A major shakeout among broadband wireless access suppliers will start within months as WiMAX standard products loom near.
This will occur on two sides ‘ the WiMAX equipment providers, which will find their market overcrowded; and the opponents of the standard, which will be sidelined.
The BWA base station makers are, for the main, moving their product ranges to incorporate 802.16a silicon at the physical and MAC layers (see separate story). The main manufacturers of these chips will be Intel and Fujitsu, and silicon manufacturers that aim to stay independent, or base station manufacturers sticking to their own chips, will be sure to fail in the face of the economies of scale and consequent low prices that the chip giants can offer.
Cheap WiMAX equipment ‘ from $500 per subscriber and falling rapidly next year ‘ will make it impossible for all the BWA vendors to survive. Those with a clear differentiation in their proprietary product should be able to preserve this as they move to 802.16. The flexibility of the 802.16 standards process was conceived deliberately to allow many different implementations to remain compliant with the base layers ‘ different smart antenna approaches are allowed, for instance, rather than one or two being mandated. This is important for customer choice and to allow the suppliers to differentiate themselves, but there will still be far too many OEMs building round a commodity standard than the market can bear, and we will see significant shakeout.
This could begin within a few months, affecting those companies with the weakest funding or customer base, since many hotspot and other operators will hold back on implementing BWA until standard equipment is available. This will deprive the start-ups of new revenue just at a time when they need to invest in re-engineering for WiMAX.
Intel’s powerful backing for WiMAX has helped to convince many operators that 802.16 is the future, which makes companies that are trying to stick to their own technologies highly vulnerable. Another important factor working against the non-WiMAX players is Nokia’s support for 802.16, since Nokia has huge influence on the carrier market.
A new report from ABI Research suggests that the only potential spanner in the works of WiMAX’s progress in metro area and last mile wireless is splintering of the standard. Just as uniting all the equipment makers behind one commodity standard will slash prices and cost of entry for operators, the emergence of multiple standards will limit economies of scale. ABI points out that there are three versions of 802.16 but, while the point about fragmentation is correct, this is not the problem ‘ the three variants have well defined and different functions and they remain interoperable. It is important that they stay that way ‘ the split of the market between the two fast Wi-Fi standards, 802.11a and 802.11g, showed how adoption can be slowed and vendors sidelined by a technology battle.
In WiMAX’ case, the split is more likely to be between 802.16 and the rival IEEE standard, 802.20, or between WiMAX and proprietary alternatives. However, the big difference is that the various strands within 802.16 are, so far at least, well integrated and WiMAX has powerful vendors behind it, while its rivals have significantly less impressive support. Whereas the 802.11a/g stand-off was largely between specialists, with the victory decided by consumer preference for ‘g’, the metro area lines are drawn between Intel and Nokia on one hand and a bunch of start-ups on the other. And the deciders will be the operator customers, whose economics demand that they opt for the lowest price equipment within a performance range. And with Intel turning out mass silicon, the clear winner of that battle will be WiMAX.
* The ABI report predicts that WiMAX will generate a total of $2bn between now and 2008 with the largest revenue coming from the residential last mile base, followed by the small/medium enterprise sector offering wireless access within the office and on the move; and then by large enterprise, hotspot backhaul and nomadic sectors.