In three weeks’ time, significant steps should be taken towards a standard that could turn the wireless communications industry on its head and assure the dominance of the WiMAX metro area standard.
This is the proposed Handoff Project of the IEEE, which was set in motion in March and which will hold its second major meeting on 8-9 September in Denver, Colorado.
The Handoff Executive Committee Study Group has a mandate to consider the viability of developing a standard for a common handoff framework for all 802 standards ‘ WiMAX, Wi-Fi, short range technologies such as UWB ‘ and also for IEEE wired networking standards.
The committee is headed by David Johnston, an Intel employee, Ajay Rajkumar from Lucent and Nokia’s Michael Williams ‘ as usual, the leadership of the key groups indicates the vendors that are putting the greatest time and investment into the work and therefore see it as most critical to their strategies going forward. There will also be work on handoff between WiMAX and cellular networks, an area where Lucent has been a pioneer.
Such a standard, though in its very early stages and likely to take several years to come to fruition, would make all the arguments about different wireless standards irrelevant. Transmissions could be seamlessly passed between the most appropriate local, metro area and wide area networks, especially with the development of radios that intelligently choose the best connection, as Intel is planning.
Such a scenario will truly fulfil the promise that is currently enshrined in the far more limited roadmap towards 4G, the marriage of IP and cellular. Incorporate WiMAX into that mix too, and wireless communications could really become ubiquitous and robust for data and multimedia use.
The work would allow for devices with interfaces to multiple 802 networks to roam between them. Key issues to be addressed, according to the committee, are compatibility with other work on handoff, particularly the more basic projects on the Wi-Fi side, 802.11k and 802.11f; interworking with upper layer protocols, especially IPv6 and IPv4; and security.
At the first meeting in May, the main concern was defining the scope of the project, for instance, that work will focus only on the bottom two layers, the physical (PHY) and the medium access control (MAC). The September meeting will make big decisions on technological approaches such as how to build layer 2 constructs to reduce handoff latency and support real time applications; and
Also important is monitoring of handoff work in other standards groups, especially the Internet Engineering Taskforce’s WLan projects, the 3GPP cellular body and other IEEE groups, particularly 802.11x; as well as work being done on layer 3 and above by the 3GPP and other bodies.
Johnson of Intel sees security as the biggest potential hurdle. ‘Security is a complex issue addressed elsewhere (linksec, 802.1x, 802.10, 802.11i, EAP). Trying to include security procedure in handoff specifications would hugely expand the scope and conflict with other groups,’ he said. ‘But a handoff standard must not undermine security so the work should include validating that it is compatible with existing 802 security architectures.’ The solution is likely to be to exclude security specifications from the standard but ensure that the final technology is compatible with other bodies’ security work.
More on the Handoff Project in this month’s Wireless Watch research paper, which looks at WiMAX and broadband wireless standards; and coverage of the September meeting.