A feature of the emerging generation of mobile broadband standards is that the major operators have seized the steering wheel, and are determined to ensure the technologies are optimized for their commercial needs. The most powerful body coordinating the operators’ activities is the NGMN (Next Generation Mobile Networks) Alliance, which numbers 18 carrier members and works with a wide range of other bodies. When it was first formed, it seemed to be a force for unity across the industry, able to support more than one RAN technology, and bring various 4G contenders within a common umbrella of patents policies, performance tests and interoperability systems. But now the operators are descending into the same politics that have often delayed or fragmented standards over which the vendors have ruled, and the clearest signal is that the Alliance has selected just one technology ‘ LTE ‘ as its preferred new generation network, and this has prompted WiMAX’ greatest supporter, Sprint Nextel, to quit the Alliance.
The developments dampen hopes for a near term convergence of WiMAX and LTE into a single mobile broadband standard for the run-up to 4G, although the Alliance did indicate, when it made its LTE selection earlier this month, that it would assess WiMAX again in its next iteration, 802.16m. This suggests strongly that WiMAX and LTE could remain separate for the current generation and then come more closely together at the 16m/LTE 2 stage, in a few years’ time, assuming that both technologies have strong market positions by then.
However, in the short term, the NGMN Alliance has clearly become an LTE supporters’ club, and reinforced this by forming a close interworking collaboration with the GSMA, the main representative of the GSM and UMTS communities, which see LTE as their natural future path.
Sprint said it ended its relationship with the Alliance after the group chose to endorse LTE because the body was supposed to endorse the coexistence of various technologies without favoring just one, and that technology neutrality was a key tenet when it co-founded the Alliance, in order to avoid duplication of work by existing standards bodies. “Sprint was disappointed that NGMN shifted from its original technology neutral stance,’ said a spokesperson. The other founder operators were China Mobile, NTT DoCoMo, Vodafone, Orange, KPN and T-Mobile, all of them planning to make LTE their major next generation network, at least in their heartland territories. Most of the other 12 carrier members also back LTE, and even those that have major WiMAX plans, like Tata and KDDI, did not fight too hard to retain WiMAX or the technology neutral strategy, suggesting they will take an interest in LTE too.
All this could be another blow to the chances of Mobile WiMAX gaining a prominent position in the mobile carrier market, driving it further towards sectors where it has a headstart over LTE, or where LTE activities have not been focused ‘ such as fixed line operators moving to quad play, or fixed/nomadic access for underserved areas. There is little doubt that WiMAX will amass a significant presence in these markets, but the odds look increasingly poor in the 3G heartlands.
This leaves Sprint Nextel virtually isolated as a tier one carrier with a truly ‘4G’ vision of mobile broadband based on WiMAX. This in turns means that its interests are not represented by the mainstream operator bodies, which could hamper its roll-out of new technologies, for instance by reducing the confidence of device makers in 802.16e. It also means that Sprint’s influence over the WiMAX Forum is disproportionately high, because of its poster child role, and while it is important to Sprint to ensure that the Forum’s agenda is geared to its commercial needs as it prepares to merge its WiMAX unit with Clearwire, its dominance is also alienating some smaller carriers, whose voice may not be heard in the Forum. The main exceptions are KT and British Telecom, the first because of its roll-out of Wi-Bro in Korea, the latter because it represents WiMAX’ best hope for gaining a tier one European carrier (though only if BT acquires a 2.6GHz license, by no means a foregone conclusion).
The burden on the ‘new Clearwire’ will be immense ‘ its roll-out and the real world performance of its technology and its services strategy will be closely watched and a major factor in deciding whether or not the mobile operator community gains confidence in WiMAX again, perhaps taking a renewed interest at the 802.16m stage.
Sprint Nextel’s investors may be feeling some nerves over whether the Xohm unit has picked the right technology, but at least it is now sharing its risk and cost with other partners, and the shareholders will be pleased with the strength of those allies. If partnerships are to be key to keeping Sprint in the front rank of US telecoms ‘ especially the rump company, once Xohm is spun off into the enlarged Clearwire ‘ the telco’s board may have to listen more seriously than before to another potential backer, SKT of Korea. Sprint Nextel’s board rejected a $5bn proposal from SKT and Providence Equity Partners out of hand last year, when the Korean company wanted to take a stake in Sprint (and particularly Xohm), but the deal foundered on the legacy politics of the US operator, with the board hating SKT’s insistence that the former Nextel CEO return to head up Sprint.
Now SKT is said to be back on the trail, although rumors that it was interested in taking a major stake, or even attempting a full takeover, have been largely discounted by the companies themselves and by many analysts. Sprint is regarded as a possible takeover target, on the basis that the past year of financial turmoil and under-performance have reduced its value significantly, and do not recognize some inherent value and growth that remains within the company, such as its share of Xohm, its spectrum assets and the recently relaunched push to talk service. Any bid would be likely to come from abroad, possibly from Deutsche Telekom, looking to add to its T-Mobile USA holding ‘ the big two US carriers would almost certainly be blocked from taking over Sprint and although a cableco deal would not be inconceivable, the cable carriers seem more inclined to pursue joint ventures, as with the participation of Comcast and others in Xohm.
SKT has been eager to increase its position in the US market, and believes it can bring the expertise and knowhow it has acquired in its home territory, the most advanced mobile broadband country on earth, to leapfrog larger carriers in markets like north America, which are only just starting on the mobile internet journey. This puts its focus firmly on partners or acquisitions that are focused on advanced web services and complex content, the areas where SKT thinks it can add value and differentiate itself. Its first major initiative was its Helio joint venture with EarthLink, which established an MVNO with a highly sophisticated and ambitious vision of delivering a new breed of content-driven multimedia and internet services. This proved ahead of its time, with most users still prioritizing cheap voice and text minutes over unique content, and it was recently sold off to more established MVNO Virgin Mobile, long before SKT had the chance to see through the goals it had originally set, such as expanding Helio’s scope to embrace WiMAX and mobile broadband (though SKT retains a 17% stake in Virgin Mobile, in return for a $25m investment plus Helio).
Given Sprint’s participation in the new Clearwire – which promises to have the first true mobile broadband network in the US supporting open access, a new breed of multimedia devices and other essential aspects of the wireless web ‘ it is clear why SKT retains its interest, and it could even look to add value to Sprint’s older CDMA network, as that is upgraded, something of which the Korean has its own experience at home. The likely collaboration that could arise from current talks, according to sources and analysts, would center on joint development of new generation devices and services for open, broadband wireless networks, including CDMA and Xohm/Clearwire, and would involve a far smaller sum from SKT than the $5bn offer of last November. Sprint currently has a market capitalization of $26bn, about double SKT’s of $13.8bn.
Arguably Sprint Nextel really needs a partner with expertise in corporate turnaround and in eking the maximum business out of ageing technologies, rather than one with the 4G vision of SKT. But the Korean would bring many benefits, though the synergies would have been stronger when Xohm was fully owned, since SKT’s natural interests would seem to lie with Clearwire not ‘old Sprint’. Nonetheless, SKT has much to recommend it. It has strong ambitions to expand internationally, including in the US and is prepared to put significant cash behind these objectives. It would bring Sprint real world experience of deploying a next generation wireless network, and far more importantly, real knowledge of operating an advanced mobile broadband service. With SKT, Sprint would have a partner that understands this market more than almost any operator, because of Korea’s peculiarly advanced broadband culture.