Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

11 June 2008

WiMAX leaders form Open Patent Alliance to keep IPR burden low

One of the key uncertainties surrounding the emerging mobile broadband technologies is the level of royalties that will be applied to LTE or Mobile WiMAX products. This is an important issue to operators, which have complained of high licensing fees inflating the cost of handsets in particular in 2G and 3G. The vendors behind both the new platforms have been keen to reassure carriers that the situation will be different in the next generation, holding out the promise of sufficiently low cost devices to support flat rate internet models and to push into emerging economies with low average GDP. In April, a group of major 3G players agreed on a licensing framework for LTE, and now the WiMAX supporters have followed suit with the formation of the Open Patent Alliance (OPA).

This was created by six key players in 802.16e, although like the LTE group, it will need to attract other majors in order to have real teeth. Predictably, two of the OPA initiators are the foremost WiMAX patent holders, Intel and Samsung, which have been proposing patent pools for OFDM-based technologies for some years, and pushing Wi-Fi style ‘reasonable and non-discriminatory’ licensing via the WiMAX Forum. The other vendors are Alcatel-Lucent ‘ also a founder of the LTE group, and potentially important in pushing for harmonized IPR frameworks across all the OFDM/MIMO platforms ‘ and Cisco, whose presence is important not so much for its patent holdings (though it has some in beamforming via its acquisition of Navini) as for its new willingness to take a major interest in WiMAX, a technology on which it remained cool for a long time. Cisco is always, of course, an important influencer in any technology that could penetrate the enterprise or home network.

The OPA also numbers two operators in its initial line-up. These are the inevitable WiMAX cheerleaders, Clearwire and soon-to-be JV partner Sprint Nextel, but their inclusion is important for sending out signals to the carrier community that their interests will be considered more fully when devising IPR policy for mobile networks this time around. Without operator involvement in licensing groups, these schemes risk attracting insufficient support, and the initiative can pass to operator-driven bodies like the Next Generation Mobile Network (NGMN) Forum. This has been campaigning assiduously to try to influence IPR policies among vendors and regulatory bodies, and operators like Vodafone have been instrumental in pushing rulings in standards organizations that could have more far-reaching impact than patent pools. For instance, Vodafone’s hand was heavy in ETSI’s 2006 rulings that patent holdings should be declared upfront for any technology to be approved by the European standards body.

The OPA may, like many such initiatives, be as much about marketing spin and operator reassurance as real reversal of old licensing practises, but it is part of a tide of change in patents policy that will be impossible to resist, eventually, even by the greatest defenders of the old systems, such as Qualcomm. The OPA sets up a patent pool that promises ‘predictable cost’ of licenses, and claims its key innovation is to provide a more competitive royalty structure by charging only for the features required to develop WiMAX products. ‘The patent pool will incorporate a variety of royalty licensing solutions, including accounting for cross-licensing among individual members within the pool,’ said the group in a statement. It will set up an independent third party ‘patent referee’ to evaluate the relevance of submitted IPR. The Alliance opposes current licensing practices which bundle all features, both necessary and unnecessary, into royalty charges, which raises the bill.

The OPA is clearly lacking some important members, though it says it expects to secure six to nine further investor companies, each with a seat on its board of directors, in the near future. It is unlikely these will include Qualcomm, whose patent claims in WiMAX are vague (beyond a handful of licensing deals with specialist vendors like Soma), but which hints at having extensive OFDM-related IPR through its own developments and its acquisition of Flarion Technologies. A Qualcomm spokesperson said the company would not join the OPA and said that, though patent pools were a ‘valid approach’, the chip giant had ‘consistently preferred to negotiate license agreements bilaterally’. She said the company now had nine licensing agreements with companies using its patents in WiMAX products.

Another likely absentee ‘ and potential major patent holder ‘ is Nortel, which has carried out significant R&D in OFDM and MIMO geared to the Wi-Fi, WiMAX and LTE platforms. Nortel stayed aloof from the LTE patents group, instead saying it would have its own licensing system, rather than joining a group, but claiming this would be consistent and open to all and based on ‘about’ a 1% royalty rate to handset vendors. This implied that Nortel believes that it has significant IPR in LTE that might go under-rewarded in a communal system, and the same could well be true in WiMAX. ‘Nortel believes that pioneers and innovators should be entitled to a reasonable return on their investment in R&D and leading contributions to the next generation standard, where not all patents are created equal,’ said John Hoadley, VP of 4G ecosystem and development at Nortel, in a statement.

The LTE group, as-yet unnamed, aims to develop a framework based on the industry principle of fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory (FRAND) licensing for essential patents. Its major members are the European giants – Nokia Siemens, Nokia, Ericsson, Sony Ericsson and Alcatel-Lucent ‘ plus NEC and NextWave. It wants the maximum aggregate royalty bill in an LTE handset to be a single digit percentage of the sale price (Nokia and Ericsson have pushed, so far unsuccessfully, partly due to their own charges and partly to Qualcomm’s opposition, for a 5% ceiling in 3G. Aggregate royalty fees can represent 25% of a 3G handset’s cost if the manufacturer has no patents of its own to trade).

Given the similarities between LTE and WiMAX technologies, and the prospect that their standards bodies could harmonize their efforts in future, it would be logical for the two licensing initiatives also to converge. As in all aspects of this process, major companies like Intel will be looking to retain a key position of influence even in a merged platform. The OPA said it may work with non-WiMAX groups in the future, applying its new approach to other standards (hence the non-WiMAX specific title), and Intel would aim to be a driver behind this. “Intel’s vision in driving the formation of the Open Patent Alliance is to bring the openness of the internet and computing industries to the wireless industry and WiMAX” said Sriram Viswanathan, VP at Intel Capital and general manager of the chip giant’s WiMAX program. “By facilitating an open intellectual property rights model, we expect the alliance to in turn create a more competitive, innovative and broader WiMAX industry that ultimately benefits the consumer with more choice for WiMAX technology and services.”