Humble consumers probably have no idea that there is a war being fought to bring them something they dearly do not want, and that is advertising on handsets. Over the next 10 years, this has the potential to become the biggest advertising market in the world – hence the war. After Microsoft spent four months trying to court the 11 members of the Yahoo board, CEO Jerry Yang saw off a Microsoft bid for the company that supposedly foundered on price, but was really about corporate culture clash.
Yahoo has done surprisingly well on the handset – in January opening up its Mobile Developer Platform to third party applications; showing off a revamped version of its Yahoo Go wireless web front door; and offering a new system to integrate content and advertising on a device. On the developer front, Yahoo offered tools to write widgets once, for instant publication across the device ecosystem, and convinced eBay, MySpace and MTV to use it.
It then followed this up by signing 16 Asian wireless operators, between them reaching around 40% of all Asian handset owners ‘ partners include Aircel, BPL and BSNL in India, and multiple operator deals in Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, Hong Kong, the Philippines, South Korea and Taiwan.
The fight that is blazing for Yahoo’s hand is as much a fight about putting advertising on the handset, as a consolidation between the world’s major web portals. This week two more events put the outcome in doubt, with the US Department of Justice realizing that it needs an antitrust investigation into the partnership that Google and Yahoo signed amid the Microsoft battle, and investors trying to eject the entire Yahoo board so that they can go ahead and accept a new deal with Microsoft instead.
The deal that the board thinks will keep Yahoo as an independent company is the one cut in mid-June, which would mean that Yahoo searches will use ads served by Google. If that deal goes ahead, it is likely to see Google overnight dominating advertising on the handset, and we believe that will mean ‘more’ advertising on the handset. The agreement would last for four years and would up Yahoo’s annual advertising take by around $800m a year. We find it hard to see how such a deal can be sanctioned, given the amount of search advertising control this grants to Google. This step can only happen if a severe consent decree is signed by Google, limiting its ability to dominate neighboring markets. Private and publicly funded antitrust probes will be likely, not just in the US, but in Europe, where Nokia will feel compromised, and in Asia, where local providers will feel the same pressure. This appears to make the Google-Yahoo proposal a non-starter.
We have to remember that Google already has its Android initiative, which will power a subsection of the handset market where it will likely end up with all on-device advertising. And recently we have seen the launch of the Nokia Advertising Alliance, bringing together couponing, location-based targeting and image recognition on Nokia devices to offer advertisers a simple way to increase consumer engagement.
Also, this week Microsoft ha almost declared itself back in the game, by saying that if activist investor Carl Icahn manages to remove much of the board at Yahoo, in a vote that will happen on August 1 at the Yahoo shareholder meeting, then the Windows giant is happy to resume takeover negotiations ‘ though it is more likely this would result just in the purchase of the search business, which could escape regulator review and not leave the transaction open into the next US government.
Given that the share price at Yahoo has collapsed since talks with Microsoft were declared off, and that it has already recovered slightly with the potential for an Icahn delivered proxy fight, then there is every chance that the entire board could find itself out of work come August 2. Today the share price is a shade over $24 after a low of $20, when the Microsoft offer price was $37. There have been conversations between Icahn and Microsoft’s CEO Steve Ballmer, because clearly, Icahn has a bigger chance of kicking out the board if there is a suitor waiting in the wings.
The world has to find a counterweight to complete capitulation to Google on internet and eventually handset advertising, and on handsets Nokia and Yahoo each has a strong part to play. Meanwhile, Microsoft is poised somewhere between irrelevance and becoming part of the Yahoo effort. Because if Google takes a stranglehold on ALL search, both mobile and fixed, then it will have the power to go after the declining TV broadcast advertising market and the entire IPTV advertising market, and then there will be no stopping it, to the detriment of all our media experiences.