Sony has significantly boosted the fortunes of its Sony Ericsson handset joint venture by donating its high profile Walkman and Cybershot brands to the cause, with the former the only logo with a hope of touching that of iPhone/iTunes in mobile music. But many believe the real killer move for the smartphone maker in its core multimedia heartland would be to import the PSP (PlayStation Portable) gaming brand to the phone market. The Japanese giant may have come a step closer to taking on the iPhone by the jugular, filing two patents that point to a touchscreen gaming/phone device with direct and gesture-based input (Sony already leads in gesture input due to its PlayStation Eye Toy, built around its inhouse CCD technology, which is used in cameras.)
Buoyed by news of the patents, the hunt for the Sony PSP phone is on, and games blogs and wireless papers all over the world are having a stab at it, with one data sheet emerging this week saying that it will have a 2megapixel camera, a built-in web browser, a flight mode (for playing games while on a plane without jamming the aeronautics), weight just 250 grams and with 4.3-inch screen using 16 x 9 video with 480 x 272 pixels. Such attempts at predicting the PSP phone’s qualities are not really interesting, because basically they are the PSP spec combined with standard features of a smartphone. But the big issue that is being debated, though not resolved, is whether or not this would be a handset that can play PSP games, or a PSP that can make calls. The truth is that both are possible and both are likely, and Sony already offers some hints in its Wi-Fi PSP applications, notably voice over Wi-Fi.
The phone was first mooted last summer when Sony watchers unearthed patents for a device where the screen would swivel, uncovering controls that made it look just like a PSP in one formation and just like a phone in another. Last week news emerged about yet more patents – a touchscreen where buttons would raise for one application, and then slide back down level with the screen; and gesture control, using the Eye Toy software.
Looking for clues from patents is a lousy way of predicting the future strategy of a company like Sony and its handset division Sony Ericsson, because the incorporation of patents can take years, but in reality, market trends suggest that Sony may well bring a PSP phone to market in the near future. One issue is whether it would be a Sony Ericsson product, or whether the Japanese parent will keep its crown jewel brand all to itself, rather than giving Ericsson a free ride.
First, we have to remember that Sony Ericsson currently makes a profit, and Sony’s games division doesn’t. Games will strengthen, but were held back by two huge steps which cost legendary PlayStation designer Ken Kutaragi his job in charge of PlayStation ‘ the reliance on a massively powerful complex chip, the IBM Cell chip, for the PS3, and the fact that the devices HAD to sell with a Blu-Ray disk drive inside them, or Sony would have lost the HD disk war. So although the gaming division doesn’t currently make a profit, the entire $88bn Sony operation owes it a favor right now for coming through for Blu-ray.
Already, the Sony brands of CyberShot cameras and Walkman portable media players are alive and well within Sony Ericsson, and were responsible for much of the growth that company’s handsets sales in the past quarter. So the idea that Sony won’t trust Sony Ericsson with the PlayStation brand doesn’t seem to hold true. And in terms of devices and profit Sony Ericsson is the company that holds the high ground ‘ it shipped 30m devices in the fourth quarter of last year, while the Sony PSP shipped just 14m million devices last year in total, around 3.5m a quarter. Interestingly, the PSP will have made a very small profit since it relies on games subsidies to bring the division into positive territory. So those saying that Ericsson should be forced by Sony to sell some of its 50% ownership in the handset company, before Sony should let it use the PSP brand, don’t understand how things happen in the games industry. If Sony Ericsson helped Sony ship more games, Sony would make all the profit.
The Sony PSP, when it was launched, was around $650 of hardware on the market for $250 with the massively profitable game sales providing the rest of the financial equation. That will have changed now, but still it is the games that do the damage. So in order to get Sony Ericsson to make a device which will give it far less margin than its existing handsets, quite a lot of decisions have to be made regarding the price of the device to operators, and whether any subsequent games revenues could be allocated to pay for it.
So when rabid PlayStation insiders phone up gaming sites and say: ‘No way are we ever going to give our PlayStation brand to the handset group,’, what is actually more likely is that the handset group is holding back asking: ‘How are we going to make money if we add gaming?’ and asking for some of the games sales revenues. Which is perhaps why we have been waiting for a year for a PSP handset and it has not emerged (and why Nokia has made successive efforts to create a gaming content platform as well as handsets that are optimized for games playing).
But Sony Ericsson is now in something of a bind, as well as facing key decisions about profit versus volume, that could even include an Indian merger (see separate item). Nokia has re-energized its NGage portable gaming effort this year, and made it into a software platform that can be incorporated into many of its existing handsets. We know that Microsoft is working towards a portable Xbox, out either this year or early next ,which will harm PSP, and in Apple’s AppStore, games make up about one-third of its 500-strong catalog, which means that overnight, the iPhone could become the de facto gaming handset on the market. While Samsung and Motorola will lose nothing from that, this would strike straight into the heart of Nokia’s NGage efforts, and cut off all the oxygen from a Sony Ericsson gaming move. So its F305 handset, which launched a few weeks ago targeted at games, but launched without the Sony PlayStation brand, is way too little, and it may be too late.
Sony’s new CEO Howard Stringer has to prevent the various fiefdoms that split Sony into around six separate companies from undermining his company’s efforts to bring the PlayStation brand to handsets. If there is no Sony Ericsson handset that plays PlayStation games out by this Christmas, then Apple will covertly steal the gaming high ground on phones, which would be a Sony disaster.
This analysis was originally published in Faultline, Wireless Watch’s sister title, which offers weekly insights into the digital media markets and the economics of the quad play. Please contact Peter White on [email protected] for more details.