Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 May 2008

As carriers look to femtos and core for first LTE spend, Forum agrees standards

With Cisco and then Qualcomm getting serious about femtocells (see Wireless Watch May 22 2008), the tiny base stations are joining the mobile mainstream even before they have got far beyond the initial operator trial stage. Over half of operators looking to deploy LTE in mature markets are keen to invest first in the core, for 3G integration, and in small base stations to support hotzone roll-out in high ARPU areas. This offers a huge opportunity for femtocells, but fulfilling this early potential will require standards, in the interests of interoperability and low pricing, if operators are to turn high interest into committed dollars. One significant step in this direction was announced last week by the technology’s trade body, the Femto Forum, with an agreement on a new, standard interface between the mini-base stations and the gateway to the core.

The Forum has been working since its formation last year on standards for interfacing femtocells to the core network, an area where as many as 15 different approaches (some proprietary) are in use. Early trials have proceeded using the vendor’s chosen interface, in order not to delay the process, but before full commercial implementation, carriers will insist on standards in order to avoid vendor lock-in and help drive down equipment prices to the consumer levels being demanded of femtocells. The Forum has now agreed on the acceptable interfaces and will forward these to the 3GPP for approval within its own femtocell projects for 3G and 4G. Having a clear roadmap, even if full ratification of standards within the 3GPP takes another year (though the Forum members say it will be a matter of months), should give operators greater confidence to move beyond the limited trial phase and commit to larger volumes and deployments.

The Forum is referring to its proposed standard as the ‘Fa interface’, which will connect the base station itself to the femtocell gateway. This will be a modified Iu interface, and exactly which flavor of Iu it will adopt should be finalized this week before submission to the 3GPP. While many vendors use various forms of Iu, most commonly UMA (Unlicensed Mobile Access) or Iub, the Fa interface will not adopt any of these outright, so all suppliers will need to modify their equipment, a process that could take 18 months to full commercial availability. The decision to create, in effect, a new interface, even though Iu-based, at least avoids the controversy that has sometimes surrounded some IEEE standards, which have often adopted a readymade technology and so given the vendors of that system a market headstart (an approach that has caused some of the worst examples of IEEE politicking).

The Forum has also adopted a collapsed architecture, where the Node B and radio network controller functionality are placed in the femtocell access point, to optimize signaling over the broadband connection and create a ‘network in a box’ (a phrase first used in anger by the carrier Wi-Fi community, perhaps inauspiciously).

In transferring call sessions between the local network and the core network, using the broadband connection, the femtocell can use various interfaces, but a fully standardized one will be vital for mass market scaling, with UMA and SIP the main options. Although UMA was designed with unlicensed access in mind, it is not tied to these technologies or to Wi-Fi. It uses open interfaces between the RAN and core, in the shape of Iucs and Iups, and services implemented in the existing core will automatically be available to the femtocells. It offers some advantages over other connectivity options and should be considered as a generic way to link access points to the core, not specific to one wireless network. It offloads as much traffic as possible to the home network – essential to avoid congestion when scaling the RAN to millions of users – and supports the concept of moving the phone around and retaining its ID, a challenge for femtocells.

These days, operators do not just need to see standards support on checklists; they want to influence the creation of those standards to ensure they map to real world deployment needs (and enhance the operators’ power in the relationship with their suppliers), The Next Generation Mobile Network initiative has been the most important operator-driven body, and the Femto Forum is paying due respect to the carriers’ demands by working with the GSMA, the global cellco trade association, on standards. The GSMA will provide mobile operators’ requirements and outline specifications for femtocells to the Forum to be included in its platforms and to ‘ensure that this new technology develops in a way that maximizes its potential to serve mobile users’, as an official statement put it. It went on: ‘Where appropriate, the two groups will also work together to address issues that may affect deployment of femtocells, such as operator security requirements or the regulatory environment.’

In the short term, femtocells can enhance coverage and indoor penetration, and support convergence and mobile broadband at low cost, but many operators see their real potential lying in the 4G stage, where they can help support staged or ‘hotzone’ approaches to mobile broadband build-out, and new types of applications. The operator interest in using femtocells in the very first stage of 4G roll-out will put pressure on the sector to support new standards, notably WiMAX 16e and 16m, and LTE, at the earliest opportunity, since in some cases, carriers are indicating that the first 4G RFPs will focus on femtos and the core.

While 3G deployments in Europe and other mature markets were largely wide area, full coverage networks to overlay or run alongside GSM, 4G patterns will be different and focus for some years on high value, densely populated broadband user bases. This means that 3G integration is vital, with only a selective investment in RAN for areas where there is expected to be user demand and ROI opportunities in stage one. So while 3G roll-outs tended to go first with base stations, and then link these to switches, gateways and so on, 4G operators are looking to start with the core, working on 3G integration, and rolling out access services in limited areas via small base stations, often femtocells. This means they can wait for larger base station formats to be fully ready, and for there to be sufficient choice to drive down prices, but means they want work on the LTE core standards and on LTE femtocells accelerated. In a recent survey of 85 operators planning LTE deployment in at least some (mature) markets before 2012, Rethink Research found that 49 had decided on this approach, provided the industry comes up with the goods on time.

While the vendors and 3GPP are not over-vocal about this issue ‘ Ericsson et al are still clinging to the mirage of mass deployment of macro base stations as early as 2010 ‘ the operators are forcing it on to the table and there is notable effort to speed up the finalization of LTE standards for the core.

On the femtocell side, Qualcomm’s recent interest (taking a stake in femto maker ip.access) may indicate that the company, along with other tier one silicon firms, may be aiming to leap into the femto chip fray at the 4G stage. Ahead of all that, the main femto chipmaker with actual products, picoChip, has unveiled the LTE reference designs it promised at the Mobile World Congress in February. These femto and picocell designs, developed with German partner mimoOn, are based on the same common hardware platform as the picoChip WiMAX reference designs, include PHY and MAC and run in 5MHz and 10MHz channels, and in TDD or FDD mode. picoChip also has a reference design for the Chinese 3G standard TD-SCDMA and will work on one for the 4G extension of that, largely expected to be the basis of the TDD LTE standard.