Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 April 2008

US mobile TV market fragments further with Dish Network trial

A year ago, the US mobile TV market looked set to be dominated ‘ sailing against the current of world standards – by Qualcomm’s MediaFLO system, which had been selected by Verizon Wireless and AT&T. Now the territory is, in fact, one of the most hotly contested in the world, as at least five technologies battle for operator favors, and even the MediaFLO users do not look certain to stick permanently with their first choice.

The latest to make its move is satellite TV provider Dish Network, which recently bought up large amounts of 700MHz spectrum (the same band in which MediaFLO runs, and for which Qualcomm also purchased additional licenses ‘ see Wireless Watch April 2 2008). Dish is partnering with Alcatel-Lucent to test the French giant’s DVB-SH hybrid satellite/terrestrial mobile TVtechnology, an extension of the DVB-H standard. Dish said the will take place in its lab in Atlanta beginning next month, using equipment, terminals and services from the vendor, and it hopes to validate the performance and cost efficiency of the technology by August. DVB-SH is already being trialled by mobile satellite firm ICO in partnership with Clearwire, its stablemate in the Craig McCaw-controlled empire, and ICO has already launched a $500m commercial satellite to support its project, which it hopes will emulate the US success of satellite radio.

DVB-SH can be used in any frequency below 3GHz, including UHF, L-Band and S-Band, and in terrestrial, satellite or hybrid networks. Dish, which split into a separate trading company from parent EchoStar in January, holds 168 licenses for 6MHz of unpaired spectrum in channel 56 within 700MHz, across 76% of the US population. When it acquired its spectrum, it was widely speculated that it would use it to leverage its mobile capabilities through Sling Media, the placeshifting pioneer which EchoStar/Dish bought for $380m last year.

While Dish’s trial is at the earliest stage, and the provider remains cagey about its intentions, there are other mobile TV technologies vying for position. Importantly, two
powerful groupings are chasing what may well prove to be the key US standard for mobile TV, ATSC-M/H ‘ a backwards compatible extension of the existing Advanced Television Systems Committee platform, to bring mobility to the standard.

At the recent National Association of Broadcasters (NAB) conference in Las Vegas, the rival groups (see Wireless Watch July 9 2007) were showcasing their approaches and pronouncing their readiness for mass mobile TV take-up in 2009. Both had demonstrations of the technology live around Las Vegas, to prove that transmitters 25 miles distant from the city, could reach every part of it.

Lined up on one side is the US favored transmitter company Harris, strong among free-to-air broadcasters, and aligned with Zenith, the US company that introduced the VSB signaling technology that underpins the ATSC standard. Zenith is owned by LG Electronics, the third member of the team. They call their implementation Mobile Pedestrian Handheld (MPH). Opposing them is a more globally influential group, but with less local US presence ‘ Samsung; Germany’s Rohde and Schwarz (the transmitter company that has more than its fair share of mobile TV installations around the world); supported by Nokia Siemens Networks, MobiTV, and SES Americom.

At NAB, Harris named new partners in EXPway, Envivio and UDcast, all of whom are household names in mobile TV installations round the world. Harris has met these companies in overseas trials, mostly for DVB-H, and has formed bonds with them. The other new Harris partner is Triveni Digital, which has added a new station-side software platform to the equation. The entire system is said to be ready to install by this fall.
UDcast said it has a system for delivering mobile TV over a WiMAX nework, with a combination of multicast and broadcast channels, though there were few details (TV over WiMAX is also promised by NextWave’s recently announced MXtv system).

The Harris group has a bigger vision for how mobile TV and MPH will fit into the US landscape ‘ talking of channel change spots for advertising and channel promotions, and using the IP transport layer not just to offer an electronic services guide, but also to add voting, e-commerce, digital signage updates and public safety announcements. Harris also said that it was a long way into discussions with Nielsen Media over audience measurement capabilities for MPH, and expected it to launch with those capabilities.

LG Electronics had two handsets ready, and although these appeared to have external four- inch antennas, there is a clear mission to have internal antenna by the time these devices go into the field. GPS would soon be added to the mix, supporting mobile TV on non-handsets, and of course in-car devices, which are expected through Kenwood, strong in the US automotive aftermarket. There was also the mention of an internet tablet coming to the market with MPH, and those that device category is most intimately associated with Nokia, this time the speakers were probably referring to a parallel LG planned product.

Jumping over to the other camp much of the same was on offer, but perhaps because it was coming from companies not quite so integrated into the broadcasting community in the US, it came over as slightly less well prepared and a less fully considered strategy. However, this group has more global power than the Harris-LG combination, and great lobbying power to sway standards bodies, as well as huge technological expertise, so it may well swing the vote and end up with its implementation, A-VSB, initially proposed by Samsung, as the US technology winner.

The group said that its platform is complete and ready to go, and that the broadcast equipment comes integrated with the OMA BCAST service layer, which is already a global standard. OMA BCAST defines the higher level software protocols within the handset that will work with the A-VSB physical layer, and many mobile TV services around the world, especially those considering DVB-H, are expected to use BCAST too.

Rohde and Schwarz also announced the necessary test equipment (as did Harris) to test that signals are standard compliant, along with new ranges of gap fillers that help build a constant signal strength in a territory, compatible with ATSC, MediaFLO, DVB-T or H and other global TV standards.

We asked Harris president Tim Thorsteinson what would happen if his company got pipped at the post by the rival proposal. ‘You will have noticed that we have a new digital exciter, and that it is software driven, rather than our old MPH exciter which was hardwired,’ he said. ‘This means that we can offer a different software stack that works with the rival standard around 90 days later than our own offering, if the vote goes that way.’

If the two standards proposals are that close together, it makes you wonder why the two consortia cannot sit down and agree a compromise and save all that important time, to ensure they are both ready for digital switchover in February 2009. It is clear that the broadcasting community is going to have to attract the US cellcos to the ATSC-M/H standard once it is approved, in order to get them to stock and subsidize devices which can receive it. No effort to sell mobile TV around the world has ever worked without the blessing of cellular operators, and their absence would be a huge setback for this standard. But getting AT&T or Verizon interested in taking part is going to be infinitely harder if the devices can only support one of these standards and view half of the TV channels. Of course it may be the case that both Samsung and LG can adapt their chips, radios and devices to pick up both service types, but no-one has said that, and it seems an unnaturally divisive route to go down for a standards body.

One thing that could reduce the importance of the involvement of AT&T or Verizon is to come up with a plug-in device – as NextWave has done for other mobile TV systems – which attaches to existing handsets and delivers mobile TV to them cheaply. Either Samsung or LG (or NextWave) could do that and open the floodgates whether the cellcos are on board or not.

This analysis was originally published in Faultline, Wireless Watch’s sister title, which offers weekly insights into the digital media markets and the economics of the quad play. Please contact Peter White on [email protected] for more details.