, D and E blocks. “People say they have a national network. Well, they don’t really have a nation network,” chief strategy officer Jim Wiesenberg told RCRnews. “They have a national dense population network. They don’t have a national network; they don’t cover the low density areas.” He claims his company could save a new national wireless player $2bn, or construction of 8,500 new towers across the country, in order to create a national public safety network in D block, complying with the current FCC build-out deadlines and coverage mandates.
Google, with its interest in any technology that will extend low cost internet access, is said to have invested in Space Data earlier this year, and there have been recent rumors ‘ all meeting with ‘no comment’ from the smaller company ‘ that Google might even be interested in cooperating on building a balloon network, or even acquiring Space Data (though like all speculation that Google aims to build its own networks, using any of various technology choices, our response is ‘why would they, and why only in the US?’).