Friday’s ambitious 21-country launch of the 3G iPhone indicated two things ‘ Apple has a long way to go to achieve the efficiency of its larger rivals in pulling off huge hardware roll-outs, but it can knock spots off most of them in terms of software. As Google increasingly arouses developer frustration with repeated delays and changes to its promised Android open platform, Apple managed to attract over 500 software creators to its AppStore, an almost entirely closed platform. The store – which launched with the 3G iPhone and has far greater significance for the balance of power in the mobile internet than another webphone, however desirable ‘ boasted 10m downloads between the Friday kick-off and the end of Sunday.
After all the hype, it was almost inevitable that there would be problems on launch day ‘ insufficient supplies for queueing customers, and most seriously, problems in many countries, notably the US and UK, with the new activation system. In the US, these hitches led some observers to describe the launch as a ‘fiasco’. Although designed to reduce the prevalence of unregistered iPhones, the in-store activation system often took an hour or more, with frequent server crashes and credit card glitches, and when online, users found that this process only worked with Internet Explorer, not Apple’s own browser Safari. AT&T blamed iTunes, which had collapsed under the simultaneous demand of thousands of 3G activations while 2G handset owners also tried to update their devices to the 2.0 operating system (also released on the same day) and access AppStore. For US users, there was added frustration in many areas since AT&T actually has very limited 3G coverage.
But the 3G/AppStore debut, described by Apple chief Steve Jobs as the ‘most important launch of my career’, outdid expectations on the software front, where about 300 programs had been expected to be available through the new channel for the iPhone and iTouch. About 25% of the apps are free, and the majority of the rest are under $10 (Apple takes a share of the revenues). About one-third are games and there are some high profile additions like Google Talk, social networking programs (see separate item) and the first iPhone app from an airline, offered by British Airways for customers to book flights, check flight status, check in and so on.
The AppStore is genuinely significant for the nascent mobile web industry because it highlights and accelerates a few key trends. First, it proves the reality of the mobile internet applications base, and that there is demand from users and willingness of developers to participate once they see that demand, and once they have a device that showcases their software well, and tools that work. The initial success of AppStore is a positive for the whole mobile web business, helping to quieten the doubts that still surround it.
The second factor is related ‘ the AppStore shows that the obsession with open platforms may be overdone or at least premature. The PC web experience, the rise of Web 2.0 and other new trends, and the media machine of Google and others, have all convinced us that openness is the way to go ‘ whether open platforms under fairly tight control of a vendor or group, like Android, or an entirely open source approach like OpenMoko. Economics and user expectations dictate that, as on the PC, once the mobile web services market is somewhat mature, it will indeed be open and there will be a drive to standards and the volume and user choice enabled by openness. However, in the early years, where mobile web users remain a minority, a more closed platform can deliver what is really wanted ‘ brand, attractive applications, and a level of revenue that is large enough to divide among the value chain participants. AppStore and the iPhone phenomenon in general prove that openness is not all as far as the users are concerned ‘ as long as the device is well priced and the apps useful or entertaining, a closed system will be tolerated (and possibly have advantages like ease of use) more than a chaotic or delayed open service. In this context, the two-year wait for the new Symbian Foundation to achieve full openness for the smartphone OS and development platform may turn out to be perfect timing, rather than a frustrating wait, provided developer expectations are managed more successfully than by Google. The search giant has shown that it has yet to learn the first lesson of open source ‘ the paramount need to communicate clearly with the community and treat all developers the same (the company angered programmers first with a delay to its SDK, and then by releasing an updated beta version to selected partners only).
The third factor is that the market impact of the iPhone, merited or not, will drive financing into mobile web applications, even at a time of economic uncertainty. Kleiner Perkins Caufield and Byers, the firm behind the $100m venture capital fund set up with Apple for official iPhone application development, says it has been been ‘overwhelmed’ by applications for funding, with 1,700 received since the initiative was formed three months ago. Two have so far been publicly announced as receiving funding – Pelago’s Whrrl and iControl Networks’ iControl. KPCB says it has also extended another offer to an unnamed start-up and another 10 are being seriously considered.
The Phone 3G is now available in 21 countries – Australia, Austria, Belgium, Canada, Denmark, Finland, Germany, Hong Kong, Ireland, Italy, Japan, Mexico, Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, UK and the US and will go on sale in France on Thursday.
3G iPhone ups and downs:
Ups:
Massive demand for the new device, and consumers can now get their hands on an iPhone for a low price or even free, admittedly with sometimes draconian contract terms.
The launch is spurring other smartphone makers into renewed innovation efforts and accerated launch schedules, promising greater choice and possibly even a Sony PSP phone (see separate item).
