Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

6 August 2008

LiMo refuses to back down in mobile web battle, but Windows misses targets

While Nokia put Symbian firmly into pole position in the mobile web software platform race when it formed the open source Symbian Foundation earlier this year, the main rivals are certainly not fading away. Google is finally preparing to make a new version of Android generally available, and those who have received a sneak preview claim it is a step-change improvement over the current release. The other main Linux-based contender, LiMo, trades on its time to market advantage over Android, and this week announced seven new handsets plus new industry supporters. Microsoft, though, is looking less shiny, at least outside its mobile enterprise heartland. It fell well short of achieving its high profile target of 20m Windows Mobile license sales in its last financial year and on a broader note, is talking publicly about the eventual end of Windows and its work on a new web-oriented OS for fixed and mobile platforms.

Andy Lees, SVP of Microsoft’s Mobile Communications Business, said Windows Mobile unit shipments were around two million short of its 20m target for the year ended June 30. He blamed lateness to market of certain devices, though did not specify which ones, and claimed the disappointment would have little material effect on the Entertainment and Devices division. At least Windows Mobile is growing more quickly than the RIM and Apple operating systems, which are confined to a single vendor’s systems. According to research by IDC, Windows Mobile unit sales increased the OS’ market share from 11% to 13% last year.

And for the future, Microsoft has a new generation OS in its labs, codenamed Midori and designed to be the company’s first ‘post-Windows’ system. This shows that the software giant is finally publicly admitting that Windows cannot be the basis of its business forever, but also that it still sees itself as a provider of operating systems, and will not willingly adopt Linux or another future open system and focus on applications and services. The Midori project has huge internal profile and is headed by Eric Rudder, former head of Microsoft’s server and tools business and a key member of Bill Gates’ inner circle when he was still running the company.

Sources revealed this week that Midori is an offshoot of the Singularity OS, designed to run directly on native Intel or ARM processors or be hosted by a Windows process. Key focuses will include optimization for multicore processors and for mobile devices. The programming model will be geared to web services and allow for applications to be broken down into services that can be split across tiers. Midori will represent a ‘clean break from the existing Windows user interface model” at the presentation layer, but is unlikely to see the light of day commercially for several years, if ever.

In the more immediate market, Windows will remain Microsoft’s flagship and it will have to fight off Linux on all platforms. In the mobile world, the LiMo Foundation is still hoping to be its chief challenger, rather than Android, and to gain the leading share of a mobile internet Linux device market that ABI Research expects to reach over 50m units a year by 2013 ‘ mainly because of the support for a single converged platform on multiple device types. Although this is often seen as a two-horse race with Android, there are other Linux and open source initiatives that have achieved powerful support and so will be influential, even if they may cooperate more closely with the big two in future. Examples are Maemo, which is backed by Nokia, and Moblin, which Intel supports, and which it will integrate tightly with the Atom mobile processor.

LiMo has made a big step forward this month, unveiling seven new handsets from Motorola, NEC and Panasonic, all using LiMo 2.0 and due for release in early 2009, many specifically for Japan. Motorola’s latest musicphone, the ROKR EM30, also runs LiMo, although the US handset maker is shifting away from Linux ‘ except in China and a few select markets ‘ and will make Symbian its primary smartphone system from next year. There are now 22 LiMo handsets on the market, with the other new additions being the Motozine ZN5, NEC Foma N906i, N906i’, N906iL and N706i, and Panasonic’s Foma P906i and N906i’.

Several of these models incorporate release 2.0 features such as higher resolution displays, international HSDPA roaming, GPS, mobile TV and advanced video streaming, as well as secure payment and advanced mail functionalities. LiMo now has over 50 members, including Nokia, via its purchase of Trolltech (although the Foundation has admitted it is ‘not sure how long that will last’ following the formation of the Symbian Foundation). Nokia itself maintains some interest in Linux, mainly for its internet tablets. ‘Our commitment remains to S60 on Symbian OS as our platform for converged mobile devices. However, we are already producing mobile devices based on maemo Linux, and we continue to see a strong role for Linux in that class of devices and will continue development,’ said a spokesman for Nokia. ‘ LiMo is certainly an interesting forum and we will consider in good time what kind of role Nokia should seek to have in this forum, if any.’

LiMo has announced nine new members this week and promises its SDK by year end. Among the newcomers are Esmertec, Freescale, Telecom Italia, integrator MIZI Research, and OEMs Longcheer Holdings and ZTE.

LiMo’s members, however, do not include Google, and the search giant said last week that it had no plans to join its rival alliance or seek convergence between the two groups, even in the cause of ending fragmentation, the main problem that has held mobile Linux back to date. Eric Chu, group marketing manager at Google’s Android group, said at the LinuxWorld conference: “Unification for the sake of unification is not the path we decided to go down. In the end, what matters most is what consumers are looking for. But having too many people on the design phase, especially early on, would have hurt the project.’

He added: ‘With mobile, you are fighting for every spare 500 kilobytes you can find. So instead of adding in compatibility for everything, we think it is important to clarify for developers the best possible direction and make it open source so it is available to more people.” Android is a far more tightly controlled environment than LiMo ‘ the latter only decides on which middleware to approve, while Google’s initiative will develop a full top-to-bottom software stack, as Symbian, Apple and Microsoft do.