The Indian Department of Telecom (DoT) is considering a proposal to issue nine 3G licenses, rather than just five as originally intended. This could resolve a dispute that has raged for over a year and is holding up the hotly anticipated 3G auctions.
India is the world’s fastest growing mobile market but its operators are notoriously short of spectrum to meet demand. However, DoT experts have now identified bands for over 20MHz of additional 3G spectrum, which would be able to support at least four extra carriers, assuming each had just 5MHz each – fine for efficient 3G voice and basic data, but probably inadequate for a move towards mobile broadband. However, basic services capacity is the most urgent objective in India for now, and regulator TRAI plans to auction mobile broadband spectrum in 2.5-2.7GHz this year too, and to follow up with an early sale of 700MHz licenses, as early as next year. Until now, the DoT had earmarked 25MHz spectrum for 3G, in the 2.1GHz band, to be auctioned to five companies in 5MHz chunks. One is already reserved for state-controlled BSNL.
Incumbent operators have been lobbying against the DoT’s decision to open the 3G auction to new players (including foreign telcos), a decision that has been opposed and even placed in doubt by TRAI. The existing cellcos argue that competition is already too fierce and that opening up the bidding risks inflating 3G license prices to the levels seen in Europe at the start of the decade, making the business case untenable in India, and causing even greater problems than resulted in Europe. There are already 12 2G operators in India, including some new entrants that gained licenses recently but have not rolled out services as yet. All these might bid for 3G franchises, as might additional Indian business groups, and outsider operators such as AT&T.
The DoT recently doubled the “recommended reserve price set by TRAI. For ‘category A’ circles, or telecom regions, such as Delhi and Mumbai, the minimum is now $37.2m, while the figure is $18.6m for category B circles (like Chennai and Kolkata) and $7m for category C circles, which are more rural. The government expects to raise about $4.7bn but large numbers of bidders, and especially the entry of deep-pocketed foreign carriers, could drive this sum far higher.
In preparation for expected bids from these overseas operators, the DoT is to review merger and acquisition procedures and regulations, aiming to clamp down on speculators and ‘frivolous’ bidders. The department is also likely to restrict start-ups from selling, merging or otherwise exiting the Indian market for a specified period of time, likely three years. Already, new rules in this area have forced players such as Idea, Aircel and Vodafone Essar (recently awarded new licenses in many circles) to put planned mergers with smaller players in these regions on hold. Such restrictions do not apply to new entrants such as Datacom, Unitech, Swan and Loop Telecom.