With the W-CDMA establishment firmly wedded to LTE as its next generation migration, the WiMAX community has set its eyes on appealing to new mobile entrants, such as broadband providers, and on the CDMA carriers. Once it became clear that Qualcomm’s own mobile broadband, OFDM-based offering, UMB, would not be commercialized, the CDMA operator base was wide open to be wooed by WiMAX and LTE vendors, and at its annual conference last week, the CDMA Development Group (CDG), the main industry body for the platform, lent weight to the claims of WiMAX to be a strong migration option for EV-DO cellcos.
Meanwhile, another stand-off between WiMAX and LTE may be on the horizon, as both bid for approval as official 4G technologies ‘ or perhaps look to converge into a single platform that could materialize after the current generations of the two networks. The ITU (International Telecommunications Union) has approved the general technical specifications for its IMT-Advanced platform, which will be the basis of true 4G, and has opened up for submissions from specific candidate technologies to be approved as 4G standards. WiMAX won a belated but important victory last year when it was approved as a system for 3G or IMT2000, allowing it to compete for 3G business in territories and spectrum that were previously reserved for W-CDMA, CDMA2000 and China’s TD-SCDMA. It will need the same approval for IMT-Advanced, with LTE and China’s LTE TD-SCDMA the other prime candidates. The systems will need to move to their next iterations to conform with IMT-Advanced specs ‘ while LTE and WiMAX supporters often bandy about the ‘4G’ term, in reality their technologies are currently at the ‘3G+’ stage, and will need to boost data rates and other aspects to qualify for true 4G as defined by the ITU.
From October, technologies can be submitted for IMT-Advanced approval. The WiMAX Forum is preparing its next generation system, 802.16m, while the 3GPP is polishing up LTE Advanced even before first wave LTE is fully standardized. The ITU’s technical criteria were approved at a meeting held in Dubai at the end of June and will be published later this week. Key requirements will include average downlink speeds of 100Mbps in the wide area network, and 1Gbps in fixed, local access or low mobility scenarios. Another key criterion will be low latency – less than 10 millisecond roundtrip delay and less than 100ms to set up a new session.
Also, IMT-Advanced calls for very wide channel widths – 40MHz up to 100MHz, which will force significant change in future spectrum auction rules from many regulators. It may also make spectrum availability a serious obstacle to deployment of true 4G networks and services in the medium term.
While there has been much speculation ‘ and operator demand, driven by Vodafone ‘ for WiMAX and LTE to combine their efforts, this is far more likely to happen at the IMT-Advanced stage than in the current iterations of the standards, partly because of the politics involved, and also because WiMAX and LTE are, for now, at different stages of commercialization and targeting different markets. Convergence would most likely center on WiMAX providing the TDD element of a unified platform, rather than the Chinese LTE TDD technology supported by Ericsson, but Ericsson will remain a major opponent of unification, aiming to keep 802.16 out of the mobile broadband picture altogether, and include technologies over which it has significant political and IPR influence.
The ITU’s Radio group will start accepting proposals for candidate technologies at the next IMT-Advanced meeting in October and at that time, should also agree on the evaluation criteria for the technologies. It is expected to complete its recommendation for the IMT-Advanced radio interface technology in early 2011, with commercial ‘true 4G’ deployments likely between 2012 and 2025.
Looking to the shorter term, and the ongoing migration of advanced operators to ‘3G+’, the CDMA Development Group is looking to the options for its carriers. It sees LTE as the main candidate, largely because the biggest CDMA cellco, Verizon Wireless, has selected it. However, it also supports WiMAX as a good migration route, as taken by the US’ second CDMA operator, Sprint Nextel ‘ while other CDMA carriers are even adopting a dual-technology route with WiMAX and LTE networks, including KDDI in Japan, Reliance in India, and SKT in Korea.
Speaking at the CDG summit, Sarvesh Sharma, director of network solutions marketing at Huawei, said that the recent sole focus of the main operator body, the NGMN (Next Generation Mobile Networks) Alliance, on LTE, was misguided. “At the end of the day, they [WiMAX and LTE] rely on a common OFDM base, and we will work at full interoperability with LTE and WiMAX,” said Perry LaForge, chairman of CDG. “Wireless operators may show a natural tendency toward LTE, but they know they cannot ignore the significant WiMAX deployments that exist worldwide.”