Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

16 July 2008

HDMI spreads its wings as high definition standards map gets complicated

As the wireless and consumer electronics sectors come ever closer, the standards picture gets ever more complicated. UltraWideBand is battling to be the basis of standards right across the field, from TVs to PCs to handsets, but is facing challenges from the more established Wi-Fi and from the emerging 60GHz efforts for high speed, short range multimedia connections. Now HDMI is also looking to move beyond its natural home in the living room to the handset, and Sony is backing a new standard for handheld device communications.

The wireless personal area network (WPAN) space has been gripped all year by the battles between Wi-Fi, UWB and 60GHz, and a key decision will be made this week by the IEEE. The main UWB flavour, WiMedia, has so far failed to live up to its performance claims of over 100Mbps at short range, and key supporters like Texas Instruments have gone cool because of its unreadiness for the handset. The Bluetooth Special Interest Group and TI are just two parties that have turned their attention, at least in the short term, from UWB to the new iteration of Wi-Fi, 802.11n. This confines this generation of WiMedia to PC-peripheral connectivity and Wireless USB, while the other main UWB technology, Pulse~Link’s C-Wave, shows better performance for superfast in-home multimedia networks, but remains proprietary and needs a tier one adopter.

The crisis in UWB’s hopes, even if temporary, is letting others into a home networking and mobile device market that will account for billions of chip unit sales in a few years’ time. The last thing that is needed is another feud in the IEEE, whose initial UWB efforts foundered on the stand-off between Freescale and Intel/TI, with the latter taking their technology out of the standards body and turning to another organization, ECMA, to standardize what is now WiMedia. But history could repeat itself in the bid to define standards for high speed WPANs using the 60GHz spectrum, which has the advantage of being plentiful and almost empty. The IEEE’s 802.15.3c group is already working on a standard, which could even, in time, use a UWB physical layer. But the effort is at loggerheads with the latest 802.11 Wi-Fi task group, which is also interested in 60GHz for its VHT (Very High Throughput) extension.

The two groups have held two meetings but failed to agree on how they might divide their efforts and so convince the IEEE that the two proposed standards would be significantly different in technology and applications ‘ a prerequisite for the standards body to sanction two efforts. A ruling will be made this week at the IEEE summit in Denver, Colorado, where the 3c group will be voting on the first draft of its standard. It has no wish to see its territory trampled by the Wi-Fi effort which, while behind in timing, would have the advantage of the weight of Wi-Fi’s installed base and industry backing.

The 3c group claims to have found just one significant differentiator in the VHT proposal compared to the 3c draft ‘ a seamless roaming feature. But the older 60GHz group says it already supports handover capability and expects to add roaming in future. It is now requesting that the VHT adopt the physical layer chip and the channel scheme ‘ four 2160MHz channels over 9GHz of bandwidth ‘ defined by 3c.

An agreement to use the same physical layer and channels would reduce the risk of interference between different 60GHz technologies, though this should not be high given the amount of this spectrum that exists. It would also point to a world where different standards, like Bluetooth, Wi-Fi and 802.15, would evolve their future, high speed iterations using a unified physical platform. This is a vision already held up by the UWB community, and WiMedia succeeded in winning the USB and Bluetooth groups to its unified platform, before performance question marks turned the latter’s eyes towards Wi-Fi and probably deterred other potential standards partners like Firewireless.

Never mind UWB, the position of USB itself as the natural digital interface for cameras and cellphones could also be under threat, from HDMI, the standard interface for HDTVs, but now resurrecting old claims that it could leap the gulf into mobile devices too. The effort to bring HDMI to the mobile world is being led by Silicon Image, a founder of HDMI Licensing and a key patent holder. The company this week announced a dual-mode solution that supports HDMI and its proprietary, compact alternative, MHL. This product promises to reduce the bill of materials, power consumption and time to market for interfacing handsets to digital TVs.

The company is pushing its proprietary MHL (Mobile HD Link) interface as a smaller form factor option to HDMI. MHL promises to address an important concern of OEMs, the number of system-on-chip audio/video I/Os ‘ HDMI needs 19 but MHL can use as few as five. Silicon Image also hopes to create a dual-mode USB/MHL connector in future. However, the HDMI camp says the Type C profile of the standard also supports compact SoCs for handheld devices and a proprietary option should not be necessary, and Silicon Image’s main rival ADI, claims its HDMI transmitter chip combines PHY and MAC, and offers smaller chip size and lower power consumption than MHL. Also, for MHL mobile devices to connect to digital TVs, they will need a dongle that translates between MHL and HDMI, and this does not support the latest HDMI enhancement, Deep Color.

Whether Silicon Image succeeds in making HML a de facto standard, or whether HDMI vendors shrink down their technology to rival, or live alongside, USB in handheld devices, the standards picture is getting yet more complex. Also recognizing that PCs, mobile devices, TVs and in-car systems are becoming highly integrated with one another, and may require unified platforms, Sony is spearheading a new effort within the Consumer Electronics Association (CEA), which will hold a meeting this fall to decide whether to devise a new standard for portable systems and how they connect to TV, stereo and automotive products.

“The CE industry has clearly morphed beyond the traditional TV, stereo and car audio systems to a convergence of technologies, so it may be time for us to address these portable systems in a broad way,” said Dave Wilson, director of technology and standards for the CEA. The Association has tended to leave portable CE standards to other bodies apart from its Portable Digital Media Interface (PDMI), a 30-pin connector for media players that aims to be an alternative to Apple’s iPod interface. The CEA has a version of PDMI in the works that should support multiple protocols including USB 2.0, USB 3.0 and DisplayPort, and it has explored adding HDMI too.

“We’re trying to create an interface for portable devices such as media players and other systems to link to TVs, stereos and car audio products,” said Wilson. “If we could establish a connection for the digital world as ubiquitous as the RCA plug was for analog video it would be a great help to the industry.’ The CEA is particularly keen to get involved in order to push standards that do not carry high royalties or usage limitations, like proprietary systems like Apple’s.