The battle to extend the speed and range of Wi-Fi heats up every month with a host of start-ups working on methods of boosting performance, many of these focused on smart antennas ‘ the use of intelligent and closely spaced antennas to handle signals more effectively.
In the limelight this week is a technology called MIMO (multiple-in multiple-out), in which the two most important vendors driving wireless networking today, Intel and Nokia, have interests. MIMO uses huge amounts of computing power to send large numbers of signals from antennas placed close together, creating a cumulative effect that can transfer large quantities of data in and out.
The first chipset for an MIMO approach was introduced today by heavily financed start-up Airgo Networks, which has backing from Nokia. It claims to be able to boost performance from Wi-Fi’s limits of 54Mbps over 150 meters to 108Mbps over up to 900 meters, while remaining complaint with most 802.11 standards ‘ though Airgo’s major obstacle is that its technology does not interoperate seamlessly with Wi-Fi. The performance enabled by its new AGN100 chipset would anticipate fast 100Mbps-plus Wi-Fi standards under development at the IEEE, but which are unlikely to become reality for two years or more. Airgo will submit its technology as a possible standard for future generations of Wi-Fi running at 100-200Mbps.
The main question that strikes us is: Interesting as these technologies are, what is the point of extending Wi-Fi when we have the metro area wireless networking standard, WiMAX or 802.16, already incorporated in products, and with commodity silicon just around the corner to bring down deployment costs drastically?
Wi-Fi extension solutions, from the well established routing/antenna approach of Vivato to the newly voguish MIMO, have to be targeted well beyond the usual Wi-Fi market. Very few users, either business or consumer, push Wi-Fi to its limits, except in a few multimedia applications, so the long distance, high speed implementations of the start-ups have to be focused on backhaul and metro area usage. This is where WiMAX already sits, and is fully capable of working with Wi-Fi hotspots and end points.
Why would operators and service providers looking to break the boundaries of Wi-Fi to offer metro-class services adopt a proprietary technology from an unproven vendor in preference to a WiMAX solution backed by a giant and at a lower price point, once Intel and Fujitsu bring out their commodity silicon? The answer is, they will not. In reality, these start-ups are showcasing their innovative approaches to smart antenna and performance boosting, approaches that could just as relevantly be applied to WiMAX ‘ which is far better adapted than Wi-Fi to support smart antenna models anyway.
Commentators remain obsessed with Wi-Fi and largely ignorant of WiMAX, but it seems no coincidence that Nokia and Intel, the leaders of the WiMAX industry drive, are the investors in the two main MIMO start-ups. Anything that continues to enhance and drive WiMAX is good news for these two unlikely allies, which have both set great store by taking the lead in 802.16, in order to jumpstart and mold a new and potentially massive market ‘ one that will drive Intel’s wireless chips and create a new breed of base stations and handsets for Nokia to exploit.
Nokia Venture Partners is one of four investors backing Airgo, the others being OVP Venture Partners, Sevin Rosen and Accel Partners. Nokia generally invests in companies whose technology it is keen to implement itself in the future, rather than purely for financial profit. Airgo is one of the strongest smart antenna start-ups, with $52m raised in venture capital so far and a good pedigree ‘ its founders set up Clarity Wireless, which pioneered OFDM for broadband wireless, and then sold it to Cisco in 1998; and its senior development team includes the inventor of the Wi-Fi access point, a former senior member of the Intel Centrino team, and Richard van Nee, director of WLan engineering, who was a prime mover behind the 802.11 PHY layer and the ‘g’ variant while at Lucent/Bell Labs.
So far, Airgo is talking about targeting the Wi-Fi niches where performance is critical, in the hope that ‘ as with 802.11g ‘ makers of consumer equipment will risk adopting a non-standard technology for the sake of stealing a performance march on competitors. Data connections for high definition television and multimedia streaming applications on computers are key targets.
However, Airgo runs the risk of falling between two stools here. Its distance capability is easily trumped by WiMAX, as is its promise of offering companies the ability to network a whole campus with just one access point. But its speed, though higher than WiMAX’ 70Mbps, is only really required in the high end digital home, which remains a niche, and here there are even faster short range wireless links such as UltraWideBand emerging, which will be standardized and available by the time this market goes mainstream.
Adapting MIMO technology to 802.16 would be a far longer term strategy and one that Nokia is sure to be interested in. For its part, Intel has acquired the intellectual property of another Silicon Valley MIMO specialist, IoSpan Wireless, which was part of the IEEE 802.16a committee that creates the WiMAX standards. IoSpan was acquired by specialist avionics company L3 but its IP remains with Intel, indicating the chip giant’s interest in this particular smart antenna approach. IoSpan developed MIMO-OFDM technology, with more traditional focus on broadband fixed wireless.
Meanwhile, at the recent Defcon conference, the first ever ‘Wi-Fi shootout’ was held, between vendors and amateurs showing off means to boost Wi-Fi’s range. The winner was 5G Wireless, also a high profile start-up targeting fixed broadband wireless. 5G claimed a Wi-Fi shot over 15 miles, though at a speed of only 4Mbps. 5G said it had used commercially available products, not specially customized ones, and managed to defeat its main rivals in the enhanced power Wi-Fi sector, Vivato and YDI.