French engineering group Safran has, as expected, sold off its mobile devices arm Sagem ‘ but not to key partner Sony Ericsson as was once hoped, but to venture capital firm Sofinnova Partners.
Meanwhile, mobile software firm Esmertec, another Soffinova investment, is to acquire Sagem Mobiles’ software activities, working with Purple Labs (yet another Soffinova firm) to develop the platform, which will be licensed back to its original owner. Esmertec specializes in Java in-device engines and will now look beyond that market to a broader platform geared to emerging markets and voice-centric phones. Taking over Sagem’s platform, which is installed in millions of devices, will expand its IPR and will combine a mature software platform with a Java middleware and application layer, to be suitable for consumer electronics and higher end phone products. Purple Labs offers a Linux software suite.
Although Sagem has scored some good points in the past year or so – notably its deal with Sony Ericsson to codevelop and make the handset giant’s low end range for India and other emerging markets ‘ and has a strong reputation for logistics and partnerships, nonetheless, its losses have been dragging down its otherwise robust parent group. Now, under its new owner, it will broaden its activities in white label handsets, building on the Sony Ericsson relationship and creating a new ODM company to develop and market products under other brand names, on behalf of operators, other phonemakers or fashion, sports and luxury brands.
The new company will be named Sagem Wireless, and will be based in Cergy-Pontoise, near Paris. Sofinnova will hold a majority stake, while Safran will retain about 10%. Pasquale Pistorio, former CEO of STMicroelectronics and former chairman of Telecom Italia, will be chair of Sagem Wireless, which will have 310 employees.
Problems at Sagem over the past two years have highlighted the increasingly unforgiving nature of the handset market and raised the question of how many tier two and three vendors are likely to survive the next few years. The French company saw operating losses widen from €52m in the first half of 2006 to €94m in the same period of last year, with handset sales falling by 49% year-on-year. In 2007, Safran’s outgoing chairman, Jean-Paul B’chat, admitted that the merger of Sagem and jet engine maker Snecma in 2004, to form Safran, had been a mistake. ‘We wouldn’t have done it if we had known then what we know today,’ he said, though at the time he claimed that the phone unit would not be divested.
The problems at Sagem have come from many sources, although Safran tends to point to a ‘less rigorous’ management culture rather than to the key problem for all vendors in this category ‘ being squeezed between the massive market share gains of the top five, and the emergence of extremely low cost suppliers from India and elsewhere. Sagem could not be faulted for its supply chain and procurement expertise, but outside France it was unable to combine this with strong brand awareness.
HTC of Taiwan is one former unbranded vendor that is looking to make the difficult transition to competing under its own logo against the giants. Sagem has been trying to do this for some years, but is now reversing its strategy. For a while, like many smaller phonemakers, it saw close partnership with operators as being its best chance of success. With the cellcos wanting to increase their brand awareness and their influence over handset design and development, many turned to smaller suppliers – more malleable than Nokia and willing to make operator-branded devices. However, in the past two years the handset brands have been seizing back their upper hand, with the iPhone just the most extreme example, forcing operators to work with them ‘ and lessening the appeal of the smaller manufacturers.