Shares in Psion soared this week to their highest level since March 2002, as the market eagerly awaited today’s quarterly results from its part-owned Symbian unit. The strength of those figures bring the likely flotation of the mobile phone operating system company several steps closer, with the possibility of an IPO next year.
The company more than doubled sales in the first half of the year, reporting £21.1m compared to £9.5m in the first half of 2002. In its first official financial results announcement, it said 2.68m Symbian phones shipped in the period, up from 230,000 last year. Pre-tax losses narrowed from £21.8m to £15m, net cash increased from £24.4m to £29.7m and royalties were up from £1.5m to £10.2m, boosted by the release of the new version 7.0 of the operating system.
There are now 10 Symbian based models from three suppliers shipping, with 26 further devices from nine licensees under development and due to come to market within 18 months. Chief executive David Levin was careful to be cautious about the outlook for the rest of the year, pointing out that Symbian remains a small part of the overall cellphone market and that this is always a very uncertain sector to predict. However, his decision to announce financial results is widely seen as a sign that Symbian intends to list on the stock market in the near future.
It is likely that Symbian will wait for an IPO until it breaks even. CEO David Levin says this will come when the company is shipping 20m units a year at current royalty levels of $5-$8 per handset, which is targeted to be late 2004. More cautious observers believe 2005 is more likely ‘ the particularly anti-Symbian analysts at Nomura, for instance, estimate it needs 25m units to break even and that this will happen in mid-2005 at the earliest.
But the performance of the Symbian OS and the smartphones that it powers have been far more impressive than anyone would have foreseen in the early, stuttering years of the company, which is jointly controlled by Psion, Nokia, Sony Ericsson, Motorola and Samsung. It is almost single-handedly responsible for the boom in the nascent smartphone market, which will see 260% growth next year, to overtake PDAs (see separate story).
Before the results were announced, Psion had seen its market value lifted to £350m with a 24% rise in its share price in two days to reach 84p. This boost was particularly satisfying to David Levin, the CEO of Symbian, who was previously CEO of Psion itself. The UK handheld pioneer had been largely written off when its devices lost ground to Palm and others, and initially nobody recognized the incorporation of Psion’s software into Symbian for the masterstroke it was.
Levin was head of an innovative but floundering UK manufacturer of niche mobile devices; now he leads a company that is still based on Psion software, but which has the support of all the world’s largest handset makers, will almost certainly dominate the high end cellphone market in the coming years, and as the smartphone becomes ‘the new PC’, has a realistic shot of becoming as important as Microsoft.
Microsoft is fighting back with its usual terrier-like determination (see separate story), but while it may prevent Symbian gaining a Windows-class monopoly of the future computing client platform, it has lost the battle to take a dominant position itself on the smartphone. However, Symbian faces other threats, the greatest of them being fragmentation.
The handset makers are all desperate to control the operating system themselves rather than being beholden to a third party like Microsoft. But they will inevitably have problems maintaining a common agenda within Symbian when they are such bitter rivals and may explore other options if they feel that they have insufficient influence over the common OS. This is already starting to happen. Nokia may have no more shares than its competitors, but by dint of its market share and its uncompromising devotion to the Symbian OS and its own Series 60 architecture, it has the most powerful position in the group.
This has already driven Motorola to consider other options where it may be able to retain greater control ‘ notably, it has been the main phonemaker to support Linux, it is developing its own smartphone OS and it has an agreement with Palm. Motorola also plans to launch a Microsoft phone and has been driven by its weakening market position relative to Nokia, and its dependence on Microsoft in other sectors such as set-top boxes, to form an alliance with the Windows giant that will almost certainly damage Motorola (see Wireless Watch issue 22).
Samsung has taken the reverse path to Motorola. Late to join Symbian, and then only as a means to fulfil its aim of offering handsets based on all major operating systems, it has now become a more ardent supporter, forming a business development alliance with Nokia and backpeddling on its plans for a Microsoft smartphone. But the company still has its own operating systems too and a determination to remain OS-agnostic.
Throw into the pot the various operating systems of non-Symbian handset makers and we can see that Symbian will not have an easy ride to achieve its aim of unifying the medium and high end mobile phone platform around its software.
Ironically, one of its greatest advantages over Microsoft is also a stumbling block: its advanced support for Java. While this has contrasted, to Symbian’s benefit, with Microsoft’s hostility to Java, the strength of J2ME among mobile phone software developers means that the existence of multiple operating systems is less important than it might have been. There is not the same impetus for developers to put their weight behind just one platform as there was in the PC world, especially as Symbian itself has multiple, not entirely interoperable, environments built on top of it, and so is not perceived as a single entity by developers. Nokia’s Series 60 is by far the most important and is also used by Samsung and others, while Sony Ericsson uses Symbian’s own UIQ environment.
So we are likely to see multiple choices of operating system on the smartphone for far longer than we saw on the PC, but Symbian’s functionality, initial impetus and the all-important drive from Nokia will ensure that it becomes the most important, if not the sole, platform for the emerging smartphones.
Rethink Research will publish the most detailed analysis to date of Symbian’s technologies, markets and prospects, in September. This will be available to subscribers to the full Wireless Watch service. For details, contact Caroline Gabriel on [email protected].