All eyes are on the UK’s forthcoming 2.6GHz auction because it will set precedents for similar sales around western Europe, but also because it represents one of the only realistic opportunities for WiMAX to gain a tier one carrier deployment in this UMTS-dominated region, where the cellcos are likely to gain the lion’s share of ‘4G’ licenses in the 2.5GHz region, and will logically follow the UMTS-to-LTE migration route. The importance of British Telecom – one of the few incumbents with no wireless arm, and an avowed supporter of WiMAX ‘ gaining a license was only highlighted last week when its Norwegian counterpart, Telenor, which has been a very active triallist of 802.16 technology, indicated it was nevertheless leaning towards LTE.
Telenor has used WiMAX for some DSL equivalent services in rural areas and has been more active than many European operators in testing mobile WiMAX, but it is likely to remain in the LTE mainstream for its mobile operations. ‘As an incumbent we see LTE as the most promising technology at this time ‘ it comes from the 3G family and is therefore in keeping with HSPA,’ said Berit Svendsen, head of product and IS at Telenor, addressing the Telecom World Congress in London. She explained that the company is currently rolling out WiMAX infrastructure to provide fixed wireless internet access in remote areas, but is growing its HSPA coverage in order to provide mobile broadband.
‘We are keeping both options open but we have a strong bias towards the 3GPP family. We don’t want to have to invest heavily in both, we do have capex requirements,’ said Svendsen. She echoed the opinions of many observers in saying that there is little to choose between the two ‘4G’ technologies on a technical level, but LTE is more assured of broad industry support and the economics this delivers. ‘We believe mobile WiMAX can play a role but only if the industry supports it,’ she said. In the medium term, she shares Vodafone’s belief that there should be convergence of the two platforms, in terms of devices, core networks and standards.
However, she sees no role for LTE in fixed broadband. ‘The fixed broadband market in Norway is very advanced. We are using DSL, fiber and WiMAX to deliver good services and we don’t see that we will need LTE,’ she said.
This is being borne out in many areas of Europe, where in contrast to the situation in 2.5GHz, there is rapid expansion of WiMAX in 3.5GHz, mainly for fixed and nomadic applications, though some regulators are increasingly willing to permit mobile hand-off in the traditionally fixed-only band as the boundaries between broadband and mobility blur. Some providers, like UK Broadband, are demonstrating the feasibility of delivering mobile services even in a frequency as high as 3.5GHz, using new techniques like smart antennas, and offsetting the larger requirement for cell sites with the lower cost of spectrum.
The main driver of WiMAX expansion in this region, however, is the provision of fixed broadband to underserved areas, and the addition of nomadic laptop-based options to enhance fixed-only models and allow for metrozone and roaming deployments. In Italy, which earlier this year was one of the last major European economies to open up 3.5GHz, the first deployment of 802.16 will go live in June, with a build-out in the city of Bari by AFT-Linkem, one of the successful bidders for 3.5GHz licenses in February. The company spent €34m on its spectrum and is working in Bari with local cable TV operator Telebari ‘ a model it intends to pursue in other areas to spread cost and risk and offer a fixed-mobile convergence bundle, and potentially a full quad play, via partnerships. AFT-Linkem expects the network in Bari, which has a heavy concentration of small to medium enterprises and academic institutions (both prime user bases for wireless broadband), to cost about €50m.
AFT-Linkem intends to build WiMAX networks in all 13 regions where it was awarded frequencies, including Lazio, Piedmont, Lombardy, Veneto, Sicily, Sardinia, Umbria, Molise, Abruzzo, Campania, Puglia, Calabria and Basilicata. It is a subsidiary of AFT, and includes Group Sopaf and US-based Ramius Capital Group among its shareholders. AFT Linkem has been building wireless networks in Italy since 2001, mainly hotspots in airports and hotel chains, plus wireless broadband services for 350 municipalities.
In a longer established WiMAX market, France, Altitude Telecom – now part of the Iliad group and the original holder of a national 3.5GHz license ‘ plans to double the number of base stations in its network this year to 600. In its target underserved areas, it has seen subscriptions rise steeply, with a current run rate of over 600 new sign-ups per month, from both businesses and individuals. ‘Since the beginning of the year, we’ve seen a real increase in demand. This increase is due to the fact that we deploy networks in areas that are not covered by ADSL,’ said CEO Jean-Paul Riviere. ‘With several thousand subscribers, WiMAX is no longer in the experimental stage.’