Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 September 2012

Apple’s LTE bands can shift carrier plans, but it needs to face up to fragmentation

A device with the sales potential of a new iPhone has a unique ability to influence carriers’ network strategies. Unlike Samsung, Apple remains fairly conservative about how many spectrum bands it supports, though it has made concessions to the fragmented state of LTE frequencies by making three iPhone 5 variants supporting a total of 10 LTE band/mode combinations. Its choice of frequencies immediately creates advantage for carriers with those same bands, and effectively a second tier of iPhone operators, those which will only be able to support it on 3G (T-Mobile USA, of course, is in a third tier of only being able to support the device unlocked). The appearance of an iPhone in the appropriate band may be a catalyst for an operator to kickstart or accelerate its 4G roll-out, since it will have a flagship device to lure users, and will need capacity to support the data-hungry product. Similarly, the lack of an iPhone could slow another carrier’s plans, though O2 ‘ which is in the ‘tier two’ position in the UK, insists there are plenty of other top notch devices, and its roll-out schedules will be unaffected (it just needs some 4G spectrum to use).

But while Apple can sway timescales for LTE, and boost or depress the fortunes of some cellcos, it has to make concessions too, and will increasingly need to be more catholic in its choice of frequencies, if it is to keep carriers onside, continue to build market share after the first rush of iPhone 5 orders, and avoid opening up gaps for Samsung to fill. So, while the iPhone 5’s support for 1.8GHz will certainly increase confidence in refarming that GSM band for LTE, and accelerate some efforts in that regard, Apple will need to create a version for the other main European frequencies, 2.6GHz and 800MHz, in short order as those networks start to build out.

For its inner circle of carriers- with AT&T still the closest of them all ‘ it is willing to be more flexible about band support. FCC documentation reveals there are two more bands hidden within the US GSM variant, the one tailored for AT&T. ExtremeTech has found that the US cellular and PCS bands, for 2G/3G are included as LTE options in the filings, even though no carrier is deploying 4G in these frequencies, except Sprint in PCS (but Sprint has a different version of the iPhone, with CDMA support). Analysts speculate that AT&T may be planning a more wholesale network modernization than expected, refarming 2G/3G spectrum at an early stage to add to its 700MHz and AWS roll-outs.

And while Apple has clearly been guided in its design choices by premier deals with certain key partners such as AT&T, EE and potentially DoCoMo, it will also seek market share by extending the new handset even to small cellcos, provided they have the same frequencies. Rather than keeping the iPhone 4S as its main offering for prepaid and regional operators, as many expected, it is making the new flagship available even in the first wave to these tier two players. For instance, Wisconsin carrier Cellcom will start selling the iPhone 5 on September 28, just a week after the US big three. It has an LTE network via Verizon’s Rural America program, though some other regional iPhone operators will only have 3G in place. Leap, C Spire. Appalachian Wireless and GCI will all get the new smartphone this month.

While 2.6GHz and 800MHz could reasonably be expected to appear in an additional iPhone model soon, other frequencies have less unified support around the world or a major region, creating a chicken and egg situation for carriers with spectrum in bands such as 900MHz or 3.5GHz ‘ both earmarked for LTE in future, but carrying the risk of a limited device ecosystem.

This inequality between the two GSM bands eligible for 4G refarming, 1.8GHz and 900MHz, is clearly seen in the UK, where Vodafone and Telefonica O2 have the lower band and Everything Everywhere has 1.8GHz (with some of that spectrum soon to be sold on to 3UK). Whether Apple and other key device makers will support LTE900 in the short term will be a critical decision factor for the 900MHz owners, as they mull whether to refarm this band for 4G in order to hit back against EE’s early LTE roll-out.

Vodafone and O2 reacted angrily when regulator Ofcom allowed EE to roll out 1.8GHz LTE before the UK’s auction of new 4G spectrum ‘ in 2.6GHz and 800MHz ‘ takes place. This is scheduled for next spring, but in the meantime the other cellcos have to watch EE gaining early adopter advantage onlhy increased by a de facto exclusive for the 4G iPhone 5. Their other option, as Ofcom sources indicated recently, would be to refarm some of their 900MHz holdings, but this has been seen as a difficult option. Although the sub-1GHz bands are strong for coverage and rapid roll-out, they have less capacity than 1.8GHz (considering that the LTE services will have to coexist with 2G for some time) and although some operators are deploying 4G in this spectrum, notably in the Middle East, a device ecosystem is developing more slowly than in 1.8GHz (as Apple’s iPhone choice indicates). That would increase costs and limit smartphone choice for the carriers.

EE and Ofcom, which greenlighted the EE plans because it wants to accelerate mobile broadband progress, hit back against criticism of the decision, saying there was nothing to stop the other cellcos applying to reuse 900MHz spectrum. Refarming 2G spectrum for 3G was permitted by a 2011 ruling and extending that to 4G is a minor amendment, Ofcom told Telecoms.com while EE’s CEO Olaf Swantee insisted 1.8GHz did not give his firm a significant advantage, and that more handsets were appearing for the lower band. The same arguments have been deployed in the row over whether Vodafone and O2 should have their ability to purchase 800MHz licences restricted, because they already have sub-1GHz holdings.

Bengt Nordstr’m, CEO of consultancy firm Northstream, commented in the same report: ‘My perception is that when you are on HSPA, you tend to use 2100MHz, but the coverage isn’t that great, so all operators are really dependent on the fallback to GSM/EDGE.’ That would leave insufficient space for LTE, which only makes sense if 10MHz to 20MHz is allocated. ‘I’m not sure how viable it really is for them to effectively free up enough 900MHz spectrum without really creating congestion in the GSM band,’ he added.

