Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 September 2012

Pandora could be prey, as counterweight to iTunes or Facebook ad network

As the big web players assemble their mobile armies, internet music firm Pandora is in the spotlight as a potential acquisition target. Its core music streaming and internet radio service is the focus, because Google, Facebook or others might buy this as a way to counter Apple’s expected launch of a rival service under its mighty iTunes banner. However, Pandora is also the US’s second largest mobile advertising network, after Google itself, and so could be attractive for that reason too, especially to Facebook, which is building up its mobile ad platform.

On the music side, Google and Amazon would be obvious contenders to pitch for Pandora as a countermove to Apple, which is reported to be readying its own service for later this year. According to Bloomberg, Pandora is predicted to increase its revenues by 214% over the next two years, almost three times the media rate for US internet media firms with values over $1bn. However, Pandora shares are down 34% since its IPO, so predators could get the pioneering firm at a good price and gain a strong brand, an established user base, and a weapon against Apple in mobile and streamed music.

Pandora has 150m registered users but its value has declined amid the Apple rumors. ‘When you look at the value of Pandora to another company, it’s the infrastructure they have created, it’s the advertising business, the success with mobile,’ John Rudolph of digital media investment bank Siemer & Associates told Bloomberg. ‘Pandora has such a big installed base and such a huge number of users, there’s value in that.’

iTunes has 64% of the US digital music market and 29% of all retail music sales in Q2, according to data from NPD, and online and mobile radio services are stealing market share and listener hours from traditional broadcasting and from downloads. Pandora is also said to generate more revenue from mobile advertising in the US than any firm apart from Google, with a projected 8.7% of that market this year.

Pundits are speculating on an acquisition price of about $20, though there are no guarantees for the lossmaking music firm. The potential bidders could also weaken Pandora by creating their own alternatives. Amazon, in particular, likes to build not buy, as seen in its launch of its own online video platform to compete with Netflix. However, this is not true of Facebook which is racing to catch up and to work out how to monetize its huge mobile traffic while converting a social network into a full media and communications platform. Pandora would add content and advertising ‘ both fledgling in the Facebook system. According to eMarketer, Facebook will have just 2.8% of the $2.61bn US mobile ad market this year, putting it in sixth place. Google dominates with about 55% predicted share, and in second and third place are Pandora Media and Twitter, though neither has double-digit share (Pandora will have 8.7% and Twitter 5%, say the analysts).

The social giant may finally be getting to grips with the challenges of making money out of its vast mobile traffic, or at least the markets seem to think so. The social networking firm’s confessed uncertainty about how to monetize mobile usage was a factor in the poor response to its IPO earlier this year, but its stock rose to its highest price in seven weeks on Wednesday, on news that it is preparing a service to place adverts in third party mobile apps.

Shares rose by 6.5% to $23.29 at the close, the highest level since July 27, with investors showing cautiously increased confidence in Facebook’s ability to create a viable mobile business model. Not that it is doing anything radical here, just chasing Google and Apple in creating an advertising network rather than just placing ads in its own applications, so boosting revenue potential and the scope to offer targeted promotions to users.

‘We view the reported launch of a mobile ad network as another signal that Facebook is moving aggressively to improve user monetization,’ Colin Sebastian, an analyst at Robert W Baird wrote in a client note quoted by Bloomberg. ‘Facebook has the potential to become a more relevant ad network than Yahoo and AOL, and to compete more directly with Google.’

Facebook needs to act quickly as more of its traffic shifts from PCs to mobile devices, which have far less advertising ‘real estate’ and less user tolerance for poorly targeted ads. It also runs the risk of falling behind, in functionality and credibility, as big names and start-ups include social networking in their services, often closely tied to location and presence awareness.

‘Showing mobile ads outside of Facebook is another great way for people to see relevant ads and discover new apps,’ Facebook said in a statement though it stressed that, at this stage, the new offering was part of a ‘small test’.