Operators are increasingly under fire for closing their handsets so that users can instal only pre-approved applications, which often have to be purchased from the carrier. The debate is already an issue that divides the Symbian community. The handset makers that control the operating system are keen to encourage free development of applications to increase the attraction of Symbian phones; but they also need to win operator support, and it is clearly in the interest of these companies to close their systems.
Throwing this issue into relief is Hutchison 3G, which has ‘locked’ the first Symbian phone for its ‘3’ UK network, the Motorola-built A920, announced last week (see Wireless Watch issue 26). This means that users and developers for the A920 cannot use applications written for other Symbian handsets, notably the Sony Ericsson P800, which also uses the UIQ user interface.
Hutchison is using the same justification that operators always trot out ‘ that by taking the ‘walled garden’ approach, they prevent the phone being opened up to illegal or corrupted applications, or to hackers. In truth, a far more powerful motivation for the operator is to maintain its differentiation against rival operators and keep control of its platform in order to push applications and services from which it can make most money.
Fine, but not entirely logical for an operator in such a weak position as 3. It might do better to attract users to its network on the basis that the A920 will have a broad range of applications available ‘ especially as many of these would come from the high profile and desirable P800, which has proved a major boost to the operators that carry it, notably Orange.
Orange itself was at the center of a similar row when it closed down the SPV smartphone. Initially, no developer could even test an application on an SPV until the software had been through an official certification authority, something that was a major deterrent to developers, especially those enthusiastic, open source-oriented individuals and start-ups that make up much of the handset developer community. Now, Orange has provided an unlock procedure to its developers, although it reserves the right to relock any SPV that it suspects is being used for other purposes than application creation.
T-Mobile is an even worse example of the failure to understand developer mentality in the smartphone market. In Europe, the company sells a version of the excellent Danger Hiptop device, which it calls the Sidekick, but it seems to be destroying the product’s chances of mass market success by insisting on highly restricted developer access. Under pressure from T-Mobile, Danger did not release a software developers’ kit at all for six months and then it was of very limited functionality and did not support Java.
The power of their network reach has always enabled operators to influence the handset makers in terms of features and applications, but the featurephones tip the balance further in their favour. Commissioning a customized smartphone, often from an OEM manufacturer rather than a household name, allows the carriers to make more profit from handsets by adding new paid-for value added features and services, and to differentiate their networks and reduce churn by offering unique hardware – not to mention reducing their much-resented dependence on the big phone makers.
But the only way that an operator will win customers to its network on the basis of its particular featurephone, let alone start to erode brand loyalty to Nokia, Sony Ericsson et al, is through innovative and appealing applications for consumers and ‘ though the operators have been slower than the handset makers to think this one through ‘ for enterprise deals.