Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

14 May 2008

Cablecos weigh wireless options, but Clearwire principals turn in losses

In the wake of the creation of the ‘new Clearwire’, the WiMAX joint venture between Sprint Nextel and the original Clearwire, both partners announced big quarterly losses, but amid a climate of opinion that was turning in their favor, with some analysts even predicting a Sprint turnaround this year. Meanwhile, the cablecos that were not included in the Clearwire venture ‘ which is backed by Time Warner, Comcast and Brighthouse, as well as Google and Intel ‘ were trying to reassure investors that they do have wireless strategies of their own, with Cox taking a risk on building its own network; Cablevision (like T-Mobile USA) turning to Wi-Fi; and Chartered hinting that it would welcome an invitation to join Clearwire.

In its first quarter, Sprint Nextel continued to haemorrhage customers, losing over a million in the three months, and reported a 9% year-on-year decline in wireless revenues to just under $8bn, and losses of $505m, with $253m of those in wireless. Total revenues were down 8% to $9.33bn. Despite these horrible numbers, the quarter was actually in line with, or better than, Wall Street predictions, and this small sign of hope sent the stock up briefly, before falling by 26 cents or 2.8%, and led some observers to predict an imminent turnaround.

Sprint ended the quarter with 52.8m subscribers- 39.7m postpaid, 4.4m prepaid and 8.7m from wholesale and affiliates. Though it had lost almost a million customers from iDEN and 100,000 from CDMA during the period, and warned of similar levels of defections to come in Q2, it had not lost quite the 1.2m it had warned of (though by sad contrast, Verizon Wireless and AT&T Mobility added about one million apiece). Also, most of the losses are still coming from the most valuable portion of a cellco’s base, postpaid users, as well as from wholesale, and worryingly, the main reason for the fall-off being slightly less than expected was a surprising level of resilience on iDEN. Though a slowing of iDEN defections would be welcome, the virtual collapse of that service and need to transfer its users quickly to CDMA is now accepted and built into Sprint’s value, and it is far more concerning that the CDMA and wholesale losses were worse than predicted, since these are ongoing core businesses. The latter will worsen later this year following Qwest’s decision to transfer its MVNO contract to Verizon Wireless ‘ though the early move into supporting MVNOs was a key factor in Sprint’s last turnaround, prior to the Nextel merger, the company is now suffering from the collapse of some start-up virtual operators such as ESPN Mobile, and from the new competitiveness of Verizon in this market.

However, among the analysts who were cheered by small blessings was Cowen & Co, which rated Sprint ‘outperform’ and said the operator ‘may be on the verge of turning around’ before year end. However, the high rating was largely based on hopes of a sale to Deutsche Telekom (see Wireless Watch April 7 2008).

Digging into the detail, more than 35.5m subscribers are not using Sprint’s CDMA network, 15.7m are on iDEN, and 1.6m are using dual-mode handsets to access both, a disappointingly low uptake of what should have been an important transition option, especially for those clinging to the original (and most say, still the best) push to talk service, the highlight of iDEN. This quarter will see the first impact of the CDMA implementation of push to talk, Qchat, which is critical to the Sprint recovery plan, and to try to encourage users not to defect to other operators that are now offering PTT too. In Q1, postpaid churn was 2.45%, up slightly from the 2.3% of a year earlier. The company also reported heavier losses from its Boost prepaid internal MVNO, with a churn rate of 9.9%, up from the 7.5% reported in Q407. While the carrier lost 500,000 Boost iDEN customers, it did gain 300,000 Boost CDMA customers ‘ the latter is an unlimited local service designed to challenge flat rate carriers Leap and MetroPCS.

Postpaid ARPU on CDMA was almost $56, down about $2 year-on-year, while iDEN ARPU fell by about $6. Prepaid ARPU was about $29, down from $32 a year earlier. Data revenues grew 19% overall to an average of $11.50 per customer per month.

Unlike some of its larger rivals, Sprint increased its wireline revenues slightly, by 2% to $1.6bn, driven by enterprise IP services, which saw annual revenue growth of 44%. As well as promising further wireline growth, Sprint stressed the capex savings it would enjoy from spinning off the Xohm WiMAX initiative into the Clearwire joint venture. It
reported a capital outlay of $236m on Xohm during the first quarter. “Under our agreement with Clearwire, Sprint expects our expenditure to be reimbursed from now until the close… which is expected in the second half of the year,” stated the company.

CEO Dan Hesse tried to play down rumors that Sprint would spin off the iDEN operation, perhaps to a public safety agency to form the basis of the much needed national wireless network for US emergency response. He said that, although the iDEN base saw a 26% year-on-year decline, Sprint was making improvements in marketing and devices ‘ including plans to launch a Wi-Fi/iDEN BlackBerry ‘ rather than giving up on the former Nextel business prematurely. He said it would be very complex to spin off iDEN, though added that “nothing is off the table completely’.

