After weeks of speculation, France Telecom finally mounted a bid for Scandinavian operator TeliaSonera on Thursday, a move that would create the world’s fourth largest telecoms group (and the largest European one), with operations in 30 countries. However, the bid has already run into trouble, with TeliaSonera rejecting it, analysts blasting the French giant for setting the price ‘ about $42bn ‘ too low, and with France Telecom’s CFO Gervais Pellissier hinting that the operator may walk away from talks if its share price continues to slide. France Telecom’s shares fell in value by 10% after the Thursday announcement, with analysts questioning both the price and the wisdom of the deal.
‘There are two grounds on which we could withdraw the offer,’ Pellissier told French newspaper Le Journal du Dimanche. ‘The first is that it will not be received as friendly by the shareholders and management of TeliaSonera ‘ the second would be the continuation of market turbulence. If our share price continues to plunge, that would make the operation difficult.’ He insisted there were no plans to raise the cash and stock offer, though CEO Didier Lombard, while agreeing that he was prepared to walk away if the bid were not accepted within 15 days, hinted there might be room for flexibility on ‘non-monetary elements’ of the plan.
Telia and its largest shareholder, the Swedish government, also came under fire, notably from the government’s own audit office, which believed Telia should have tried to negotiate a better price rather than rejecting the deal outright.
If the takeover did go through, the stock portion would help reduce France Telecom’s huge debts and also the contentious stake the French government still retains in the carrier. On paper, the deal looks more advantageous to Orange than its prey ‘ for instance, TeliaSonera has an operating margin of 27%, while Orange’s is barely 10%. But French investors have been consistently nervous about the distraction of managing a major merger at a time of huge transition for the carrier, as it moves towards convergence, an upgrade of its networks to all-IP, and the introduction of new services like quad play.
France Telecom has been in expansionist mood lately, though most of its new activities and acquisitions have been geared to emerging markets such as Turkey, Kazakhstan and Tajikistan, and particularly trying to steal a march on other global operators in Africa and the Middle East. Its most recent acquisitions were in Kenya and Jordan, but Telia would bring it valuable footprint in Russia, which is expected to be in the top five growth markets for mobile services in the next few years, but where the leading European and global cellcos have no real footprint.
Buying TeliaSonera would add to the new markets portfolio somewhat, but in general the transaction would go against Orange’s recent strategy of snapping up small companies in emerging territories, and instead be motivated mainly by the need for scale. The combined group would be the fourth largest in the world by revenues, and also number four in mobile by subscribers, and number three in fixed broadband, also by subscribers. The only larger groups by revenue would be AT&T (€87bn in 2007), Verizon (€68bn and now adding Alltel), and Japan’s NTT (€67bn). France Telecom/TeliaSonera had combined revenues of €63 last year, just ahead of Deutsche Telekom. After the German giant, the global premier league would be completed by Telefonica of Spain, Vodafone, Telecom Italia and China Mobile. In 2007, France Telecom was ranked sixth, with revenue of €53bn, compared to Telia’s €10bn. In mobile, the combined French and Nordic carrier would come behind only China Mobile, Vodafone and Telefonica; and in fixed broadband behind just two operators, China Telecom and China Netcom, themselves both set to expand by splitting mobile operator China Unicom between them in the race to convergence.
The main attraction for Orange is the geographical spread it would achieve through merger with TeliaSonera. The French incumbent mainly operates in western Europe, notably France, Spain and the UK (which together make up 70% of group revenues) plus some activities in Belgium and Switzerland, and increasingly important operations in emerging markets in eastern Europe (Poland, Russia, Romania, Slovakia and Moldova); Africa (with mobile networks in 13 markets and plans to deploy WiMAX in even more); the Middle East (Jordan and Bahrain); and Asia-Pacific (China, Korea, Vietnam and Japan). There is also a small amount of business in north and central America, mainly in business or multinational services.
TeliaSonera is the incumbent in Sweden and Finland and also has operations in neighboring states of Norway, Denmark, Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania, plus Spain. It is also highly active in Russia and eastern Europe, with the former a key lure for Orange, which has not yet penetrated this high growth country in any great depth. Telia operates in Kazakhstan, Azerbaijan, Uzbekistan, Tajikistan, Georgia and Moldova and holds major stakes in Russia’s mobile leader MegaFon (43.8%) and in Turkey’s Turkcell (37.3%).
‘The combined portfolio would feature an attractive balance of consolidated assets in western Europe as well as in emerging markets in three key areas, namely eastern Europe/Baltic States, Eurasia, and the Middle East and Africa, noted France Telecom in a statement. Such reach and scale would, it told shareholders, make it easier to launch innovative services quickly and profitably, and work with the best partners and suppliers in hardware, software, content and advertising. It believes that the economies of scale and ‘strengthened negotiating power with regard to network and IT expenditure, handset procurement, R&D and support, as well as traffic optimization’, would generate savings of about $970m a year by 2013, with 70% of that figure achieved by 2011.