Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

4 June 2008

Vodafone Italy and Huawei point new way to fixed-mobile convergence

Fixed-mobile convergence has been the centerpiece of major carriers’ growth strategies in the developed telecoms markets for some years, but the approaches, in terms of consumer devices, are various and, in all cases, immature. With Wi-Fi systems showing mixed results and femtocells still over the horizon, Vodafone Italy may be showing off an interim solution that will be of interest to many other providers. This is the Vodafone Station, a Huawei-supplied combination of DSL and Wi-Fi switch/router and 3G USB key, which delivers some of the hoped-for benefits of the indoor 3G base station or femtocell.

Wi-Fi/DSL, united by UMA (Unlicensed Mobile Access), was the first option available for fixed-mobile convergence, though it required dual-mode handsets for hand-off to the wide area network. Its flagship user has been T-Mobile USA, which recently added VoIP to the service to promise a full quad play convergence offering. Other adopters, like BT, have seen less good results, with the UK operator putting its Fusion dual-mode service on the back burner earlier this year. Many operators are now looking to 3G or even 4G femtocells to achieve their business goals, improving indoor penetration and broadband applications support, and backhauling a cellular access point with the user’s DSL line. However, although many cellcos are now trialling femtocells, these devices will not be in the commercial mainstream ‘ with the low pricing that demands ‘ until 2010 or so. In the mean time, then, hybrid solutions like Huawei’s for Vodafone may well gain some short term ground and allow providers to start to experiment with true convergence bundles.

Vodafone, which once crowed over its lack of a wireline legacy to weigh down its growth, now needs convergence and has been partnering with fixed line telcos, such as BT, and buying up fixed broadband companies around Europe (it is widely expected to mount a formal bid for Italian broadband group Tiscali this week). Now its Italian unit is the first to introduce the Vodafone Station, designed to turn the acquisition of fixed lines into a differentiated commercial service. The product will be rolled out across Vodafone’s European broadband footprint (and possibly with fixed line partners in the region too) over the coming one to two years, though the company is also setting high store by femtocells, with its Spanish outfit leading the trials.

The new device, designed specifically for the giant cellco by its increasingly favored Chinese supplier, is basically a switch/router for ADSL2+ that can be shared via fixed Ethernet or Wi-Fi around the home. It also has a removable USB key that adds HSPA service to the box. When turned on, the Station uses HSPA to connect to the Vodafone network and allows seamless switching to the mobile service.

This is not quite a femtocell solution but does bring HSPA into the home, even if this is mainly as a fixed broadband enabler, at this stage at least. Like T-Mobile USA’s VoIP offering, it piggybacks on an existing DSL line to support new services and revenue streams ‘ taking pressure off the wireless backhaul, and at the same time, fending off the challenge from low cost VoIP. Also, where the mobile operator also provides the DSL line, it can ensure better control of the account and its entire telecoms, broadband and home media networking spend. This last is an important goal for cellcos that are aiming to be the primary account controller in the residential market, depriving dedicated fixed line, ISP or VoIP providers. Orange has been particularly aggressive, trialling femtocells, rolling out picocells and dual-mode systems, and working with Thomson and Sagem on would-be operator-managed standards for home media networks.

Initially, mobile operators like Verizon were suspicious of devices that enabled 3G connections to be shared around the home, and frequently barred the use of early products in this area. But, as in Wi-Fi, the carriers quickly realized they could not kill open, shared technologies, but could seek to control them and adapt them for their own business purposes, as Vodafone is now doing.

Femtocells themselves are gaining commercial momentum, and there are some optimistic forecasts around, even while some big names remain cautious ‘ Qualcomm seems to be waiting for LTE, TI is hesitant, most base station makers are wary of cannibalizing their macro cell business. However, operator demand is impossible to ignore, and most mobile equipment makers have at least a partnership to deliver femtocells, with the home networking giants perhaps the most unambivalently enthusiastic. ABI Research, which has been in the forefront of femtocell forecasting, predicts compound annual growth of over 300% between now and 2013, with the market worth $1.8bn at that date. Meanwhile, Forward Concepts believes femtocell vendors will see global revenues growing at a compound annual rate of 126% between 2008 and 2012, reaching $4.9bn at that point, consigning Wi-Fi/UMA to oblivion in the FMC market as early as 2010. The two CAGR figures clearly show the squeeze on prices and margins that will be necessary to get femtocells into the mainstream, and which may require tough adjustments by suppliers and chipmakers. Stuart Carlaw, an analyst at ABI, commented recently: “In order to meet those price declines there is actually a paradoxical need to invest huge sums in designing optimized and dedicated silicon for the femtocell market. Questions of technology, air interface, semiconductor approach, multimodality, integration, route to market, business model, and more all remain unresolved.”

Femtocell standards update:

Industry association Femto Forum announced last week that it had almost finished specifications for a standard interface to link femtocells to the core ‘ something that is currently done using many variations, some proprietary (see Wireless Watch May 28 2008). The so-called Fa interface will be submitted to the 3GPP and is expected to be ratified as a standard under that body’s auspices by the end of the year.

Steve Shaw, head of marketing at Kineto Wireless, points out that the proposed standard is similar to UMA (Unlicensed Mobile Access), also a 3GPP standard and one method of linking femtocells to the core, though it has to date been used mainly for fixed-mobile convergence using dual-mode Wi-Fi/3G. Kineto, which was the driving force behind UMA, was one of the companies responsible for the specifications now being considered by the 3GPP, working with Alcatel-Lucent, NEC and Motorola. Shaw says the end result, the basis of the 3GPP reference architecture for femtocells (or Home Node Bs as the standards organization calls them) blends UMA with elements of an original proposal from Alcatel-Lucent.

Shaw says: ‘The 3GPP HNB architecture follows an access network-based approach which leverages the existing Iu-cs and Iu-ps interfaces into an operator’s core service network. The architecture defines two new network elements, the HNB and the HNB Gateway. Between these elements is the new Iu-h interface.’ The HNB Gateway aggregates traffic from the femtocells back into an existing core service network through the standard Iu-cs and Iu-ps interfaces.