Over at Sprint’s JV partner Clearwire, the WiMAX operator reported a massive first quarter loss, justified at least in part by growing revenues and subscriber numbers, and of course by the economies and broader vision that will be supported by the enlarged and better funded ‘new Clearwire’. In its first quarter, the ‘old Clearwire’ reported a net loss of $176.4m, or $81.2m on an adjusted EBITDA basis, on revenue up 76% year-on-year to $51.5m.

Clearwire added over 48,000 net new subscribers in the first quarter to end the quarter with 443,000 users, up 72% on the year before, while ARPU was up about $1 to $36.86, mainly on the back of increased use of VoIP. Capital spending fell to $53.1m from $74.4m a year earlier, because of Clearwire’s decision last fall to slow its expansion in the second half of 2007 and into 2008. Clearwire did not add any new markets in the first quarter of 2008, but said its focus had been on “improving operating efficiency and profitability in its existing markets, and preparing to launch its initial mobile WiMAX enabled markets later in 2008′ ‘ and of course, on holding fire until the joint venture could finally be created, rewriting the plan in terms of funding and roll-out schedule, assuming it is ratified by year end.

While participation in Clearwire looks like a clear plus for the three cableco partners, offering a relatively low risk, low cost route to wireless and the quad play, some are determined to plow their own furrows ‘ even Cox, which was formerly the fourth cable member of the first Sprint partnership, Pivot. Cox is now looking to take the huge risk and investment of building its own network in the 700MHz spectrum it bought in the recent auction, a venture about which it remains secretive so far, and in which its shareholders may well be hoping it will recruit network partners of its own, with T-Mobile a possible candidate. In a recent research note, UBS said Cox would spend ‘less than $100m a year’ on building out CDMA and later LTE, using kit from Huawei. It owns 14 regional licenses covering most of its cable territory and beyond, but would need a roaming deal with another CDMA operator to gain national and international services ‘ which could bring it back to Sprint Nextel.

Cablevision is taking an approach that sounds almost retro, given the recent disappointment in wireless mesh as the basis for metrozone networks to challenge incumbent telcos and potentially provide a partner network for cablecos. The New York and Connecticut provider plans to erect a Wi-Fi canopy over its entire footprint, as a wireless overlay to its HFC network, a project that will take two years to complete. It will then offer free wireless access to its data subscribers, an approach already adopted in assorted variations by some DSL operators, like AT&T, and even cellcos, like T-Mobile. However, these bundles of free wireless with broadband or mobile services have mainly relied on a network of hotspots, which may be variable in coverage, while by building the Wi-Fi itself, Cablevision is guaranteeing access throughout its territory ‘ though of course, this will not provide the benefits of mobile roaming outside the zone for travelling subscribers, unless it signs roaming deals with a major Wi-Fi operator like T-Mobile USA.

There is logic to its thinking, though most broadband operators that have relied too heavily on Wi-Fi rather than true mobility have seen marginal benefits (example, British Telecom). However, half of Cablevision’s TV customers are already broadband internet subscribers and half of these users already have Wi-Fi in their homes. With free wider area Wi-Fi access available, Cablevision has removed one major incentive for these customers to buy a mobile broadband package from Verizon or AT&T. And the cost and risk is far less than that of Cox or Clearwire ‘ Cablevision estimates a cost of $70 per home passed to support 1.5Mbps internet and voice. However, it will also have to cope with the quality of service issues that are inherent to Wi-Fi because of its unlicensed spectrum, however well planned and controlled the mesh.

For vendors, this will be a welcome revival of interest in carrier class Wi-Fi mesh, and likely suppliers could be Motorola, already well established among cablecos through its set-top boxes; Cisco, which has the Cable ServiceMesh platform; or a start-up such as BelAir, which created a cable technology advisory committee in 2006 to develop wireless networks optimized for integration with hybrid fiber/coax networks.

With many of the cablecos fighting hard to achieve a quad play and protect their bases from the onslaught of the telcos, Charter Communications is still weighing up its options. It seems likely to go for partnership rather than build-out, but CEO Neil Smit, speaking at a first quarter results conference call, would only say: ‘We will continue to test our way into it, and try to determine what offering – whether it’s voice or broadband or any other offering the consumer accepts well. We are working on some different relationships.” He also said Charter would be ‘running some tests” related to Clearwire connection. “We are looking into that, but at this point, we have not been approached… as to a partnership.” By contrast, Mediacom Communications’ CEO Rocco Commisso said last week that it was ‘just a matter of time before we get involved’ with Clearwire.