Outdoor solutions for extending Wi-Fi’s range are the center of attention in 802.11x world this month, witness all the excitement about Airgo’s chipset last week (see Wi-Fi Watch issue 9). Three companies in this sector have raised investment in the past week, indicating where the venture capitalists’ interest is lying, but this is a high risk sector to invest in ‘ there are too many start-ups and shake-out is inevitable; they have to rely on their innovations becoming part of a standard in the future, which means playing a lot of politics with the big guns; and they will need to accommodate WiMAX if they are not to find their 802.11-based technologies marginalized.
These companies ‘ Airgo itself, Engim and WiDeFi ‘ join the grandfather of Wi-Fi extension, Vivato, and there are other pretenders creeping up behind them, such as Motia. But Vivato’s own troubles (see Wi-Fi Watch issue 9) illustrate the challenges that these companies will face making the transition from innovative start-up with some funding to long term competitor. Vivato virtually created this sector, certainly on the enterprise side, yet now it faces rivalry from more established companies ‘ wireless specialists like Proxim (see separate story) and, even more daunting, giants like Cisco. Now it seems that Vivato has made the classic pioneer’s mistake in trying to go up against the big names, relying to too heavily on its reputation for engineering expertise and not getting its hands dirty with strong sales and marketing. Its recent reorganization, under pressure from its investors, is designed to shift that balance.
Airgo, Engim, WiDeFi and others are less far along the curve but will face even greater challenges. They all have genuinely innovative technology but they do not even have the luxury that Vivato did a couple of years ago of having the sector to themselves for a while. They have to take on the large vendors from day one, and that means being several steps ahead technologically, winning support from influential suppliers and establishing their offerings as de facto standards through industry and user backing. Tough to do, and very few start-ups, if any, will succeed in that now that the Wi-Fi market is maturing.
For most, the best outcome will be to be acquired by a larger WLan supplier or to take their products more aggressively into the broadband wireless space, which will mean upgrading from souped-up or ‘mutant’ Wi-Fi to full WiMAX standards. The WiMAX market is less mature than its local area cousin’s, but it is filling up rapidly, so there is only a window of a year or so for the fast Wi-Fi specialists to make their mark here, but Engim and WiDeFi, among others, are already looking at ways to integrate their technologies into a WiMAX scene.
Engim
Engim’s focus is on speeding up Wi-Fi through multi-channel switching supported at chip level and it claims to be able to boost the capacity of WLan access points by up to 50 times. Last week, it raised $18.5m in second round funding and aims to expand into broadband wireless markets, potentially WiMAX.
The fabless chipmaker was set up in 2001 and made available the first samples of its EN-300 chipset in April. Current 802.11 access points have 11 non-overlapping channels of radio spectrum to use, but use only one at a time, with users taking turns. The Engim chipset can ‘see’ all 11 at once, using a technology called Wideband Spectral Processing, although the first chipset only enables three to be actually used at one time, trebling the performance of all variants of 802.11.
This multi-channel facility also enables features to be incorporated in silicon that are currently implemented, at extra cost and performance degradation, in software. There is risk of interference between the channels, which would reduce performance, though Engim claims this is minimized through the use of digital signal processing across the whole 802.11x spectrum.
The company, which was founded by a group of silicon design experts from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Motorola and Texas Instruments, raised its second round from Benchmark Capital, joined by Adams Street Partners, Matrix Partners and Bessemer Venture Partners.
WiDeFi
WiDeFi is also a fabless chipmaker creating Asics to boost the range of Wi-Fi using multiple channels ‘ claiming to double its range and performance for half the cost of mainstream solutions – although it is a couple of steps behind Engim. It raised its first funding, seed capital of $1.5m, last week to enable it to finish the reference design for its flagship product, WLan Extender and start development of the commercial chips. The round was led by CampVentures and Inflexion Partners, with Village Ventures and Band of Angels Fund contributing.
There are indoor and outdoor versions of WLan Xtender plus spin-off products such as P2P Xtender and Hotspot Xtender. They are basically repeaters operating on multiple frequency channels to boost performance. The indoor variant is targeted at providers of home and small business applications, particularly those that require Quality of Service, such as high definition television and voice over WLan, as it features a patent pending ‘zero jitter’ feature. It supports all three Wi-Fi standards but claims to double their range.
The outdoor technology comes in three versions ‘ for boosting performance of Wi-Fi point to point networks; for enhancing hotspots; and for full blown broadband wireless access (BWA) operators. For hotspots, it claims to be powerful enough to use 802.11a to link the hotspot to the central backhaul location, cutting backhaul costs by up to 50 times.
The most interesting aspect of WLan Xtender is the BWA option, which offers a cost effective method of covering the ‘last 100 feet’ between the BWA outdoor network and the end user. WiDeFi is particularly focusing on WiMAX operators, claiming that it will be far cheaper for them to deploy WiMAX for mass coverage but use enhanced Wi-Fi to deliver service to the customer. This is exactly how the WiMAX supporters see their standard coexisting with Wi-Fi and should put WiDeFi in good stead to take advantage of the growth in BWA based on standards-based kit.
Motia
Even further back than WiDeFi in the company lifecycle is Motia, which is still operating in stealth mode, but nevertheless attracting some attention for its 802.11 chipsets incorporating smart antenna technology, and some funding ‘ it has $5m in seed funding from Kodiak Venture Partners, Axiom Venture Partners and Carrot Capital. The company was founded in 2000 and has a chief scientist, Dr Jack Winters, out of AT&T Labs Wireless Research.
Like Airgo and Vivato, Motia relies on smart antenna to deliver its performance boost. In its case, although it will not reveal details until the autumn, it will follow the MIMO (multiple-in multiple-out) also adopted by Airgo, which involves applying smart antennas both to the access point and the clients. At the AP end, the use of multiple antennas provides increased range and capacity, at the client end, it reduces interference. MIMO uses huge amounts of computing power to send large numbers of signals from antennas placed close together, creating a cumulative effect that can transfer large quantities of data in and out.
The problem with smart antenna solutions at the moment is that they are not standards compliant. MIMO, in particular, though attracting serious interest from Intel, Nokia and other heavyweights, is not part of 802.11. That may be set to change and Motia certainly hopes to be part of smart antennas entering the mainstream, claiming it will only sell antennas that are compatible with 802.11 standard equipment. That may be a way down the road for MIMO products ‘ MIMO is not specifically included in the charter for 802.11n, the next generation of Wi-Fi. However, it could well be brought within the channel definition and, given the interest of the big vendors ‘ Intel is working on its own MIMO technology for instance ‘ is highly likely to be so. That would be a boost for all the smart antenna specialists, but would also hasten the shake-out that is surely looming for all the growing number of start-ups focused on Wi-Fi extension and linking Wi-Fi to WiMAX.