China is accelerating its progress towards providing broadband connections across all regions of its huge territory, with WiMAX seen as the primary technology for filling the gaps in the cellular network.
The government is still in the throes of the long drawn out process of auctioning off fixed wireless spectrum in the 3.5GHz spectrum but many of the operators that have already gained licenses are taking the WiMAX route. The IEEE standards body has high hopes that China will make 802.16a the national standard for fixed broadband wireless access (BWA).
The Chinese authorities and carriers woke up to the potential of WiMAX long before the rest of the world, holding conferences on the subject two years ago. The appeal is clear ‘ the country has massive geographical spread and population and is aiming to develop its economy rapidly, providing a host of new revenue opportunities for western wireless specialists desperate for new markets. Nokia has been very aggressive in pushing its handsets and setting up manufacturing ventures in the country, and is also keen to push its base stations, including WiMAX ones. And China is the primary focus of Intel’s newly created department of rural broadband access.
The Chinese operators are going ahead already, in advance of any decision on national standards by their government. The large cellular carriers are generally keen on WiMAX as they can implement it within their cell towers and provide fixed wireless alongside 2G and 3G, as well as extending their coverage more rapidly and cheaply than they can with cellular.
Alvarion is supplying 802.16 equipment to China Unicom for use, initially, in seven cities, as the first step towards what Unicom says will be the world’s largest WiMAX system. The carrier has 23 of the 94 licenses awarded so far ‘ each city has about 31.5MHz and each carrier has about 10.5MHz to play with.
Another winner is Wi-Lan, one of the key contributors of technology to the 802.16a standard, providing the basis of the OFDM physical layer. Wi-Lan is working with China Communciations, which has won 25 licenses so far in its country’s 3.5GHz auction, making it the biggest fixed wireless operator. It is also partnering with China Sat, which has three licenses. China Netcom has 17 and China Mobile 10.
Nokia in sight of 40% market share as smartphones beat back PDAs
Only a year ago, the prevailing wisdom was that PDAs were still the basis of the mobile enterprise and smartphones were an interesting curiosity. Now the PDA is being rapidly eclipsed by its newer rival, a trend that is benefiting Nokia and Sony Ericsson in particular.
Of course there is significant overlap in functionality between PDAs and smartphones, and in another year we should stop using either label and will see a single group of ‘converged devices’ supporting voice and data in equal measure. But for now they are still discernibly distinct product groups.
The PDA specialists that survive will do so by making the difficult break into the smartphone sector, changing the form factor and enhancing the voice capabilities of their devices, but more importantly, cultivating links with the carriers and phone retailers. Of the independents, the Palm-Handspring merged entity – rebranded this week as PalmOne prior to the spin-off of the software arm Palmsource ‘ has the greatest chance of a future because of its sheer market share in the PDA sector.
But we believe that that future will be medium rather than long term. Market share does not count for much in a world where there is little customer loyalty and where the desirable brand profile that once boosted Palm and others like Blackberry has now been eclipsed by more modern brands like the Sony Ericsson P800. These brand-conscious power users have been the mainstay of Palm’s business but, as they upgrade their machines, they are likely to move to the next cool thing. In the enterprise, Palm has made some powerful alliances, such as that with IBM Global Services, and like all PDA makers, it needs to pin its hopes on corporate deals for its handhelds. But IBM and all the big company suppliers are rapidly signing up smartphones too and Palm has yet to demonstrate enterprise quality voice and wireless capabilities.
More likely to make a successful transition from PDAs to smartphones are Dell and Hewlett Packard, the leading vendors of machines based on Microsoft PocketPC, or Windows Mobile as it is now called. Dell plans a smartphone version of its Axim product next year and HP has hinted at the same thing. These companies have the market weight and brand awareness to win enterprise contracts in their own right and also to appeal to the operators, particularly those that want to reduce their dependence on Nokia and Motorola. This is the strategy, of course, that Microsoft has pursued for its smartphone, but ironically it may be Dell that gets Windows into the carriers’ portfolio in a big way, but with a Windows Mobile device that makes Microsoft’s pure smartphone architecture redundant (see separate story).
We would never underestimate Dell’s ability to turn out well designed, well priced and enterprise-friendly devices but it will be well over a year behind the real smartphone makers, which will have spent that time not only establishing and enhancing their products ‘ which already look light years ahead of the conventional PDA in functionality and desirability ‘ but also cultivating their own enterprise connections and eking every ounce of advantage out of their influence over the operators.
And the companies coming at convergence from a heritage of voice are the ones with the booming market. According to IDC forecasts, smartphones will leapfrog their older rivals by the end of this year. PDAs will see an 8.4% drop in unit shipments to 11.35m this year, while smartphones will leap 260% to ship 13.1m. IDC expects a slight pick-up in PDA sales in 2004 on the back of better wireless support and low cost consumer models, but sales will be around 15m rather than the 20m previously predicted, as sales of non-wireless handhelds plummet more rapidly than anyone had foreseen a year ago.
In the second quarter, worldwide shipments of PDAs dropped by 7.3% year-on-year, IDC said, to 2.5m units. A sharp decline in the Chinese market and a poor global economy contributed to the dip. Palm retained its dominant market share of a failing market, with 51.4%, followed by PocketPC-based devices on 35.9% of units. However, the increasing dependence of Palm on low cost models was shown by its lower market share by revenue ‘ 41%, compared to 47.7% for PocketPCs.
Palm’s market share in its niche has been legendary, but Nokia is achieving similar percentages in its far broader territory. It is set fair to cross the 40% threshold in the global market, from about 37% now, and is likely to achieve 50% share in Europe in 2004. Estimates from Strategy Analytics point to an 11% growth in handset shipments next year, to 507m units, with the recent increase in Nokia’s CDMA business, and its smartphone successes, giving it 40% of that figure.
‘Europe has developed into a fortress for Nokia,’ said Strategy Analytics’ Chris Ambrosio and robust demand in western Europe helped the Finnish giant make market share gains against Motorola, which is more dependent on the weakened Asian region. Sony Ericsson is also increasing its volumes rapidly in Europe on the back of its P800 smartphone and its popular T610, but there must still be concerns over its potential to get into profit on market share of less than 7%.