Operators have as many political agendas and commercial feuds as vendors, but when they get together, they seem to be able to create common cause more effectively than their suppliers. In the two years since the key operator driven body for defining mobile broadband networks ‘ the NGMN Alliance ‘ was formed, it has achieved greater unity than vendor-driven standards bodies often manage in a decade. At its recent summit meeting, it came to key agreements on its platform, including the decision to focus primarily on LTE/SAE rather than WiMAX or other OFDM-based contenders ‘ though it will re-evaluate WiMAX when the next iteration, 802.16m, is defined. It laid down aggressive plans to address interoperability testing, GSM integration and roaming (see Wireless Watch June 25 2008), and formed alliances with some key bodies that will help create a usable 4G platform, including the GSM Association and Femto Forum.
But significant challenges remain. Some are partly beyond the operators’ control, namely whether the real world LTE products will deliver the performance promised by last week’s demonstrations. There remains considerable scepticism among NGMN delegates that this will prove to be the case, and these parties predict that, unless LTE delivers 10 times better performance than HSPA, most cellcos will stick with HSPA/+ for their next generation of mobile data services, postponing LTE build-out for some years (or just deploying it in high value hotzones, one reason for the new closeness to the Femto Forum, given that femtocells would be one way to achieve this dual-layered approach).
Other potential hurdles are ones that the NGMN Alliance believes it can leap itself, and the most serious is probably the thorny issue of IPR. Vodafone is leading the call for a transparent system of declaring patent claims upfront, a demand it has also been making for the past two years in key bodies like the European ETSI organization, which has adopted some of these recommendations. CTO Steve Pusey, speaking on behalf of the NGMN Alliance, called recently for a web site on which all companies should publish the amount of royalties they would expect in any aspect of LTE, particularly pushing companies even to publish ‘zero’ IPR if they have decided not to participate in the IPR distribution. To set the pace, Vodafone itself has already published ‘zero’ for LTE patent fees.
While many operators are likely to follow suit – despite their greater role in contributing patents than in previous mobile generations ‘ vendors have more to lose, having grown up with a system of fairly generous patent revenues. However, rewards for their hefty R&D spend must now be balanced with the need to seed new technologies like LTE swiftly through the ecosystem, including consumer electronics and ultra-low cost devices for emerging markets.
Vodafone’s preferred scheme would not necessarily reduce royalties, but would at least alert vendors and standards bodies to them in advance, giving the opportunity to put pressure on particularly greedy patent holders, or adopt a different, cheaper technology. It would also reduce the chance of surprise lawsuits and license fee demands after the adoption of a platform, which are always lurking in the shadows, threatening to disrupt pricing assumptions and possibly deter vendors from adopting a new standard. The most famous example was probably the long running battle between RIM and patent troll NTP, and there have been many incidents in the Wi-Fi sector, some of which threatened to derail the backing for the standard.
While the NGMN Alliance focuses on its own remedies for this situation, some vendors are taking a different approach to ensuring IPR claims are made upfront, avoiding shock lawsuits and making licensing more transparent. Ericsson, Cisco, Google and Hewlett-Packard have teamed with operator Verizon Communications, but rather than coming up with new industry guidelines, they are actually looking to buy up IPR that they regard as business critical in order to protect themselves from lawsuits (not, they insist, to create new patent revenue streams for themselves).
The Allied Security Trust says it aims to acquire patents and license them fairly, according to industry guidelines, before they fall into the hands of trolls or other companies that could use them as weapons. Companies will pay roughly $250,000 to join the group and will each put about $5m into escrow with the organization, to go toward future patent purchases. Member companies will sell the patents they acquire after granting themselves a non-exclusive license to the underlying technology ‘ a move designed to ally fears that the Trust could itself become an aggressive patent enforcer. “It will never be an enforcement vehicle,” said the group’s CEO, Brian Hinman, a former VP of intellectual property at IBM. “It isn’t the intent of the companies to make money on the transactions.” Hinman said the group will not face any antitrust issues because it isn’t a profit making venture and its members do not actually own patents – they just grant themselves a license to them.
The Coalition for Patent Fairness, a technology lobby group in Washington DC, says the number of patent related lawsuits rose to nearly 2,500 through October of last year from 921 in 1990.