China stands a strong chance of providing the key technology for LTE’s TDD implementation, but its 3G standard, TD-SCDMA, looks set to remain confined to home shores, as far as major mobile build-outs are concerned. However, a surprisingly large number of trials are underway in other countries, though most are pre-commercial and likely to be geared to gaining political and business clout with the Chinese.
In Italy, a network is being built for enterprise users by Mywave Electronics and Chinese vendor Potevio, while other trials are being run in Hong Kong, Korea, Canada, Romania and Ghana (none commercial as yet). Two years ago, France Telecom joined the TD-SCDMA Alliance and hinted it might deploy the technology, but networks have not materialized, and like many of those flirting with the Chinese 3G platform, its moves seem to have been mainly geared to gaining business partners, influence and knowhow in China, rather than reflecting a real desire to use TD-SCDMA, which even lead operator China Mobile has implemented under duress.
Potevio, which is supplying the new Italian trial, is a joint venture between Nokia Siemens and China Putian (NSN holds 49%), created in October 2005 to develop both TD-SCDMA and W-CDMA equipment.
Where TD-SCDMA is deployed outside China, it would be because an operator needed to supplement mainstream services with data-oriented offerings in TDD spectrum (W-CDMA runs in FDD mode and the TDD flavor of the standard, TD-CDMA, never really gained market traction and is now part of NextWave). However, WiMAX is also bidding to be the default network for TDD-based mobile broadband, and in a few years’ time, there will be the option of TDD LTE (likely to be based on the next iteration of China’s standard, but also potentially incorporating WiMAX). So given that TD-SCDMA is only know becoming commercialized, and is largely unproven, it will have a very small window to establish any toehold outside its home country.