One of the key promises that the WiMAX community has held out to operators has been the chance to support an open internet model from scratch, including an end to handset subsidies. Although subsidies enabled operators to seed the market quickly in the early days of mobile communications, they have become a bugbear in many developed markets, adding significantly to cellco costs. However, users are accustomed to cheap or free handsets in return for signing mobile contracts, and will not give them up easily. Even the iconic iPhone will now be heavily subsidized, suggesting that very few devices will prove so attractive as to lure users to pay several hundred dollars. And even cheerleaders for subsidy-free WiMAX are accepting that there will have to be some compromise.
While Barry West, the outspoken head of Sprint Xohm ‘ soon to be merged with Clearwire ‘ insists that getting away from subsidies is vital to the differentiation and success of WiMAX services, other early adopters are less radical. KDDI of Japan and India’s Tata Communications both told the recent WiMAX Forum Congress that they will subsidize handsets and other devices like USB dongles. Prateek Pashine, Tata’s VP of marketing and technology, said that in India, WiMAX will mainly serve home broadband, where CPE comes at very low cost to the consumer. “If today a DSL modem is available at a throwaway price, you have no option but to give the CPE a subsidized rate,” he said during a panel debate. “It would be the business model that almost all emerging markets are following.”
Even West conceded that in the early days, the industry could engage in some form of “bootstrapping” until the prices of chipsets fall to under $10 and make the devices far cheaper. For instance, operators could offset some of the handset makers’ bill of materials or the chipmaker’s costs according to how many devices were signed up, a practise that has been followed in some markets like South Korea, where subsidies are illegal.