Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

25 June 2008

Wi-Lan extends patent suits to Motorola and RIM

Wi-Lan, once an early vendor of WiMAX kit, but now entirely focused on patent licensing, has added Motorola, RIM and UTStarcom to the rollcall of vendors it is suing in the US District Court in Marshall, Texas ‘ one renowned in the past for generous judgements in favor of patent holders.

Although Wi-Lan made its initial claims to patent prominence based on OFDM, especially WiMAX, its biggest infringement suit, filed last fall, concerned IPR in Wi-Fi and DSL. In the first wave of suits regarding these patents, 22 companies were named, including Apple, Dell, Intel, Texas Instruments, Sony, Lenovo, Broadcom, Acer, Best Buy and Circuit City. Now it has added the three new companies, claiming they are infringing its IPR in handsets and other equipment.

Wi-Lan has had some success in licensing its patents, most recently settling a dispute with Marvell, and it numbers Fujitsu, Nokia and Cisco among its customers. It is predicting revenues of $20m this year. However, its transition from equipment maker to a patent-only business has been fraught with upheavals and many of its patents are heavily questioned, as witnessed by the large number of lawsuits in which it is engaged. The company’s co-founder, Hatim Zaghloul, who was responsible for many of the inventions that Wi-Lan was set up to commercialize, resigned in early 2006, following disputes over the move to an IPR-only strategy.

In the early days of WiMAX, the Canadian firm caused a stir by asserting significant IPR holdings in the standard and, more generally, in OFDM. It sued Cisco and others over alleged use of its patents in Wi-Fi, and concluded WiMAX related licensing deals with several majors including Fujitsu (see Wireless Watch July 15 2004). However, rumors that it would be acquired by Qualcomm or another IPR-hungry company failed to turn into reality, raising question marks over the true value of Wi-Lan’s assets, and since exiting the equipment manufacture business amid financial difficulties, the company went quiet, until it filed its round of lawsuits last October, claiming rights not just in OFDM but in GSM/EDGE, DSL and Wi-Fi.

Wi-Lan clearly aims to take advantage of the current state of flux in handset licensing, with Nokia and others seeking to rewrite the rule books in their negotiations with Qualcomm, Interdigital and other major IPR holders. Wi-Lan is not in this league, but last year it paid up to $11m for a portfolio of 10 issued and pending US patents that it says are essential to a key area of handset market growth ‘ multimode devices. It claims several of these patents ‘would be infringed by most cellular handsets sold in the United States today’, particularly those with a combination of GSM and EDGE (most famously, the iPhone).

One giant that Wi-Lan is sufficiently circumspect to avoid antagonizing is Nokia. Although its new set of patents is not heavily licensed, Nokia and Siemens are already signed up. In January, when Wi-Lan first stuck its head above the parapet in the cellular device space, it did not go public until it had secured a deal with Nokia. At that time, it claimed that about 140 companies owed it royalties, though it would not say how many were actually paying.

Wi-Lan’s activities are divided into three IPR areas – WiMAX, Wi-Fi and cellular – the latter raising the fascinating possibility of Wi-Lan taking on the grandfather of wireless patent businesses, Qualcomm. Wi-Lan says its MS-DSSS technology is widely used in CDMA2000, CDMAone and W-CDMA devices. Other areas in which Wi-Lan states it aims to build up patent rights include 60GHz devices, the Nokia-backed Wibree personal area network, cognitive radios, RFID smart tags, xDSL, cable modems and HomePlug.