Two-thirds more applications available in the AppStore on day one than anticipated, with many big names adapting their programs to make best use of the iPhone’s features.
Downs:
Failure of the in-store activation system, leading to high levels of frustration. This probably did not lead to many lost sales, but did mean that some operators had to break the ‘in-store activation only’ rule, designed to prevent unauthorized handsets, and this is proving a major boost to the grey market. No problem for Apple but a blow to operators like AT&T that still have an exclusive in their territory.
The Italian launch was marred by an antitrust complaint lodged minutes before the new handset went on sale. The influential consumer rights group, Movimento Difesa del Cittadino, claimed that the policy of limiting distribution of the device to just Telecom Italia and Vodafone amounted to anti-competitive behaviour, a suit that, especially if emulated elsewhere, could be a serious challenge to the practise of operator exclusives.
In Canada, there have been two weeks of fury about Rogers’ restrictive and expensive 3G iPhone service plan, the toughest in the world, with a compulsory three-year contract, hugely expensive break clauses, high voice rates and even more expensive data rates, with unlimited data usage packages supported by the carrier ‘ which is a near-monopoly in parts of the country. Anger at the terms, despite some last minute compromises, meant the Canadian launch was a flop.
Chip suppliers:
The first teardowns have emerged after the iPhone launch, and European suppliers seem to be the big winners, according to experts at Portelligent and Semiconductor Insights.
As expected, Infineon is the star of the show, supplying the UMTS transceiver, and the baseband processor (a two-chip module in a single package, comprising the X-Gold 208 chip for GSM/GPRS/EDGE and the PMB 8802 for W-CDMA/HSDPA). The German company is also the major supplier of a significant new feature for the 3G handset, built-in GPS, which was only software enabled in the 2G version. Infineon’s Hammerhead II chip integrates an assisted-GPS baseband processor with a GPS RF front end and multipath mitigation to improve accuracy in urban environments.
Many components are the same as in the 2G phone, including Samsung’s ARM-11 based processor and Wolfson Microelectronics’ audio codec hardware. The baseband’s support memory comes from Intel/STMicro spin-off Numonyx and STMicro is providing the accelerometer, and CSR its BlueCore6-ROM Bluetooth chip ‘ an update from the 2G iPhone’s BlueCore4.
Power management comes from Infineon (the communications portion) and NXP (system level power control and management). Other suppliers are Toshiba (NAND Flash); Triquint (power amplifiers); Texas Instrument (touchscreen line driver); Broadcom (touchscreen controller); SST (serial Flash); Skyworks (quad band GSM/EDGE amplifier module; National Semiconductor (display interface); and Linear Technology (battery charger plus USB power controller).
Pricing:
It is interesting to see just how widely varied the price of an Apple iPhone is in various parts of the world and then to throw in the minimum contract rate to see what kind of investment it requires. Certainly in most countries this is now higher than owning a top of the range PC.
Our partner company, Rider Research in the US (www.riderresearch.com), has put together a comparison table providing pricing details for most of the countries where the 3G iPhone is available. Even though carriers require minimum contracts of varying lengths, Rider has used 24 months for each in the chart to show a comparison of the total cost of ownership in the far right column.
Canada’s response has already shown how galled north American owners may be to realize that they are being ‘milked’ because of their high standard of living. As for Denmark, what must it have done to deserve the huge price of $3,318 (about £1,650) for a two-year lifetime ownership, while being limited to a monthly data allowance of just 300Mb. Italy and Ireland are nearly as bad, while the The UK equivalent is $1,611 (£805) with unlimited data usage, and a minimum contract of just 18 months. We suspect that this is because the UK is an exceptionally competitive market, but then again so is Denmark.
The US total cost of ownership runs to $1,879, with a minimum contract over 24 months and unlimited data. In Finland, Switzerland and Sweden the operators seem to have lost sight of the fact that Apple iPhone users have the largest appetites for data usage of any handset owner and have limited the inclusive data to just 100Mb a month. Some power users can get through this in under a week so the likely real cost of ownership, with a reasonable usage, could be far higher than those cited at $1,450, $818 and $1,482.
Interestingly, in Switzerland the handset is being offered by both Orange and Swisscom, and it has a 1Gb monthly data limit but costs far more over 24 months, some $1,225, around $400 a year more in total.
The US is one of the cheapest actual purchase prices, a move that featured heavily in the launch imagery with Steve Jobs standing in front of a sign that said $199, but in Germany the 8Gb version is even less at $94, though it has the highest monthly rate outside Denmark and Italy.