Google is behaving like a spurned suitor, casting doubts on Verizon Wireless’ commitment to opening up its new networks ‘ perhaps a case of sour grapes, since the US’ number two cellco is close to announcing a new open platform deal, but with the LiMo Foundation, not with Google’s own Linux-based offering, Android.
According to wireless analyst service Unstrung, Verizon Wireless will soon follow up on openness pledges made last fall by announcing its first cellphones based on the Mobile Linux would-be standard from LiMo, one of the various vendor groupings seeking to gain control of the emerging market for open access mobile networks and services. The Android initiative, spearheaded by Google and supported by the Open Handset Alliance, is another major contender, though both groups share some members in common.
Verizon has an open access mandate for the 700MHz national license it bought in the recent US auction, but this will not start to be built out (mainly with LTE) until well into 2009. In the mean time, the operator has sought to draw the sting out of the tail of the fully open mobile internet drive ‘ which threatens the traditional cellco profit model and has been led by Google and Intel ‘ by making openness promises of its own. While these are certainly lukewarm compared to the fully blown open access vision touted by Google, they do represent real progress compared to the walled gardens. In November, Verizon said it would open up its CDMA network to third party devices and applications ‘ subject to testing for security and so on ‘ from later this year, and held a developer conference to support its claims. It will start testing unlocked devices and open apps for its network from the end of May and is likely to make its LiMo announcement at the same time, stealing some of the thunder from the enlarged Clearwire, the most advanced exponent of true open mobile internet models in the US, and recently bolstered by new investment and new devices like the Nokia WiMAX internet tablet.
Moves to openness by Verizon and AT&T are partly a PR ploy, and both carriers have made it clear they expect the majority of subscribers voluntarily to stay within the operator environment to gain the advantages of subsidized handsets and ease of use. However, as well as being forced to embrace key attributes of the internet model, such as flat rate data, there are real benefits for the operators too. Open source phones should allow Verizon to attract more new applications and get them running more quickly and cheaply, luring a new class of users and reducing the impact of Clearwire on the consumers that are demanding a full, unfettered web experience on the phone or other mobile device.
The LiMo Foundation seeks to unify the fragmented efforts behind Mobile Linux standards, and create broad standards from operating system to higher software layers and user interface. Politically, it is set against Android and the Nokia efforts, and its main founding backers are Motorola, NTT DoCoMo, Samsung and Vodafone. In February it unveiled its first wave of LiMo handsets, with 18 models from seven vendors, and so far has a clear time to market advantage over Android, though Verizon will have the option to support more than one open platform.
Meanwhile, Google has petitioned the FCC to obtain a guarantee from Verizon Wireless that the operator will honor its commitment to open access. The search giant’s filing raises concerns that Verizon is not fully dedicated to the open access mandate for its Block C of 700MHz spectrum.
“Action now is especially necessary given the long lead time typically required for software applications developers and device manufacturers to design, develop, and deploy their products to the public, as well as the uncertainty Verizon has introduced publicly regarding its compliance with the open access obligations,” Google’s lawyers wrote. It refers to Verizon’s filing last fall of a lawsuit to force the FCC to abandon the open access rules, in which the operator also proposed a two-tiered approach to the C Block, allowing sales of both locked and unlocked devices. But two months later came Verizon’s ‘Any Apps Any Device’ initiative, and there is little evidence the company plans to go back on its 700MHz commitments.
Google’s petition says: “Verizon has taken the public position that it may exclude its handsets from the open access condition. Verizon believes it may force customers who want to access the open platform using a device not purchased from Verizon to go through ‘Door No. 1’, while allowing customers who obtain their device from Verizon access through ‘Door No. 2.’.’The open access condition would apply to none of Verizon’s customers, and thereby render the condition a nullity.’