An O2 spokesperson told ZDnet: “Everything Everywhere claim we can ask to liberalize our own 900MHz spectrum for 4G, but as they know, there are no devices compatible with 4G on that band. There is such little 900MHz spectrum in Europe that it doesn’t make commercial sense for the manufacturers to build the handsets to support it, and that isn’t going to change.’ Rethink research among the device ecosystem indicates that OEMs are adding 900MHz LTE support, but the availability of models lags behind 1.8GHz by 12-18 months.

In the wake of the iPhone 5 launch, O2 is campaigning for earlier access to spectrum in the UK. The operator is reported to be in talks with UK regulator Ofcom, urging it to bring forward the much delayed 2.6GHz/800MHz auction. An O2 spokesman told Techworld: “Yes, we are in discussions to bring the timeline forward.” In theory, O2 could also refarm spectrum but its GSM band is 900MHz, where a 4G device ecosystem is far less developed than in 1.8GHz, while it would take years to clear its 2.1GHz 3G spectrum.

Meanwhile, the dilemma about 900MHz and its device ecosystem remains, and Apple is unlikely to shift the balance with an iPhone in this band any time soon. Even more distant, it seems, will be a TD-LTE model, despite persistent reports of collaboration with China Mobile. Even if a Chinese smartphone did appear, it would only support Mobile’s particular band plan. Other TDD operators, such as Clearwire in 2.5GHz and UK Broadband in 3.5GHz, claims many other major OEMs are now flocking to their unpaired spectrum, but by most estimates, they remain at least two years behind FD-LTE in terms of handset choice.

Deploying LTE in 3.5GHz is currently very rare, despite the best efforts of ZTE and Huawei, the most aggressive vendors in backing the option (Huawei supplies the UK Broadband network in London). The 3.5GHz band has been largely ignored by mobile operators because its short range makes it too expensive to deploy conventional cellular networks ‘ large numbers of base stations would have to be purchased, and issues like interference increase. However, it is well suited to small cells, and promises significant capacity which has been underused, outside of some fixed wireless services ‘ but is available on an almost global basis.

A new report from Maravedis-Rethink found, in a survey of over 60 mobile operators, that two-thirds of small cell base stations will be deployed in bands above 2.2GHz by 2016,
compared to fewer than 40% in 2013. The use of small cells in public 3G and 4G networks will increase the usage, and the value, of spectrum of 2.3GHz and above. A key motivation for carriers to invest in this technology will be the ability to free up the vast capacity in high bands for mobile services.

The band will also get a significant boost from US plans to open it up specifically for small cell use. FCC chairman Julius Genachowski will take formal steps this year to accomplish this. The spectrum is seen as relatively low hanging fruit in the Obama administration’s goal of opening up over 500MHz of new broadband spectrum, and could support near-global roaming.

However, the FCC wants to accelerate the opening up of the band by making carriers share the spectrum with incumbent government users. The plan is part of the agency’s goal of allocating 100MHz specifically for small cells, to create a dense layer of additional mobile capacity. However, while the government thinks it will be simpler to offer the frequencies without forcing existing federal users to move, carriers are suspicious of sharing.

The issue gained profile when PCAST (the President’s Council of Advisors on Policy and Technology) put forward controversial proposals earlier this year to clear as much as 1000MHz of spectrum for mobile broadband ‘ more than in the official National Broadband Plan roadmap. PCAST is heavily focused on opening up formerly inaccessible bands by encouraging sharing with government bodies.

Announcing plans to kick off the process of using 3.5GHz for cellular use before year end, Genachowski did not mention sharing with the current radar applications , but the Ars Technica website confirmed with the FCC that this was the intention. That will provoke criticism from the carriers, whose industry group, the CTIA, has said sharing will create more problems than it solves. Much depends on where the radar systems are located, and at what times they are active, which will decide how easily they can coexist with small cells.

Processes of refarming spectrum or sharing with incumbents are non-trivial and in some cases will limit performance and capacity potential compared to virgin spectrum ‘ but the latter is too scarce to support mobile data loads alone, so operators and their suppliers are investing heavily in techniques to make sharing more practical. Apple is doing its bit for refarmed bands by favouring them in its iPhones over some of the uncluttered frequencies, but by the time ‘iPhone 6’ arrives, it will have to be supporting most of the LTE options, even 3.5GHz and TDD< in order to attract every market share opportunity in a fragmented world. Please contact [email protected] for more information, or an executive summary, of Maravedis-Rethink's new report, 'Transforming the Mobile Data Network: Operator strategies for profitable small cell networks 2012-2016'. iPhone 5's LTE bands: The three iPhone variants for now include two GSM/EDGE/ HSPA(+) combinations, one for AT&T (and the Canadian majors), supporting AWS and Lower 700MHz; the other international in focus ' but with an idiosyncratic selection of LTE bands, namely 2.1GHz, 1.8GHz and 850MHz, but not the main European bands, 2.6GHz and 800MHz. The most internationally available LTE frequency range, 2.5GHz/2.6GHz, is ignored, meaning that most of the early European movers are excluded, including all the major French and German LTE carriers and the original LTE operator, TeliaSonera. 2.1GHz is the main global 3G frequency, but one in which very few carriers have shown interest for LTE refarming, at least in the near term. However, it is used by Japan's NTT DoCoMo. The CDMA model appears to be the 'worldphone', supporting several international bands as well as Verizon's and Sprint's (the line-up is 2.1GHz, 1.8GHz, 850MHz, Upper 700MHz and the expanded 1.9GHz band). This combination seems mainly geared to KDDI in Japan, the biggest non-US CDMA iPhone vendor, as well as Korea.