The race to take the lead in shaping the mobile internet market and value chain is well underway, with carriers, content providers, device makers and internet players all seeking to set the agenda. Most of the attention has been on the latter two categories, with frantic activity by phonemakers like Nokia, internet giants like Google and Intel, and companies that bridge the divide, notably Apple. The carriers’ ability to set the rules for the market in their own favor seems more limited, and some, like 3, have already grasped the nettle and reorganized their models around being a bitpipe and riding on other companies’ brands. Others will give in to the internet model less easily, but will they go as far as to acquire a handset business in their own right? Apparently so, if Wall Street talk that AT&T and Vodafone are both considering a bid for Huawei’s cellphone unit proves true. Such a move might seem bizarre ‘ the handset market is very tough for all but the top five, and the carriers have no expertise in this sector. But it would greatly enhance the ability of a large cellco to specify its mobile internet interfaces, services and experience, rather than having to negotiate with handset majors that are increasingly looking to other channels and direct-to-consumer web services of their own.
Whether or not AT&T and/or Vodafone make a move on the Chinese company’s device business, this highlights the latest round in the constant tug-of-war between cellcos and handset makers. The carriers had been used to taking the products the phonemakers presented them with, one factor many, including Vodafone, have blamed for the early failure of 3G handsets to appeal to the users. But over the past five years or so, they have pursued various routes to grasp the upper hand in mobile phone design and branding, reducing the power of the likes of Nokia, improving their own negotiating power, and placing their brands center stage. In the mobile internet, these ambitions become even more important, because the cellcos need to reduce their cost base to support flat rate broadband services, and their main hope of avoiding bitpipe hell rests in establishing their own brands as core in the internet experience, becoming a magnet for content and developer partners as well as devices.
The cellcos’ efforts over the past years have rested mainly on banding together to impose standards, and so improve time to market and purchasing power; and on trying to build up tier two and ODM phonemakers, willing to make handsets to the carriers’ specifications and even on a white label basis. Buying a phonemaker outright would take this strategy a major step further, and give a carrier like AT&T the sort of power that Japanese and Korean cellcos have over their handset makers ‘ in which they often invest directly and carry out joint R&D programs. The main drawback is that the policy of turning to own-brand devices has had only limited success, and has especially failed in the high end, internet-capable phone sector. The combined market share of the top five handset makers has increased steadily, at the expense of the tier two and three players, and many ‘ such as Panasonic and Alcatel-Lucent ‘ have dropped out altogether. And in the mobile internet world, the all-important early adopters, traditionally the most loyal to their initial service providers, have been far more attracted by brands like the iPhone, Sony Ericsson Walkman, HTC Touch or Nokia N95 than by operator brands. This means that the carriers, despite their need for increased influence in the internet, may end up purchasing a business that is mainly geared to a low cost supply of basic phones, rather than the smartphone end of the spectrum.
Huawei apparently decided to put its handset unit on the block a few weeks ago, with private equity players like Blackstone and TPG also showing an interest, and a report in the South China Morning Post speculated it would raise at least $2bn if it offloads the whole division. It is not yet clear whether it will sell the whole business or a majority stake ‘ one possibility is that it will sell a 50%-plus share to a partner like AT&T, keeping a minority in order to gain a new foothold in the US market, which is proving tough for the Chinese vendor. By contrast, it has expanded significantly among European cellcos, though this has mainly been in the infrastructure market, rather than handsets, despite an approved supplier deal with Vodafone across Europe. Its compatriot ZTE has followed a reverse pattern, with most of its infrastructure success in developing markets, but a growing presence in the US device market, especially with CDMA. Huawei now plans to sell off its cellphone, laptop, wireless data card and home router activities, a move partly prompted by the failure of its plan to take a minority stake in US-based network gear maker 3Com, following a backlash from US politicians over company founder Ren Zhengfei’s military background.